Tom Scully in September ...

[beelzebub 23,198]

Nup. It's for the money and the money only.

and Ive got absolutely no real problem with that as far as it goes. His life..his job.. his income. No problem.

Its all the rest Ive issue with.

But..... its nearly there....we can soon get on with a more unified approach to supporting Melbourne

add.

I wont be grieving personally.. I actually see it as a fresh chance to get value out of the pick.. Thats Pick 1 two goes ago. I think in essence we were totally dudded but we might come out of this ok in the end.

Edited September 8, 2011 by belzebub59

[daisycutter 29,317]

Yep, it never ceases to amaze me the amount of ignorance there is when it comes to perceptions of Sydney's western suburbs; for example, this whole Blacktown/Falafel connection (saw it used in here a few pages back)... apart from the racist overtones, I think when Eddie said it, he was probably confusing Blacktown with Bankstown (where there is a large mid-eastern population), yet people still persist with it here. Go figure.

hardtack, people are persisting with the Eddie/Blacktown/Falafel connection not because its true but its fun to take the pizz out of the TS thread saga which would have to be one of Demonland's worst most boring threads ever

If you didn't catch-on then you need to ramp up your sarcasm detector

[s-t-i-n-g-a 439]

Think about the players that have gone to GWS so far, two come from clubs that have lost or sacked their coaches and one from a club that seems to no longer need him and then you have Scully. Any decent player from any decent club has told them to [censored] off.

And amongst all of this Trengove signed on for another 4 years...

[Goodvibes 3,596]

And amongst all of this Trengove signed on for another 4 years...

Yeah but Trengove comes from South Australia - he would have signed on with the Baghdad Beavers for another four years.

Edited September 8, 2011 by Goodvibes

[hardtack 10,400]

hardtack, people are persisting with the Eddie/Blacktown/Falafel connection not because its true but its fun to take the pizz out of the TS thread saga which would have to be one of Demonland's worst most boring threads ever

If you didn't catch-on then you need to ramp up your sarcasm detector

You're right DC... I made that comment with a vague recollection of the falafel reference but forgot the context. My mistake and apologies.

Edited September 8, 2011 by hardtack

[Roost It 1,434]

Even if that sweeping generalisation was true, it doesn't mean that EVERY SINGLE THING the club does is crap - which is the picture that the woebegones paint.

"on the most part"

[Jack7 521]

Nathan Jones just said on 3aw that he saw Tom at the club today and Gerard said Tom has changed his travel plans to attend our B & F.

Clutching @ straws aren't we

[Roost It 1,434]

He should have done it already. He's seriously taking the [censored] if he thinks that anyone actually believes that he's still making up his mind. Personally I think it's been a done deal since last October. The guy's used us for match practice for the season, he knows, the AFL knows, the club knows it. Worst of all the crazy old man and grubby allan know it. The fact that he's still riding us this hard a week after the season finished really sh*ts me.

[Longsufferingnomore 1,609]

Nathan Jones just said on 3aw that he saw Tom at the club today and Gerard said Tom has changed his travel plans to attend our B & F.

Clutching @ straws aren't we

If he was "gawn" why turn up at the B & F. Be rubbing salt into a very nasty wound. Surely every man and his dog will be asking the question that he doesn't want to answer, yet.

[daisycutter 29,317]

If he was "gawn" why turn up at the B & F. Be rubbing salt into a very nasty wound. Surely every man and his dog will be asking the question that he doesn't want to answer, yet.

Rischitelli (sp?) turned up to B&F last year......AND won the bloody thing!

[lucifer 119]

Will be very interested to see what they say on the Footy Show tonight. I wonder how many times Barrett will say he's signed and we will find out tomorrow?

[Pipefitter 2,133]

Nathan Jones just said on 3aw that he saw Tom at the club today and Gerard said Tom has changed his travel plans to attend our B & F.

Clutching @ straws aren't we

Well that Just blows a big hole in MMM reporting He is In

Sydney.

[Pennant St Dee 12,658]

I'm glad to see you think things are going smoothly, you're the supporter we require at melbourne the most; compliant.

I am gutted as everyone else here that we haven't jumped forward as quick as some expected, but lets not kid ourselves that we are as bad off as we were in 2007. All your doing is increasing the clouds of doom hanging over the club. Dannihers lack of turning over the list and Craig Camerons recruiting options, left our list in dire need of a rebuild which started under Dean and the young guys got exposed with greater responsibility this season. The benefits of which will be evident in the seasons to come.

Our young guys are just like the Eagles kids in fact I think they are better, they mirrored us from 08-10 and have jumped up this year. We don't have Cox, Kennedy, Kerr & Glass. If we had those older bigger bodies things would be different but we have the list we have and will move forward with our without Scully as the case appears to be.

[Trengoove 7]

Have no idea if its true and no source to back things up but just saw this on BF opsted by a western syd supporter.

"Yep congratulations are in order to you guy's I have just heard on very good authority, from someone from gws he has turned down the gws offer. I don't know when this will be confirmed but gws were hoping to have a presser on tuesday but were informed at 4.30 this afternoon that he will not be taking up the offer. I can see the egg on faces now, anyway congratulations if that's the young man's wishes I respect him"

Might be rubbish...might not be.

fingers crossed

[Bay Riffin 1,454]

might as well take that down mate. that guy has a poor reputation for spreading rumours that are not true.

[daisycutter 29,317]

What happens if Tom re-signs with MFC for 12 months?

Can we repeat all this 'fun' again next year?

[diesel 420]

might as well take that down mate. that guy has a poor reputation for spreading rumours that are not true.

Might as well shut down this board if spreading BS isn't allowed!

[deeflog 679]

Might as well shut down this board if spreading BS isn't allowed!

hahaha, well played diesel

[Jack7 521]

What happens if Tom re-signs with MFC for 12 months?

Can we repeat all this 'fun' again next year?

This thread will hit 5,000 posts!!!

[Bay Riffin 1,454]

Might as well shut down this board if spreading BS isn't allowed!

pay that.

[praha 11,117]

I just feel that if it were to be on The Footy Show, they'd have promoted it.

[felixdacat 459]

Might as well shut down this board if spreading BS isn't allowed!

OMG! Did you hear they are shutting the whole Board down..

[beelzebub 23,198]

Congrats Peeps...weve already blitzed August's effort ..all in only 8 days. Good work all

now back to the waffle

[hardtack 10,400]

There was another post on that BF forum as well, that went as follows (again, bucket of salt material):

"Just wanted to chime in,

Heard on Monday that Tom will be re-signing with Melbourne. (Will be a 1-2 Year Contract)

Again, it could be totally wrong and I hope for you guys that it isn't, but this year I have had a 100% strike rate with re-signings and the same source has told me this rumour aswell.

Fingers crossed for you guys, and hope the drum beats louder for Tom staying."

[Samsara 65]

Not sure Tom would sign a 1-2 year desk when both MFC and GWS are offering 4-5 year contracts