David Schartz on SEN at 4.20pm today

[Hells Gates 505]

For those that missed it.

David Schwarz - http://www.sen.com.au/audioplayer/Audio/David-Schwarz-on-Melbournes-Poor-Form/4663

[Sir Why You Little 35,171]

Just heard the Ox's podcast on the SEN Website.

I AGREE OX. WELL SAID.

[Guest José Mourinho]

He also said Sylvia should be traded...said he likes Col, but he just doesnt like hard work.

Now where have I heard that before on this forum..?

[bush demon 1,920]

PPS I would just like to add that I hadn't noticed you spelt Schwarta in that fashion, and it wouldn't have bothered me anyway. I for one think that spelling is very important and don't know why it gets such bad press on these boards.

ok (edit) back to the drawing board:

"You say Schwarta, and I say Schworta,

you say Maloney, I say Moloney,

Maloney, Moloney,

Rigoni

"Ragoni"

Let's call the whole thing off

Let's call the whole thing off"

Apologies, George Gershwin and Norm Smith's curse

PS The Ox is patient.

Edited May 21, 2012 by bush demon

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Just a guy who could win a one on four contest for the Demons on sh!t money and one knee and never ever complain about the privilege of being paid to do so .

It was a tongue-in-cheek comment about the spelling of his name, not questioning the man himself.

[old dee 23,118]

PPS I would just like to add that I hadn't noticed you spelt Schwarta in that fashion, and it wouldn't have bothered me anyway. I for one think that spelling is very important and don't know why it gets such bad press on these boards.

Bush demon I think spelling is important.

It may be because it is I think my biggest failure in life.

I have improved over the years but I still make errors.

90% of my edits are because I notice a spelling error after I have posted.

The other 10% is grammer.

Oh how I would love to be able the spell well.

My saving grace in reason years is "spell check" ( which I cannot use on Demonland )

Try harder guys it is important

Good communication is I believe a corner stone of civilization

Here ends the sermon!

[Real Demon 232]

I liked what Ox said, and his passion.

As said earlier, echoed the sentiments of many members.

[diesel 420]

He pretty much nailed it for me.

And it is not a case of yet another media commentator giving an opinion, that's silly.

It is an opinion from someone who lived the MFC when it was nomadic with 3rd rate facilities and who well knows through injuries and personal mismanagement how opportunites can be wasted or taken away.

[Rogue 585]

"You say Schwarta, and I say Schworta,

you say Maloney, I say Moloney,

Maloney, Moloney,

Rugoni

"Ragoni"

Let's call the whole thing off

Let's call the whole thing off"

Apologies, George Gershwin.

Pretty great that you didn't spell Rigoni's name correctly either time.

[Dr. Gonzo 22,692]

I'm in two minds about this.

On one hand I agree with the frustration show by all MFC supporters (both public and private figures) and think the laziness and sense of entitlement of the senior players is a legacy from prior coaches and administrations. I think the senior players need a big boot up their arse and a few (most?) of them should be on the chopping block at the end of the year.

On the other hand though (and something I've only really considered over the last couple of days) I think we have to bear in mind the training load the new FD is making the players go through where they are basically continuing to do pre-season work throughout the season in order to get their fitness levels up for 2013 and beyond. If they are doing heavy mid-week sessions when other clubs are resting and recuperating then I think it is no wonder that they look lacklustre and as though they are not trying on game day.

If they are training heavily I don't think this is a bad thing as we definitely have a legacy of lack of fitness with the playing group.

However if they are being bashed from pillar to post by all and sundry (including media, supporters and former players) and are getting belted on the field every week then I can see the players losing confidence in Neeld and the FD very shortly. Basically they are having their legs taken out from them by the FD and then left to cop all the flak.

I don't think there is a real answer as I think it is a necessary evil for the club to go through in order to get up to "elite" standards however having former players and supporters all sticking the boot in certainly won't do anything to help the situation.

[bush demon 1,920]

Pretty great that you didn't spell Rigoni's name correctly either time.

Well, for your info. I thought, it was 'Rugoni' but in the spirit of my lyrics you miss the point anyway. Frankly.

[Guest]

Spot on Mighty Demon.

Ox not only nailed it - he was all over it.

He is a Demon fan like the rest of us. We all have aspirations for our team and it hurts when we witness the capitulations that we have had this year. The very least we can expect is that they play for their coaches and show endeavour. It's OK if they lose games because of inexperience or ability but we want and demand honesty in their performance. Our season is gone. What remains is an opportunity to see who really wants to play for this club into the future. Off to the McGoo's for those that don't.

[Bitter but optimistic 21,560]

Whatever else might be said about "Ox" he played with a passion for the club. He does not deserve to be derided in any way. I just wish a few of the blokes who are currently being paid megabucks had a portion of his guts.

[DeeSpencer 23,567]

It's time for our footballers who are running around like they are in the under 12's to be treated that way.

If I was coaching at half time I would have simply swapped the midfielders and the forwards. Why complain about Sylvia but do nothing about him. A couple of quarters at full back would be a start, and if it meant we could move Bartram from a position where the ball goes and hide him in the forward pocket like the dud kid in under 12's that would be a win as well.

[deeflog 679]

Do we need a new thread every time someone voices their opinion?

By the way, who is David Schartz?

do we really need to highlight every time someone makes a spelling mistake?

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

PS ... should be 'elitist'.

LOL - give me a break, ive got a migraine...

[Range Rover 1,935]

Just a guy who could win a one on four contest for the Demons on sh!t money and one knee and never ever complain about the privilege of being paid to do so .

Post of the Year.

[Je Roos Salem 661]

David Schwarz is a real person, a real media commentator and as good a person to come out of the club as there is. Was a fantastic player and my favourite as a young kid. Well done Ox you are spot on with these comments

[jumbo returns 6,596]

Bush demon I think spelling is important.

It may be because it is I think my biggest failure in life.

I have improved over the years but I still make errors.

90% of my edits are because I notice a spelling error after I have posted.

The other 10% is grammer.

Oh how I would love to be able the spell well.

My saving grace in reason years is "spell check" ( which I cannot use on Demonland )

Try harder guys it is important

Good communication is I believe a corner stone of civilization

Here ends the sermon!

Grammer......err grammar.

Oh, I see what you did!

[old dee 23,118]

Grammer......err grammar.

Oh, I see what you did!

Not very clever am I jumbo you picked it up straight away

But then again I do support the Dees

That probably explains a lot

[deestar 159]

The Ox was my favorite player as a boy ! If he stayed sound the football world wouldn't be lording Wayne Carey is the best ever it would have been the Ox !!

Agree with him 100% !! If I could pull on the red and blue jumper I'd run through a brick wall if I had to. We don't have to accept this !!

The Ox should address the players !! Id sure love to !!

Well said .... U hope the club is taking note of the goings on on demonland this week.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Personally Id prefer to see a new thread on the comments of people who actually played the game and who know people in the club or who have had an association with the club, than more illinformed 'sack the coach/administration' cycles, but that's just me. especially when that opinion is given with such passion.

People are so precious about surname spelling. If thats the best way to invalidate a comment then no wonder the outside world view MFC supporters as elitest.

Like I said he has said nothing new and its just fodder. And I dont think its a choice between rehashed criticism of the Club and sack the coach threads.

I am glad you are so enamored with the comments of a person whose name you cant spell Nrom Simth. Oops now there I go.

PS ... should be 'elitist'.

Doh LOL.

My response was in relation to his obvious frustration at the opportunities afforded others - do I get a warning point?

No just an education. Comments on his troubled past had nothing to do with his right to express a reasonable criticism of current players.

I for one think that spelling is very important and don't know why it gets such bad press on these boards.

When you want to grandstand on a person's comments the least you can do is get his name right. But I am glad you believe it is important.

[jumbo returns 6,596]

Not very clever am I jumbo you picked it up straight away

But then again I do support the Dees

That probably explains a lot

Join the Club

[Nasher 33,187]

By the way, who is David Schartz?

Watch the movie "Along Came Polly" for an explanation of Schartz.

[Rogue 585]

The Ox was my favorite player

Me too.

I'm posting this because there's no way this could be posted too often:

No just an education. Comments on his troubled past had nothing to do with his right to express a reasonable criticism of current players.

This is the post you replied to:

David had so many problems to overcome and he can't believe the opportunities some blokes have been given, considering his career was so cruelly curtailed.

I don't see that jumbo's post was necessarily about Schwarz's 'foibles', as you call them, since you could certainly argue that Schwarz had enough to overcome with his injuries and his Dad etc.

Even if Schwarz's 'foibles' were part of what jumbo was referring to I don't see that it was deriding Schwartz.