Top 5

[hrob 2]

one of my pet hates is how some people spell moloney with an A, maloney, its MOLONEY!, jst spell it correctly, thank you.

[H_T 3,048]

one of my pet hates is how some people spell moloney with an A, maloney, its MOLONEY!, jst spell it correctly, thank you.

Good point. Beat me to it.

Scully

Frawley

Grimes

Sylvia

Watts

Trengove Jurrah & Davey stiffer than a honeymooners.

[Roost It 1,434]

Scully, Watts, Frawley, Grimes, Blease

[The Jacks 0]

You've got to be joking with Jordie McKenzie. Are you saying others don't give as much as him. Rubbish. Endeavour is great but for the rest of his game he's in the bottom third at this stage. May develop well as we hope he does. Jamar, Sylvia, Bruce, Green, Mahloney can all be considered for that fifth spot. Hard to argue with your other four.

I don't turn it into a negative about the rest of the blokes. I would say Shaun of The Dead (Jordie) gives more than just about anyone else. It's pretty plain and clear to see, I'd say. McKenzie is a seriously good tackler, but he doesn't have the skill of natural ability of plenty of others who could bring their game up another level if they applied themselves with the same level of intensity and effort.

He just loves hunting for those zombies!

As for Brenten Mahlony, I'm sorry about the spelling.

[Mad_Melbourne 877]

one of my pet hates is how some people spell moloney with an A, maloney, its MOLONEY!, jst spell it correctly, thank you.

agreed, especially when putting him as your favourite player

[daisycutter 29,616]

one of my pet hates is how some people spell moloney with an A, maloney, its MOLONEY!, jst spell it correctly, thank you.

Yeah, spelling Moloney as Maloney is just baloney boloney rubbish

[jayceebee31 761]

I cannot believe that no one except Wonahjurah has placed Jamar in the top 5 as yet- HE IS THE MOST IMPORTANT PLAYER ON OUR LIST.

Jamar is the most important player by far currently by a MILE.

JAMAR

Frawley

Jurrah

Green

Davey

then daylight..to others developing.

Edited October 25, 2010 by jayceebee31

[Seinfeld 40]

Jurrah

Sylvia

Frawley

Davey

Jamar

[Allen Jakovich 516]

Jamar is the most important player on our list, but the question was favourite players.

Sylvia

Jurrah

Watts

Grimes

Frawley

Edited October 25, 2010 by Allen Jakovich

[e25 5]

What Jako said, jcb.

I mean, Bartram is my absolute least favourite to watch, yet I know he is not the worst on our list.

If it's any consolation, Jamar would make my top 15...

[Carn dees 108]

Sylvia

Petterd

Jurrah

Chip

Moloney

That was hard.

[The Lobster Effect 892]

fave player totals so far (yep, i was bored)

frawley dominates since EVERY single person has put him in their top 5 so far

frawley 20

jurrah 14

sylvia 11

davey 9

grimes 8

scully 8

watts 8

mckenzie 3

green 3

jamar 3

petterd 3

rivers 2

dunn 2

trengove 2

garland 2

bail 2

moloney 2

bate 1

bartram 1

blease 1

total = 105

[Eth 4]

Ricky Petterd

Colin Sylvia

Liam Jurrah

Brad Green

Jack Trengove

Sorry Chip, would've had you sixth

[Roost It 1,434]

Ricky Petterd

Colin Sylvia

Liam Jurrah

Brad Green

Jack Trengove

Sorry Chip, would've had you sixth

No Scully No Frawley. If we lose these two we lose any chance of a Premiership. We lose Petterd and Green we still have the cattle. Scully and Frawley are locks as top 2 at the club at the moment,

[Hannabal 4]

No Scully No Frawley. If we lose these two we lose any chance of a Premiership. We lose Petterd and Green we still have the cattle. Scully and Frawley are locks as top 2 at the club at the moment,

It's about one's favourite player, not best players, most important players, etc.

I can't fathom how Trengove and Scully aren't in every list, but that's Melbourne supporters for you.

[Radar Detector 1,347]

Sylvia

Davey

Jurrah

Scully

Watts

Frawley and Green very stiff.

Edited October 25, 2010 by Deemolition

[Roost It 1,434]

It's about one's favourite player, not best players, most important players, etc.

I can't fathom how Trengove and Scully aren't in every list, but that's Melbourne supporters for you.

Surely the best players are the favourite players? I'm a fan of Petterd but when it comes to Scully, I mean really.

[Eth 4]

Surely the best players are the favourite players? I'm a fan of Petterd but when it comes to Scully, I mean really.

Are you accusing Petterd of being a spud?

I hope not

Edited October 25, 2010 by eth38

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

I cannot believe that no one except Wonahjurah has placed Jamar in the top 5 as yet- HE IS THE MOST IMPORTANT PLAYER ON OUR LIST.

No he's not...

He's the most important going into 2011 because we don't have much left in the cupboard to back him up. In terms of winning flags in the future he doesn't even make it into the top ten. Way too much premiership winning quality on the list right now. Or at least hopefully will be. It's all a matter of opinion, but it's certainly not a fact that he's the most important. I would argue a single superstar forward (could be Watts, Dunn, Jurrah, Bate) would be more important to getting us further up the ladder. It's all context.

But as someone above said, we're talking favourites. It could be something as simple as liking how his 'tache looks on the TV. Completely subjective... fun, but ultimately, pointless to disagree with. (like most of demonland)

Having said that... given his story, I would have thought he'd sneak into a few more lists. Maybe it's his years in the wilderness, or his age... or perhaps the overhwelmingly large number of young guns coming through.

fave player totals so far (yep, i was bored)

Fantastic. I was going to do this myself. You saved me the trouble.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

I can't fathom how Trengove and Scully aren't in every list, but that's Melbourne supporters for you.

They haven't been playing that long, haven't become the league-leading mids they will be, and both are VERY quiet in the media. I mean come on, we have people giving favourite tags to Dunn for his moustache for crying out loud. Since when has importance to the team, or quality as a player had anything to do with favouritism?

I like the personality contests. It's actually the only thing MOST demonlanders are qualified to make any call on. Their favourites. Reminds me what the site is for.

[45HG 1,539]

Going forward:

Watts

Scully

Grimes

Trengove

Frawley

Currently:

Grimes

Green

Scully

Frawley

Jamar/Jurrah

Edited October 25, 2010 by 45HG16

[Hannabal 4]

They haven't been playing that long, haven't become the league-leading mids they will be, and both are VERY quiet in the media. I mean come on, we have people giving favourite tags to Dunn for his moustache for crying out loud. Since when has importance to the team, or quality as a player had anything to do with favouritism?

I like the personality contests. It's actually the only thing MOST demonlanders are qualified to make any call on. Their favourites. Reminds me what the site is for.

Players are like cattle to me.

I like the best quality meat.

[jnrmac 20,097]

Players are like cattle to me.

I like the best quality meat.

Hannabal the Canibal

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Scully

Jurrah

Petterd

Chip

Russian

Mckenzie

Anyone who wears the red and blue with pride and tries to get the most out of themselves, yeah cliche I know, diligaf.

[Chook 15,013]

1. James Frawley

2. Liam Jurrah

3. Mark Jamar

4. Jack Grimes

5. Colin Sylvia