882 6pr Radio Perth

[Bruce Almighty 0]

Said that they believe the deal is

# Travis Johnstone to Sydney for Pick 11

# Rivers to Adelaide for Van Berlo

# Van Berlo, Pick 4 and Pick 11 to West Coast

# Judd to melbourne.

That's what they believe.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

That's a no for me.... too expensive.

[Diablo 1]

Said that they believe the deal is

# Travis Johnstone to Sydney for Pick 11

# Rivers to Adelaide for Van Berlo

# Van Berlo, Pick 4 and Pick 11 to West Coast

# Judd to melbourne.

That's what they believe.

If that happens I will rain death upon the football club.

And by death I mean an insignificant torrent of abuse.

[Deers 202]

We have to give away Johnstone, Rivers and Pick 4?

Stupid to the extreme. Losing Rivers would crush our already deplorable backline.

[praha 10,574]

That'll never happen. Ever. Though it would send Rivers home.

[stretch marks 2]

We have to give away Johnstone, Rivers and Pick 4?

Stupid to the extreme. Losing Rivers would crush our already deplorable backline.

agree..Rivers would be close to the most untouchable player on our list

[Gorgoroth 12,447]

Yep rivers MUST stay.

[Jerry Lundergard 411]

If that was to happen(and i don't want it to!), i would think that Adelaide should throw in Meeson for us.

[Gorgoroth 12,447]

As much as i like van berlo, i would much rather rivers, although meeson as well as VB does make me think a little more, we would then keep chip.

[jacey 333]

Said that they believe the deal is

# Travis Johnstone to Sydney for Pick 11

# Rivers to Adelaide for Van Berlo

# Van Berlo, Pick 4 and Pick 11 to West Coast

# Judd to melbourne.

That's what they believe.

Don't see that happening cause WCE would just cut the middle man. They'll prefer Rivers then Van Berlo.

Van Berlo's a good player who'll lift a cog next year but good smart defenders are invaluable.

[praha 10,574]

As much as i like van berlo, i would much rather rivers, although meeson as well as VB does make me think a little more, we would then keep chip.

According to that trade, we lose Van Berlo to WC. All we end up with is Judd. WC get 2 picks (one from us and one from Adelaide) and Van Berlo, Adelaide get Rivers, we get Judd.

[lucifer 119]

What we need to remember is that ONE man can't win a team a preimership! Giving up Rivers would be a massive mistake! Saying that, I want Judd at the club as badly as the next guy...just NOT at any cost

[dee3po 0]

We have to give away Johnstone, Rivers and Pick 4?

Stupid to the extreme. Losing Rivers would crush our already deplorable backline.

Really?? If we want Judd we need to give something. It seems to either be a Rivers or Frawley exchange somewhere down the line. Rivers is the biggest loss but you are adding the best midfielder in the comp, while losing an exellent potential AA backman. Even with this Surely Chip can step up with some experience under his belt and fill the void. Without Judd we still have a lazy midfield with 2 excellent prospects in Jonesy and Brock who desperately need a role model. Our backline has been deplorable but taking into consideration the neglect our midfield has shown in defending and the absence of, imo, the best small back in the comp in whelan for the year, adding Judd for Johnstone, Rivers and a pick package might not be the defensive armageddon you envisage.

[leucopogon 1,494]

Rivers to Adelaide for Van Berlo!!!

Oh no, looks like we're going to be the ones held over a barrel. What a shonk this is. I would expect a lot more from Adelaide for our nab rising star winner. I'm just going to reserve judgement on everything until any deal(s) are done and dusted.

[Little Goffy 13,021]

Said that they believe the deal is

# Travis Johnstone to Sydney for Pick 11

# Rivers to Adelaide for Van Berlo

# Van Berlo, Pick 4 and Pick 11 to West Coast

# Judd to melbourne.

That's what they believe.

I'm sorry, the RISING STAR WINNER and ABSOLUTELY REQUIRED CHB Jared Rivers for whatsisname van ok player?

That's so stupid it's just not credible. I'd puke a fountain, even if we did get Judd.

Why would WC want van berlo so much?

Trapper to Sydney for 11 isn't so bad, though.

Bah, this is all getting stupid. I'm gonna go watch some footy, I hear there's a game on today?

[two sheds jackson 3]

dee3po

A ) Whelan and Frawley are very different players to Rivers (Whelans a small defender, Frawley a prospective KPP, while Rivers is a smart zoning defender). We dont have anyone capable of filling the gap left by Rivers. The issue isnt just that he's an excellent backman, its also the fact that we dont have any other players in his mold.

B ) Whelan has been injury prone for the last two seasons and might well be on his last legs- I hope he can stay fit next year and regain some form, but even if he does, as a best case scenario he only has two or three good years left in him. Frawley has the opposite problem- realistically it'll probably be another two or three years before we see him at his best.

I'd be concerned if this is true. We'd have a phenomenal midfield, but probably a disasterous backline, and we couldnt even begin to try and address it until the 2008 draft.

Nobodies untouchable, but Rivers is literally the last player I would want to see traded.

[Jaded No More 60,129]

It is NOT worth losing Rivers for Judd.

As much as I want the Melbourne rumours to be true, I hope this one is completely wrong.

[leucopogon 1,494]

A ) Whelan and Frawley are very different players to Rivers (Whelans a small defender, Frawley a prospective KPP, while Rivers is a smart zoning defender).

You say that Rivers is a smart zoning defender, yes that's true, at this stage of his development, but he is easily our brightest prospect of becoming a KPP. He's the same height as both Scarlett and Harley (192cm) and only 3kg lighter than both of these premiership KPP's.

My money is that if Rivers is playing for MFC next year, he's our first choice CHB/FB starting from game 1 of the preseason cup.

I'd really be loathe to lose Rivers after losing Scott Thompson to the Crows.

[two sheds jackson 3]

You're probably right- I think he's just about invaluable in his current role, but I'd obviously be thrilled (but not surprised) if he eventually developes into a quality CHB, especially considering we really have no other options. I was more just saying that neither Frawley, Whelan or anyone else on our list could remotely take over Rivers' current role in the team if he's part of a Judd trade. To lose him would have a devastating effect on an already shaky defense.

It sounds like you basically agree anyway, but I just figured I'd clarify that Im not trying to sell Rivers short by saying he's "only" a zoning defender.

[Whispering_Jack 28,118]

You're probably right- I think he's just about invaluable in his current role, but I'd obviously be thrilled (but not surprised) if he eventually developes into a quality CHB, especially considering we really have no other options. I was more just saying that neither Frawley, Whelan or anyone else on our list could remotely take over Rivers' current role in the team if he's part of a Judd trade. To lose him would have a devastating effect on an already shaky defense.

It sounds like you basically agree anyway, but I just figured I'd clarify that Im not trying to sell Rivers short by saying he's "only" a zoning defender.

First things first and let's get Judd's nod that he wants to come to us. If that happens then I'd leave it to the football department to make the right decisions but I'd be surprised if Rivers was a part of any swap. Get him fit and back in top form and he could be our defensive quarterback. In his absence, we're very light on for key defenders that, as we saw today, are so integral if you want your team to be successful.

[Coxy 0]

Said that they believe the deal is

# Travis Johnstone to Sydney for Pick 11

# Rivers to Adelaide for Van Berlo

# Van Berlo, Pick 4 and Pick 11 to West Coast

# Judd to melbourne.

That's what they believe.

I'm actually laughing

[Redleg 38,585]

I'm actually laughing

Me too.

[Rogue 585]

We have to give away Johnstone, Rivers and Pick 4?

Stupid to the extreme.

Agreed.

No surprise this came from a Perth radio station.

[mick2007 0]

what a joke One of the most talented midfielders, a norwich rising star, and two early draft picks for judd idon't think he is worth that much. Judd is worth johnstone and pick 4 anything more and we are getting ripped

[beelzebub 22,724]

hey some are that delusional they think they are getting three top 20 picks !! ...must tbe the isolation !! lol