Out: Moloney. In: Goddard???

[Sir Why You Little 35,223]

Hahaha people who say they don't want Goddard. Wake up will you...

If there is any chance of getting him...just do it. We already blew the chance of Ball.

Cripes how many chances sit under your nose?

Goddard is better than 95% of our list as it stands.

[Tony Tea 2,792]

Why plump for Moloney / Goddard when I'm sure Carlton would agree to Moloney / Judd & Murphy?

</sarc off>

[jimmy sandral 6]

Goddard has been a champion player at St Kilda and his best form would be great for us.

However, this season he has become moody and angry with his team mates which doesn't look good on the field. This has affected his ability to contribute to his team.

He might well regain his form, especially under Ross Lyon. With our luck this year he'd be paid a fortune and contribute SFA.

[melbfc2013 5]

is there any chance we could trade players (eg rivers, gysberts & or any draft pics) to get vardy from the cats?

i heard they need a defender to replace scarlett and that the cats have expressed some interest in developing gysberts.

was hoping we would draft him a few years back, but instead we went for gawn and fitzpatrick, who both have had thier injury troubles but dont really look like natural footballers, and often look awkward playing.

i know he has had an injury trouble, but i think vardy would be an excelent inclusion into our forward line, and would be handy as a back up ruckman. at 198cm he moves exceptionally well, has good attack on the ball, is a solid grab, a good shot on goal, and for a young KPP has a real presence.

Not sure of his situation at the cats, is there any chance they would let him go or that we could grab him?

[rpfc 27,662]

Goddard would come in as our 3rd best player so yeah...we could use him.

[Brayshaw Self 847]

I wasn't keen on getting Goddard initially but I have warmed to the idea. I thought his poor body language and lack of application in recent times would be costly if we forked out big coin to lure him but I think under Neeld he would work harder and a fresh environment and added responsibility could encourage him to work hard and teach our kids. It would obviously be good to have a player from a successful organisation and we have a huge amount of cap space now so we need to splurge to even reach the 92% TPP cap. I think we should get him. God knows we need the class and experience.

[dazzledavey36 49,582]

has reached an agreement with freo and will be announced in the next couple of weeks.

no chance

[3Dee 1,153]

Please throw everything towards getting BJ. He would look good in red and blue.

[Geddy Lee 582]

has reached an agreement with freo and will be announced in the next couple of weeks.

no chance

Good. Don't want.

[Robbie57 1,996]

has reached an agreement with freo and will be announced in the next couple of weeks.

no chance

Is this an old post about Clark?

I would love to do that to them again. Simply put it would be negligent not to try for someone of his talent.

He is clearly unhappy at his current club and its time to go. We should go for it.

[Hardnut 327]

Goddard - no way.

IMO - he wouldn't be interested, he's too old for the time it's going to take to possibly rescue our club from the current mess, and what price would we have to pay in whatever form?

Forget it.

[Sir Why You Little 35,223]

Goddard - no way.

IMO - he wouldn't be interested, he's too old for the time it's going to take to possibly rescue our club from the current mess, and what price would we have to pay in whatever form?

Forget it.

Things can turn around quickly with the right cattle.

Go after him hard. We have $$$ to spend.

[tonatopia 278]

Please throw everything towards getting BJ. He would look good in red and blue.

He is exactly the person we need. He is a beast who almost won a premiership for the saints with his accomplice Hayes. The most incredible performance I have seen 2 men put on a football field. it was like Lenny and Goddard vs Collingwood. Awesome stuff.

Goddard can play centre, FF, CHF, CHB, FB. He can almost play any position.

He is 27, and would set an even stronger example than Clarke.

He IS the man, and if we dont throw Rivers, Moloney, Martin and Jurrah's, combined wage towards him, we are not doing our due dilligence.

[Hardnut 327]

Things can turn around quickly with the right cattle.

Go after him hard. We have $$$ to spend.

Come on WYL - you know he's not suitable for MFC at this time.

We do have $ to spend, but we must get value for money - not just throw it at anyone who looks remotely good!

[Devo 104]

He isn't coming to Melbourne. He doesn't have the time to sit through an epic rebuild at MFC. He wants to be in contention for a flag. Going to Freo would put him in a good position to do that. Ross is creating a pretty fearsome unit at Freo and they will do some damage in the years to come. Good golf courses for BJ in Perth too.

[old dee 23,122]

He isn't coming to Melbourne. He doesn't have the time to sit through an epic rebuild at MFC. He wants to be in contention for a flag. Going to Freo would put him in a good position to do that. Ross is creating a pretty fearsome unit at Freo and they will do some damage in the years to come. Good golf courses for BJ in Perth too.

I think you are right on the money Devo.

As much as I might like him it won't happen.

It is Freo or St.Kilda certainly not the Dees

[Sir Why You Little 35,223]

Come on WYL - you know he's not suitable for MFC at this time.

We do have $ to spend, but we must get value for money - not just throw it at anyone who looks remotely good!

Goddard remotely good...are you serious or talking as a clown?

[Cheesy D. Pun 1,762]

It's pretty obvious from Neelds statements that we will be going after some senior bodies. I for one am sick of this "won't be part of our next premiership" stuff. We need senior bodies to bring through the guys that WILL be a part of this supposed "next premiership", otherwise we'll never get there.

Exactly. You've got to have mentors in place.

[Hardnut 327]

He isn't coming to Melbourne. He doesn't have the time to sit through an epic rebuild at MFC. He wants to be in contention for a flag. Going to Freo would put him in a good position to do that. Ross is creating a pretty fearsome unit at Freo and they will do some damage in the years to come. Good golf courses for BJ in Perth too.

Devo has nailed it WYL.

Please quote me in context - not just one post, ignoring the previous one.

If MFC survives this current crisis, it's going to take years to repair the damage done by Neeld and co. Goddard won't be around by then.

I'm reading a lot of D/land rubbish about trading for good players from other clubs (eg getting Vardy from Geelong - as if they would give him away, let alone that he wouldn't even dream of coming to MFC) - time to get real, we have been put below the new clubs by this year's efforts. Our only way out, thanks to Neeld and co's lack of political nous, is to draft young and hope someone else will come to the club to coach them well, if we can keep them!

I'm a glass half-full person and this is how I see the mess!

[BIG JIM 508]

Devo has nailed it WYL.

Please quote me in context - not just one post, ignoring the previous one.

If MFC survives this current crisis, it's going to take years to repair the damage done by Neeld and co. Goddard won't be around by then.

I'm reading a lot of D/land rubbish about trading for good players from other clubs (eg getting Vardy from Geelong - as if they would give him away, let alone that he wouldn't even dream of coming to MFC) - time to get real, we have been put below the new clubs by this year's efforts. Our only way out, thanks to Neeld and co's lack of political nous, is to draft young and hope someone else will come to the club to coach them well, if we can keep them!

I'm a glass half-full person and this is how I see the mess!

I think your a glass full of

[demoniac 1,246]

Guys have you actually looked at our list recently. Moloney gone. Davy wouldn't be on big money anymore.

We literally have no one to pay.

If we don't land a big fish this trade period, guys like Garland will be paid $800k just to pay somebody to get to 92%

Davey is in the last year of a lucrative contract in 2013 so unless we frontloaded he will be on big money in 2013.

Space in cap will open up with departures of Moloney and Jurrah. Have to guesstimate what they were on but of it was $400,000 for Moloney and $200,000 for Jurrah then thats $600,000 space now available in cap going forward.

In terms of the making the minimum 92.5% of the cap the club does not need to pay Garland $800,000 they can simply bring forward part of 2014 contracts to 2013 thus creating more room in the cap in 2014.