Travis Boak

[Mono 454]

Terrible deal for St Kilda if that actually happened.

Depends; Goddard is free agent so maybe better to trade than sweat on AFL compensation offered.

Carlton salary cap?

For starters McLean is out of contract ($350k) as is Warnock (I think; $400k). On the face of it, that frees up lots of $s.

Goddard is a free agent. Why would Carlton bother trading for him?

That alone makes me discount the whole scenario.

Hmmm.....good point. Depends if Goddard wants to do the right thing by the saints.

[Thrice 216]

Forgot, Goddard is an unrestricted free agent isn't he? ... Cause if he just tried to walk the origonal club can just match the offer?

Unrestricted Free Agents can just walk. It's only for a Restricted Free Agent that the original club can match the offer.

[jnrmac 19,324]

Hmmm.....good point. Depends if Goddard wants to do the right thing by the saints.

Hasn't Goddard already committed to the Aints?

[Mono 454]

Forgot, Goddard is an unrestricted free agent isn't he?

Having said that I'm not sure how that works re: trading an unrestricted free agent. It'd be the same as trading a contracted player wouldn't it? Cause if he just tried to walk the origonal club can just match the offer?

Will be interesting to see how St. Kilda go this off season. Lack of ruckmen and key defenders with aging midfielders and KPF. Wouldn't love to be in their position...

Nope, unrestricted means original club can't just match the offer and keep him. Indeed, a player can go to another club for less $s, but wants to have a crack at a premiership (for example).

[Roger Mellie 3,601]

Russell and Carltanks first round pick to Port Adelaide.

Yuck - I cant see Port going for that but I love a good rumour

Edited July 6, 2012 by Roger Mellie

[Hannibal 5,814]

Pick 4 is likley to be involved in any trade for a very good player like Boak or Beams. We'd want something in return though. That's where 4 + 13 for Boak + 7 comes in - someone else thought of that before me.

I will be gutted if they trade pick 4.

Tbh, I don't think they're that stupid.

[MadAsHell 4,089]

Unrestricted Free Agents can just walk. It's only for a Restricted Free Agent that the original club can match the offer.

Nope, unrestricted means original club can't just match the offer and keep him. Indeed, a player can go to another club for less $s, but wants to have a crack at a premiership (for example).

My bad, I meant to say restricted free agent, not unrestricted.

It's my understanding that he's a restricted free agent. And if that is the case, it means there is still some trade value there yeah?

[old55 21,638]

I will be gutted if they trade pick 4.

Depends who it's for and whether we get Viney in the 2nd round so still have 3.

I don't really see enough of Boak to rate him but he's an established early pick.

Jack Martin for 3, Boak, pick 7 and Viney could be a reasonable outcome

[Hannibal 5,814]

Depends who it's for and whether we get Viney in the 2nd round so still have 3.

I don't really see enough of Boak to rate him but he's an established early pick.

Jack Martin for 3, Boak, pick 7 and Viney could be a reasonable outcome

I am concerned by reports that we're actively looking to trade for other clubs players; and I have heard that Neeld doesn't want to draft too many young players as he thinks the game is getting harder and harder for young players, but I'll be terribly disappointed if we give up picks 3 or 4. I reckon Viney will be drafted with our second round pick and I'd rather young gun mids at 3 and 4 than Boak. Like you, I just haven't seen enough of Toumpas, etc, but my gut tells me that I'd rather Toumpas than Boak.

Martin looks like he'll be a freak, but I wouldn't want to give up 3 or 4 for him a year early.

There will always be supporters that worry about getting another Morton at 4, but I don't roll like that. I assume we'll get it right and the top end talent in this draft looks terrific, even if the idea of it being a superdraft is being watered down. Having the choice of the entire field after the first two picks appeals greatly. I want A graders. Boak may become one, but right now he's a B grader and I find it unfathomable having now watched a few games of the champs that we'd give up pick 4 on a player that's presently B grade.

I'd just about give up.

Edited July 7, 2012 by Ben-Hur

[Guest José Mourinho]

I think we have just as much chance getting the player we want with pick 7 as pick 4, but I still think it's a long shot that it would happen.

And even if St Kilda could engineer some sign-and-trade deal with Goddard, why would they do it for scraps, when they could let him go as an unrestricted free agent and get a better return (likely equivalent compo to what we got for Scully, or close to it)?

More importantly, why would the club signing him agree to give up anything when they could just sign him for free?

Why would Goddard want to weaken his new club by making them trade pieces out?

[Green Machine 63]

Anyone thinking about trying to get Beams should forget it. He is a fair weather footballer.

I'm not too sure what Boak is like, but from what I have seen a few years back, he seemed explosive and penetrating.

[dee-luded 2,958]

Current rumor going around work at the moment, and if true it means we wont get Boak.

Rumor going around is that Port Adelaide, Geelong, St. Kilda & Carlton have already struck an in principle agreement that will see Boak go to Geelong, Dawson Simpson & the Ablett compensation pick go to St. Kilda, Goddard go to Carlton and Russell and Carltanks first round pick to Port Adelaide. Discussion of swapping lower picks ongoing.

Don't know how reliable, but that's what I've heard today. I hate to say it, but this is a friend of a friend scenario.

That sounds very detailed & believable. It's bit too intricate for most IMO to imagine up. This detail would take a lot of discussion.

I believe it.

Edited July 9, 2012 by dee-luded

[Dee1987 277]

That sounds pretty stupid, highly doubt Port would let Boak go for that both our picks will be higher than theirs. Plus Boak would earn bigger coin at Melbourne than Geelong. If we want class we must give up something Melbourne must stop being tight and get the best.

[dee-luded 2,958]

That sounds pretty stupid, highly doubt Port would let Boak go for that both our picks will be higher than theirs. Plus Boak would earn bigger coin at Melbourne than Geelong. If we want class we must give up something Melbourne must stop being tight and get the best.

We'd have to make him want to come to Us. Otherwise we have NO Hope.

Our biggest weapon Is $$$$$$$$$$

I think Carltank are on an all out a$$ault to get another Flag from the next 3 $eason$, & will stop at nothing to get it done.

They are the ones we need to stop.

[Grand New Flag 3,226]

I understand that Boak has probably played his last game for Port. Boak apparently performed poorly in interviews after Port was beaten badly in the SA derby. On several occasions he was asked to confirm his loyalty but all he did was confirm he has his eyes on Melbourne clubs. He could only muster "I'm happy playing here at the moment", and said many other things suggesting he had made a decision to leave.

I also understood that Boak has a foot injury that requires surgery and would prefer to leave the club now, have surgery and be back ready for day 1 of pre-season training with his new club.

Port now see the chances of Boak staying as zero and it is likely Primus will ask him to clean out his locker this week.

Boak has made it clear he wants to move back to Melbourne for "family reasons" preferably to Geelong. However, Port owes Boak nothing and will thus take the highest bidder of any Victoria based club.

Melbourne are in a position to offer far more than any other club to both in terms of picks to Port and financially to Boak should we decide he is our man.

[Guest Spirit of 39]

I'm not sure where you got your mail from but it is simply not correct. Go to the Port website and watch the said interview. Not much else he could have said under the circumstances. And to say he owes Port nothing??? Well nothing can be further from the truth. If he decides to leave he will ensure that they are looked after.

http://www.afl.com.a...78/default.aspx

Boak's teammates are confident he will stay. Time will tell.

[Range Rover 1,935]

Boak's teammates are confident he will stay.

Now where have I heard that before?

He's gone. Hopefully we make a decent play for him. Pick 13 and Tapscott would be a fair-ish deal.

[Guest Spirit of 39]

Now where have I heard that before?

He's gone. Hopefully we make a decent play for him. Pick 13 and Tapscott would be a fair-ish deal.

Read the attached link. Boak was grilled at dinner last night by the Port boys. Jackson Trengove said in his presser this morning that he thought Boak would end up staying. Probably a bit optimistic, but far from bags being packed by the end of the week as was stated in the opening post.

http://www.afl.com.a...78/default.aspx

Edited July 9, 2012 by Spirit of 39

[Dr. Gonzo 22,629]

Posted that link on one of the other threads, despite what they say he is gone, only issue is where. We can offer money and reasonable trade so should be in the box seat (or at least get involved in a 3-way trade).

[Red N Blue Society 165]

If he doesnt want to play for us then I couldnt care less what he does.

He's possibly another Scully who lies to his club...

Theres many factors as to why he doesnt want to say anything to Port....

1) If he says he's leaving Port.... chances are they wont play him....and he will be crucified..This isnt rugby where they dont give a sh&% about players leaving. AFL is full of passion with supporters.

2) If leaving is the case they wont play him & he wont get game time.

3) If he doesnt get game time he will lose match payments & match fitness & value as a player..

4) If he says he's leaving before being out of contract.... then Port will trade him where they see fit...he will have no say in it. (Correct me if I am wrong)

5) If he shuts up until he is out of contract he can go where he wants in the draft(Correct me if I am wrong also)

6) If he continues to be quiet on the issue his honesty/integrity will be questioned by all just like Scully...do we want another dishonest player at MFC even if he wants to come to us....just for the $$$???

I'm not a fan of him really, so I dont really pine for a player like him...I want a midfielder who is a star not an average good player like Boak.

In saying that I would take him but not for a massive coin contract...so I hope the Demons do their homework first..

[Range Rover 1,935]

Read the attached link. Boak was grilled at dinner last night by the Port boys. Jackson Trengove said in his presser this morning that he thought Boak would end up staying. Probably a bit optimistic, but far from bags being packed by the end of the week as was stated in the opening post.

http://www.afl.com.a...78/default.aspx

Unfortunately the 'system' forces players to conceal things from all but the closest people to them and their manager.

Scully's bags were packed in Nov, 2010 despite the offerings of Jones, Trengove, Blease and co throughout 2011.

Surely we are all grown up enough that people can feel they can speak the truth. Ridiculous.

[dee-luded 2,958]

I understand that Boak has probably played his last game for Port. Boak apparently performed poorly in interviews after Port was beaten badly in the SA derby. On several occasions he was asked to confirm his loyalty but all he did was confirm he has his eyes on Melbourne clubs. He could only muster "I'm happy playing here at the moment", and said many other things suggesting he had made a decision to leave.

I also understood that Boak has a foot injury that requires surgery and would prefer to leave the club now, have surgery and be back ready for day 1 of pre-season training with his new club.

Port now see the chances of Boak staying as zero and it is likely Primus will ask him to clean out his locker this week.

Boak has made it clear he wants to move back to Melbourne for "family reasons" preferably to Geelong. However, Port owes Boak nothing and will thus take the highest bidder of any Victoria based club.

Melbourne are in a position to offer far more than any other club to both in terms of picks to Port and financially to Boak should we decide he is our man.

IF, I hear what I think your saying, then Only, (Mid1st Rnd Pick) + 600$$$$$$$-00's,,, + a Player of some standing if required?

Not our Top Picks (3 & 4), at all !!!

[Grand New Flag 3,226]

I'm not sure where you got your mail from but it is simply not correct. Go to the Port website and watch the said interview. Not much else he could have said under the circumstances. And to say he owes Port nothing??? Well nothing can be further from the truth. If he decides to leave he will ensure that they are looked after.

http://www.afl.com.a...78/default.aspx

Boak's teammates are confident he will stay. Time will tell.

What else are Port going to say publically? I can confirm that Port are seriously considering asking him to clear his locker this week. Jackson Trengrove and other players are right to cross examine Boak after his interesting public performance post the match. Don't really think you can go on what is said in an internal Port Adelaide interview posted on their website. Personally I beleive everything I read on the internet!!!!!!! Not.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Get him!

Proven goal kicking midfielder who would thrive from the hard work of Magner and McKenzie.

Did I mention he was proven? Whilst the kids this year in the draft may look good, remind me how our history of using high draft picks has turned out again..

We need mature age, plug and play. Boak is that. If we can get it done with our mid first round and a player, do it. If not pick 4 wouldn't bother me.

[Guest Spirit of 39]

What else are Port going to say publically? I can confirm that Port are seriously considering asking him to clear his locker this week. Jackson Trengrove and other players are right to cross examine Boak after his interesting public performance post the match. Don't really think you can go on what is said in an internal Port Adelaide interview posted on their website. Personally I beleive everything I read on the internet!!!!!!! Not.

So you'll understand if we take what you say with a grain of salt...

I personally believe Boak will come back to Victoria. This situation has Scully written all over it. But I'd be hugely surprised if he didn't see the season out. And even more surprised if Travis didn't ensure that Port were looked after in terms of a trade. He seems like a loyal young man who is wants to return home, but will find it hard to leave his teammates.