Demonland Player of the Year

[titan_uranus 23,226]

6 - Moloney

5 - Trengove

4 - Sylvia

3 - Bail

2 - Jamar

1 - Wonaeamirri

Bennell needs to learn to play four frickin quarters.

[Radar Detector 1,339]

6. Moloney

5. Sylvia

4. Trengove

3. Jones

2. Bail

1. Davey

[Bang Bang Bang 5,608]

6 - Trengove

5 - Moloney

4 - Bail

3 - Sylvia

2 - Jamar

1 - Morton

Edited April 17, 2011 by Sylvia Saint

[P-man 13,353]

6. Moloney

5. Sylvia

4. Trengove

3. Jones

2. Bail

1. Davey

Really? Apologies for questioning a vote but I thought he was pretty dreadful today.

[H_T 2,941]

6 - Moloney

5 - Trengove

4 - Sylvia

3 - Bail

2 - Rivers

1 - Jamar

[Demon Tragic 0]

6. Jamar

5. Moloney

4. Rivers

3. Wona

2. Sylvia

1. Bail

[tomscullydontleave 0]

6 - Moloney

5 - Trengove

4 - Bail

3 - Sylvia

2 - Jamar

1 - Jones

[Yokozuna 1,004]

6. Trengove

5. Moloney

4. Bail

3. Sylvia

2. Tapscott

1. Morton

Apologies to Grimes and Jamar who were both close to gaining some votes.

Also after watching the replay I have forgotten to put in Bail, but I will leave my votes as they are.

Edited April 18, 2011 by Yokozuna

[DeezMan 4]

6 - Moloney

5 - Sylvia

4 - Davey

3 - Jamar

2 - Rivers

1 - Bail

[Deeoldfart 7,858]

6 - Moloney

5 - Trengove

4 - Bail

3 - Jamar

2 - Green

1 - Morton

[Deevout 456]

6: Moloney

5: Trengove

4: Bail

3: Jamar

2: Wona

1: Jones

[Guest Gotzy15]

6. Trengove

5. Moloney

4. Sylvia

3. Jamar

2. Bail

1. Jurrah

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

6 Moloney

5 Sylvia

4 Trengove

3 Jamar

2 Wonaeamirri

1 Green

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,534]

6. Moloney

5. Trengove

4. Sylvia

3. Bail

2. Jamar

1. Rivers

I found it quite easy to nominate the first four, but much harder for the last two. And what was it with all the fumbling from Gysberts, Garland and at times Moloney?

[No16 1]

6. Moloney

5. Trengove

4. Jamar

3. Grimes

2. Sylvia

1. Jones

[deeflog 679]

6 - Moloney

5 - Sylvia

4 - Davey

3 - Jamar

2 - Rivers

1 - Bail

cough cough.....Trengove??

[Demonland 66,962]

Beamer has jumped away ... and there are some good 'uns who are yet to poll.

49 Brent Moloney

32 Mark Jamar

28 Jared Rivers

28 Jack Trengove

27 Rohan Bail

25 Luke Tapscott

18 Stefan Martin

16 Colin Sylvia

14 Liam Jurrah

4 Jamie Bennell

3 Colin Garland

3 Jordan Gysberts

2 Nathan Jones

1 Aaron Davey

1 Jack Grimes

1 Cale Morton

[sylvinator 96]

Beamer has jumped away ... and there are some good 'uns who are yet to poll.

49 Brent Moloney

32 Mark Jamar

28 Jared Rivers

28 Jack Trengove

27 Rohan Bail

25 Luke Tapscott

18 Stefan Martin

16 Colin Sylvia

14 Liam Jurrah

4 Jamie Bennell

3 Colin Garland

3 Jordan Gysberts

2 Nathan Jones

1 Aaron Davey

1 Jack Grimes

1 Cale Morton

I find it interesting to see the comparison between how us armchair experts see the game and the professional coaches (who might put a premium on things like in mind 1%ers and playing the team role)

This is how Bailey and McKenna viewed the game...

Gold Coast v Melbourne

10 Brent Moloney (Melb)

5 Jack Grimes (Melb)

5 Mark Jamar (Melb)

4 Jack Trengove (Melb)

4 Colin Sylvia (Melb)

1 Aaron Davey (Melb)

1 Rohan Bail (Melb)

Jack Grimes second best on ground. Very few hand him in their top 5 at all, though some gave him 1 vote.

Just shows that sometimes you need to dig a little deeper to see a players true worth.

Jack Grimes is going to be our future captain and an absolute star on the competition. Yes he is lacking a little confidence in his disposal at the moment, but for someone so young he is a credit to himself.

Sick of hearing unwarranted over-the-top criticism against some of our players, Grimes especially.

[deejammin' 2,096]

Moloney

Trengrove

Jamar

Sylvia

Jurrah

Wonna

[Mono 454]

.................

This is how Bailey and McKenna viewed the game...

Gold Coast v Melbourne

10 Brent Moloney (Melb)

5 Jack Grimes (Melb)

5 Mark Jamar (Melb)

4 Jack Trengove (Melb)

4 Colin Sylvia (Melb)

1 Aaron Davey (Melb)

1 Rohan Bail (Melb)

........................................

The most interesting part of this is the voting MUST have been:

Moloney - 5,5

Grimes - 3,2

Jamar - 2,3

Trengove - 4,0

Sylvia - 0,4

Davey - 1,0

Bail - 0,1

Which means 1 coach voted Trengove 4 (2nd BOG), the 2nd gave him zip.

And the 2nd coach gave 4 to Sylvia and the 1st gave him zip.

Go figure.

[H_T 2,941]

I find it interesting to see the comparison between how us armchair experts see the game and the professional coaches (who might put a premium on things like in mind 1%ers and playing the team role)

Sick of hearing unwarranted over-the-top criticism against some of our players, Grimes especially.

And Rivers. If they put a premium on 1%'s and team role, Rivers would have been best by a mile. Yet, I can count on one hand how many gave Rivers votes. Even goes unnoticed by the coaches in their votes.

Sometimes people can easily be persuaded by the kick and handballs columns.

I also find it interesting that you haven't given your votes prior to this sledge for all in sundry.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,534]

Who would have thought before the season started that Bail, Tapscott and Martin would be in positions 5, 6 and 7 on the Demonland ladder after four rounds. Good on 'em.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Who would have thought before the season started that Bail, Tapscott and Martin would be in positions 5, 6 and 7 on the Demonland ladder after four rounds. Good on 'em.

what I find inetersting is the list of players who have barely contributed, or at least been well below themselves, this year

Green

Davey

Jones

Garland

Petterd

Frawley

Grimes

Morton

McKenzie

Watts

Scully

it says to me that we have a whole other gear to click into

[Roost It 1,434]

what I find inetersting is the list of players who have barely contributed, or at least been well below themselves, this year

Green

Davey

Jones

Garland

Petterd

Frawley

Grimes

Morton

McKenzie

Watts

Scully

it says to me that we have a whole other gear to click into

Possibly your best post

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Possibly your best post

yeah but I haven't clicked into my other gear yet either