Colin Sylvia- Complaints, Congratulations and Comments

[Slartibartfast 17,268]

He was good in the second quarter as well as the second half. Just ask Rhino!

He'd be a good player for us if he produces that form consistently but he's not shown that he's capable of that.

One of his problems is our midfield is very poor and forwards rely, in part, on the midfield. He's not all that tall and he's not all that quick, he's just talented.

Sylvia came with such expectation his performance to date has disappointed all of us I think. But he's a fair footballer, just not a great footballer which we thought he could be.

But with talent he could still prove us wrong.

[The Backyard Charizard 1,202]

I really hope that Col can get some consistency in his game..... Not only in his possessions, but also in his attitude.... A consistently good attitude is all that this boy needs IMHO.... The skill and strength are never absent.... It is just a question of attitude and getting rid of that FIGJAM attitude that he likes to show us every other week.....

The kid could be anything..... But the problem is that he already thinks he is something!

[Choko 493]

He was good in the second quarter as well as the second half. Just ask Rhino!

He'd be a good player for us if he produces that form consistently but he's not shown that he's capable of that.

One of his problems is our midfield is very poor and forwards rely, in part, on the midfield. He's not all that tall and he's not all that quick, he's just talented.

Sylvia came with such expectation his performance to date has disappointed all of us I think. But he's a fair footballer, just not a great footballer which we thought he could be.

But with talent he could still prove us wrong.

If by fair you mean a fairly huge disappointment or fairly pathetic attitude or have a fair crack, then I agree. The guy is a waste of talent. I can't stand seeing him play, knowing how good he could be if his work ethic and attitude matched his ability. Sylvia is the great white hope that never delivered. We should have seen what he was worth on the trade market last year. Let's hope he turns his career around, but there is no evidence to suggest that he will.

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,294]

If by fair you mean a fairly huge disappointment or fairly pathetic attitude or have a fair crack, then I agree. The guy is a waste of talent. I can't stand seeing him play, knowing how good he could be if his work ethic and attitude matched his ability. Sylvia is the great white hope that never delivered. We should have seen what he was worth on the trade market last year. Let's hope he turns his career around, but there is no evidence to suggest that he will.

Sylvia was good today. Very strong hands. I still feel he has a lot more to give and agree with others that he just refuses to be consistent. You can see that he could be a gamebreaker if he truly wanted to be, but that is just the problem, the ``IF``

[Hannabal 4]

I reckon Col's "talent" is severely overrated. Yes he can take the odd strong mark, yes he can do the occasional great kick, but his decision making is often poor, his disposal is often wayward, and he's poor in close. Most of all, he lacks footy nous.

Just a player. But will have the odd good day.

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,294]

I reckon Col's "talent" is severely overrated. Yes he can take the odd strong mark, yes he can do the occasional great kick, but his decision making is often poor, his disposal is often wayward, and he's poor in close. Most of all, he lacks footy nous.

Just a player. But will have the odd good day.

Yeah I kinda agree H he does make a few poor decisions. I just liked what I saw today but as someone else mentioned he is a bloody tease! I want to see todays form and more, on a regular basis, but I will not hold my breath!

[drdrake 3,163]

They moved him into the midfield in the second quarter and IMO he was BOG for us. Looks better in the midfield competes wants the footy, some of his marks today were great. Get of his back, support the players that are good enough to play for the Melbourne football club and let the coaches decide whether he is good enough to be in our team. We support that is what we are supporters, how about we try backing this guy instead of constantly putting him down.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

He was good in the second quarter as well as the second half. Just ask Rhino!

He'd be a good player for us if he produces that form consistently but he's not shown that he's capable of that.

Agree.

Spark up Col!!!!

[71 Molloy 266]

how about we try backing this guy instead of constantly putting him down.

Where's the fun in that?

Seriously I've given up on Col. Too many false dawns to get carried away by todays performance. Will wait and see.

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,294]

Did anyone else notice Col`s rushed behind with about 3 minutes to go with Swans up by 2 points. He clearly hanballed to no one at all straight between the posts. All the D`s put there hands on their heads thinking `` you idiot``. Umpire missed it!

[DeeBest 13]

Col played well in a praccy match last year too.

His problem is he plays well in the games that don't matter, and goes missing in the games that do.

[LeBron James 41]

Col played well in a praccy match last year too.

His problem is he plays well in the games that don't matter, and goes missing in the games that do.

That has to be one of the stupidest things i've ever read on this site. Yes, he does go missing simetimes, but in games that matter? No.

[Bobby McKenzie 2,385]

Got us back into the match today and was brilliant. Is so quick off the mark and his kicking skills are sublime. Sydney had no one who could go with him. If he plays like that every week Yze_Magic's prediction of him taking home the Bluey could very well come true.

If YM predicts a Bluey for Sylvia then poor Colin is stuffed. Can you remember any of his predictions bearing fruit?

[Allen Jakovich 516]

Did anyone else notice Col`s rushed behind with about 3 minutes to go with Swans up by 2 points. He clearly hanballed to no one at all straight between the posts. All the D`s put there hands on their heads thinking `` you idiot``. Umpire missed it!

That was Moloney, and the game wasn't played under NAB cup rules, so the rushed behind rule wasn't in effect.

But I know what you mean I was like "oh no" for a second...

[Pepe Dee Pew 0]

Our forward line was practiaclly non existent in the 2nd quarter. Col got us back in the game in the third quarter. He is a natural forward. He is a very quick lead and is stronger than most. He is not the evasive type but a strong lead.

AFL forward footy is tough to play at his size. But i think as his body hardens and becomes stronger he will be a very good forward who can pinch hit as a mid from time to time.

Our forward line will be stronger whwn Bate plays as well.

[Slartibartfast 17,268]

Col played well in a praccy match last year too.

His problem is he plays well in the games that don't matter, and goes missing in the games that do.

How many games have "mattered" in the last two years? At the end of last year Col was one of our better players and was standing up when most of the rest of the club wasn't. I'd say he stood up when it mattered then.

He's a small forward who has played in the shadow of Neitz and Robertson for most of his career. Knowing what you do about footy you'll understand that being a small forward is a hard gig particularly when you're probably 4th in the "go to" player.

I'm not suggesting he's "made it" or he's a "very good footballer" and his game against the Hawks was disappointing. But his response yesterday was very good and from my point of view he's played one shocker in his last 9 games (in the last 7 games last year he averaged 20 possessions and considering how bad we were and the fact he played mainly forward represents a pretty good performance I'd have thought).

But I understand people's frustration and measured against expectation he has not performed. But I've not written him off.

[mo64 5,874]

He's a small forward who has played in the shadow of Neitz and Robertson for most of his career. Knowing what you do about footy you'll understand that being a small forward is a hard gig particularly when you're probably 4th in the "go to" player.

When he was drafted, people were comparing him to Ricciuto. He hasn't got the football smarts to be a gun midfielder, so the best we can hope for is that he becomes a Paul Medhurst type.

[beelzebub 23,364]

But I understand people's frustration and measured against expectation he has not performed. But I've not written him off.

All the discussions about Sylvia boil down to a very simple observation. He has yet to consistently put together 2-3 good quarters over 2-3 games concurrently. You really wouldnt think is too much of a big ask of a decently skiller player..would you ?

He has yet to convince many( including me )..he's still more about a perecived potential rather than any real delivered performance and thats a very poor returnfor his expectaions.

[Slartibartfast 17,268]

All the discussions about Sylvia boil down to a very simple observation. He has yet to consistently put together 2-3 good quarters over 2-3 games concurrently. .

That's where we differ. I think he put together two months of solid football last year. Where people damn him is they judge him against his draft pick and I don't argue that against that measure he's disappointed to date. But once you are on a list that measure is irrelevent, what is relevent is what you do. And on that measure he is a servicable footballer and on the improve.

[titan_uranus 25,016]

OK, so he improved. Let's see what he does next week, and the week after that. That's the big test: any consistency?

[beelzebub 23,364]

That's where we differ. I think he put together two months of solid football last year. Where people damn him is they judge him against his draft pick and I don't argue that against that measure he's disappointed to date. But once you are on a list that measure is irrelevent, what is relevent is what you do. And on that measure he is a servicable footballer and on the improve.

Fan... Im long over expecting him to deliver accoring to his pic #. and it really concerns me if this is his good footy..as to me they were disjointed glimpses with occasional second efforts interpsersed with frustrating ineptness come ragedness of poise.

For all..lets hope he does play good footythis year..all year

[Rogue 585]

He did some very ordinary things today. Thankfully, he did some good things.

That's a fair assessment IMO.

He made more than a handful of bad mistakes, whether it was kicking in hope to no one in particular, handballing straight to the opposition, etc.

He also did enough nice things to warm the hearts of those who love Colin.

his kicking skills are sublime.

Open the other eye please

Where people damn him is they judge him against his draft pick

That's a strawman argument if ever there was one.

I reckon Col's "talent" is severely overrated. Yes he can take the odd strong mark, yes he can do the occasional great kick, but his decision making is often poor, his disposal is often wayward, and he's poor in close. Most of all, he lacks footy nous.

Just a player. But will have the odd good day.

My feelings exactly.

[Pepe Dee Pew 0]

As footy supporters we must learn to manage our expectations - thats hard in such an emotive game. If Col was a number 50 pick we would be saying he is a pretty good player and declaring a bargain.

He was number 3 and has taken a while to develop. He probably will be a very good player for the club but not a superstar. We need to accept this and be demanding yet supportive at the same time.

If he turns out to be better than a very good player then its a bonus. He is still 23 and he is yet to reach peak body strenght but already he can out body most opponents when playing up forward as well as outpace them on the lead.

In my opinion given the type of forward he is Col is about 2 years off playing at his peak.

[beelzebub 23,364]

I reckon the overall disclaimer to Col is to take him in context of WHEN. By this I mean he came along as a very high draft pick when we really needed some major return for it. In a virtual drought of real success we needed Sylvia to be one of THOSE players. As a result much expectaton is piles on his plate. Move forward and with a differing climate amassing around the club with many new faces and, I think its reasonable to say , a fair fist of talent if raw aboundig the place that we might not look so focusedly towards any single player now in the same way we did towards Col.

Essentially; He came along..we used a high pick, we had great expectations..it hasnt materialised.

His prediposition to do as many good things as bad for me puts him in the ho-hum basket. He really needs to fix that , all the whiles looking over his shoulder as he is now VERY easily replaced. So would say the quicker the better. He has about 3-4 games to stave that off in my opinion or he's for the heap ( scrap!! )

All this.." he will be ..."..geezus folks..hes been around a whiles now..and thats the rub !!

[Yze_Magic 3]

This thread is a joke.

Colin has never had anything close to an AFL body. I am not talking in shape or physique, I am talking about all his groin problems that have never enabled him to the things on the field that he is capable of.

Now that he is finally up and running, you are gonna see him average 20 touches and boot 60 goals and take home the Bluey and All Australian honors.

And I will continue to bump this thread every time he shines.