6 minutes ago, Garbo said:

That the issue, we need something to go our way to win, completely different to last year. Where it was the opposite 

Did you not remember that round 23 game in Geelong? We won after the siren following a 50.

58 minutes ago, david_neitz_is_my_dad said:

I thought a lot of our i50 kicks to Brown were not to his advantage

You mean kicking it on top of a forward’s head who is triple teamed is not kicking to advantage? Well I’ll be damned. 

55 minutes ago, Colin B. Flaubert said:

Melky was just lucky

That wasn’t luck CBF. It was superb judgment and nerves of steel against 3 opposing spoilers. One of the best contested marks you’ll see. 

I am embarrassed and ashamed to say I walked out not knowing there were still 3 minutes to go but stopped to watch it on one of the TVs in the MCC entrance. It was amazing atmosphere with supporters yelling, groaning and yelling again. When Kozzie kicked the goal everyone was hugging and cheering and then rushing back to watch the game. When the siren went the orange MCC lady hugged me and we kind of looked at each other weirdly then laughed. The atmosphere in the MCC members was like it was when we beat Hawthorn and Geelong. What made me very happy was how delirious the players were when they were walking up the race. We might have fallen into the win but it showed guts and determination not to give up and the result will I am sure provide the impetus to work that little bit harder against Brisbane next week. 

Just got home. Still on an absolute high. That was the most amazing finish I have seen in person. 
primal screams

10 minutes ago, mo64 said:

It's definitely a win by Brown. I'm not blaming Brown. My criticism is of our one dimensional game plan even when the game is slipping away. It was a bad option. Brown was against 3 Carlton players and we were fortunate that the ball hit a Carlton player in the head.

Our final goal was a result of Lever kicking the ball at right angles into the corridor. Post game, Trac said it was a shocking kick by Lever that came off, but I think Lever had the smarts to realise that Carlton would have been set up down the line.

You look at that kick and his kick v Geelong last year. Very smart footballer

1 minute ago, The heart beats true said:

Did you not remember that round 23 game in Geelong? We won after the siren following a 50.

We came back from 40 points down in Geelong. Completely different. We had no right to win it and we did. 
This year we have lost 6 games while 4 goals or more up. That is the difference. We lost our energy and killer instinct. We are just going.  

Here’s the 16th Birthday getting interrupted by a frantic finish. Reaction after Kozzie’s goal.

 

Edited August 13, 20222 yr by Dee Zephyr

Watching the Kayo mini

Carlton had the ball bounce nicely, or fall into their arms quite a few times

Jack Martin goals are a worry, we'll have our work cut out keeping Charlie Cameron quiet next week

59 minutes ago, Stiff Arm said:

20 tackles inside 50 ✅

70+ for the entire game.

Positive that we found a way to win.

Also positive for our long term objective to become a consistently competitive football club that we have been in a position to win all 21 games so far.

Just not convinced that we are as good as many on here think we are. I've been thinking/hoping we've been keeping something hidden and had a switch we might flick at the pointy end...but our defence has dropped way off (uncannily kept teams to 16 to 18 scoring shots every week last year, this year it's regularly 24 to 25), and we don't seem to have a method of getting the ball forward when plan A isn't working. I honestly see us in big trouble in week 1 of the finals if we drop next week...I reckon the Tigers are a better team than us and Dogs and us are line ball right now.

Well, weird one wasn't it? I reserve the right to make a slight revision on my during the game thoughts. I said during the game I thought we were really really poor. I now think we were just poor. 

But bugger all that, the effect a win like that has on team morale can't be bought. Do we have problems? Yes we do, are they easily fixable? No they are not. Bit honestly I couldn't give a rip about that right now. When I eventually leave this earth one of my all time favourite feelings will be a close game at the G that could go either way, then the siren going and hearing that Melbourne song, there's ni feeling like that in the world!

To the football! When you look at the metrics we matched most of the good ones. Contested ball, clearances. There were times when it seemed like the Blues wanted it s bit more in the middle but we were very much up for the fight in there. First half we looked a bit slow and off but I do think our intensity raised in the second half even if we weren't able to execute the way we like. I'm not going to complain too much about inaccuracy, we're mostly adults here and we know bad kicking is bad football. I just want a 5% improvement in that area, 10% would give me a rush, don't give me 15% oh geez, I might be watching that game in the hospital. The concern about our forward structure is a much more pressing concern than the shots we are missing. The lever needs to be pulled (pun), 1 tall forward aint getting it done. Melksham did a great job despite a few sitters missed, he did actually give us something to kick to. We have some concerns regarding even our small forwards, we just need more out of them and a don't know how we get them more looks at goal but really need to. I thought Carlton's pressure was immense tonight and they never let us get clear chances, well except at the end..

I had Gus BOG, can understand the people giving Melksham full votes I absolutely can, i flip flopped on it a lot but Gus is helping us so much at the moment I'm keeping things fresh in the middle. Clarry came alive in the second half, thought Viney's game was important. Down back I thought Petty was the pick of the defenders, May got better but had his hands full early on and made a few errors, Lever had a forget game. 

Might cop it a bit for this but I think the umpiring although questionable at some crucial points was actually pretty good, they let the game flow. Hardest sport to umpire around and they were good for the majority of it I thought.

I just want to do something I don't usually do in a postage thread. I want to give some praise to an opposition player. Sam Docherty, you are an absolute champion my friend. Thought he was their best player tonight in my book and he's been doing it all season. Multiple knee recos, cancer scares, this shouldn't be possible should it? Carlton fans are lucky to have this guy.

Enjoy it tonight and tomorrow people, we'll deal with whatever comes. For now we live to fight another day, Go Dees!

 

1 hour ago, McStaff said:

We are so lucky to have Jack Viney in this team. 
The bloke is a beast that scares the absolute s**t out of the opposition. 
❤️💙🥰

There was a stoppage on their f50 when he dropped 2 or 3 of them off the ball. Absolute bull

2 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

We came back from 40 points down in Geelong. Completely different. We had no right to win it and we did. 
This year we have lost 6 games while 4 goals or more up. That is the difference. We lost our energy and killer instinct. We are just going.  

But that doesn’t change the fact that things went our way last year too. Close doesn’t punch the ball over the boundary and we’d be week one in Port Adelaide and who knows. You need some luck. It’s easy to look back now and think it was preordained, but it wasn’t.

Also it’s tough to argue we’ve lost our killer instinct after watching that last 2 minutes. We had no right to win that game, but we did - because we didn’t give up.

52 minutes ago, Demonstone said:

Frees were 23 to us and 13 to them.   Must have been "the narrative".

Shows you how bloody dirty they are.

19 minutes ago, Garbo said:

Not a chance based on tonight that we beat lions, we have learned nothing from last week

I actually think that statement is wrong.It was from last weeks close loss that we learnt how to win tonight! 
And I think tonight’s game will kick start our season. My once dwindling premiership hopes have just started to soar.

Edited August 13, 20222 yr by Neil Crompton

Just watching the last 5 minutes and what I loved is when it came to the stoppages the umps just threw the ball up and didn't bother to nominate the ruckmen. Just got on with it. 

also I didn't realise it was melksham that got the ball to Kozzie. I hope Melksham brings that form from now on. 

1 hour ago, KingDingAling said:

I did that with 14 minutes to go and turned it back on with 30 seconds to go.

Turned it off 4 minutes to go to watch a great German serial on SBS. Couldn’t believe the result 60 minutes later. Can’t wait for a closer examination when it is posted. 
 

Hope now this shows us building into finals form at right time of year. No where near 2021 form but at least we have a chance from here. Next week will be a good indicator. Top 2 is still within reach….

1 hour ago, GCDee said:

Never in doubt… haha 

if we don’t give the flag a shake this year at least we gave this dagger to these flogs. 

hunt was absolutely clutch at the end there 

Only saw the second half... at son's grad.

Hunt was clutch for all of it.  He was great.  He changes the whole dynamic down back and through the middle on the press.

Character building win but FCS get Harmes in there.  Didn't see the first half so can't say for whom but Sparrow was pretty quite in that part.

Edited August 13, 20222 yr by Demon Dynasty

41 minutes ago, mo64 said:

Our coaches will see that as a win unfortunately. The only reason we won this game in the end was because Hunt chose to take the game on with his run. Oh, and no-one has mentioned how Melksham managed to take that mark amongst 3 Carlton players. If that was against the Pies, it wouldn't have happened, and we lose.

Mate enjoy the win for gods sake!

1 hour ago, one_demon said:

Enjoy the win of course, but it's important to be realistic and the reality is we're not wining it this year.  

Please can we have at least until tomorrow before we face anything other than joy?!

19 minutes ago, Webber said:

That wasn’t luck CBF. It was superb judgment and nerves of steel against 3 opposing spoilers. One of the best contested marks you’ll see. 

Yes same up the other end in the third when he marked the ball like a cork in the ocean on his back

19 minutes ago, Webber said:

That wasn’t luck CBF. It was superb judgment and nerves of steel against 3 opposing spoilers. One of the best contested marks you’ll see. 

Other than the other one he took falling on his [censored].

What a game Jakey boy

19 minutes ago, Dee Zephyr said:

Here’s the 16th Birthday getting interrupted by a frantic finish. Reaction after Kozzie’s goal.

 

IMG_1369.MOV 7.87 MB · 6 downloads

 

Words can't express how cool that is Zeph.

1 hour ago, Lord Nev said:

Sounds violent...

You must be strong though.