AFL TRADE NEWS AND RUMOURS

[DubDee 26,199]

Any more word on Gunston? With M Brown signing on perhaps we heard he will stay a hawk?

[dazzledavey36 55,476]

51 minutes ago, Turner said:

how does naish compare to baker statistically at afl and vfl level?

A [censored] load better.

Nah look in terms of VFL this year Baker played 7 games and averaged 18.2 disposals this year compared to Naish's 28.5

Edited September 30, 2021 by dazzledavey36

[DeeSpencer 26,097]

8 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

I think Patrick Naish might be a bit of watch this space. Hasn't been able to break into the Richmond line for the past couple of years even though he's dominated VFL level. In his 6 games this year at VFL level he averaged 28.5 disposals per game as an outside speedy wingman.

He was a highly rated under 18 prospect who was part of the highly AFL Academy squad. Outside wingman who's quick and has neat kicking skills

Wouldn't be surprised if the club are looking at him purely as a depth player as that outside player.

 

Richmond have had major injuries in each of the last 3 years and they've pretty much taken a look at Naish each time and quickly got him out of the team. Only this year when they probably knew they had to have an extended look at him did they give him 4 games in a row and he did nothing.

I'm not sure why exactly we are keeping Baker but my guess is they know he's much fitter now and his pace is still a rare attribute even if his kicking, contested work and decision making is a way off it. He has that one quality attribute and they can work on adding to the rest of his game. Plus he knows the system and can shadow Langdon all summer again.

Naish has a lovely boot but the weaknesses in his game - size, speed and more than anything his competitiveness probably just aren't going to improve. Doesn't matter how good you were as a junior and how good your VFL form is if you can't handle the step up in physical pressure at the top level.

Declase probably gets the nod as that taller more defensive winger as back up to Brayshaw and that's definitely not a role for Naish.

[Clintosaurus 7,913]

Lewis Young worth a look? Did not realise he is taller than Jacko.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

I find it hard to see how we could improve our list?

Mebbe another genuine back pocket?

[BAMF 4,418]

3 hours ago, jumbo returns said:

I find it hard to see how we could improve our list?

Mebbe another genuine back pocket?

We need Casey players.

We had a blessed run with injury this year and are cutting a lot of depth.

Jones, Jetta, Vanders, Lockhart and potentially Melksham. All of them got a bit of game time this year and were ready if needed.

I was happy that all these players were there for depth this year and likewise happy that we are moving them on now.

The weird thing is that with Brayshaw, Harmes, Jordon and Sparrow all being best 22 (or 23) we are actually light on for inside bulls at Casey!

We will also want to draft a young kpf and young ruck at some point soon.

[Chook in Perth 2,109]

10 hours ago, A F said:

I know things change, but I'm now even more intrigued by the Frank Valli comment mate. 😂  I assume you just like them and we were on like Donkey Kong and then something changed. Is that the gist of it?

Cerra was coming if they could get it done. There was much confidence they could. They couldn't. So he isn't.

[adonski 12,628]

11 minutes ago, Chook in Perth said:

Cerra was coming if they could get it done. There was much confidence they could. They couldn't. So he isn't.

Lack of interest for Weid impact things?

[Redleg 41,782]

4 hours ago, jumbo returns said:

I find it hard to see how we could improve our list?

 

Sertiously? Bont wouldn't help, Walsh, Dusty, Max King, De Goey, Andy Brayshaw, Luke Ryan, Whitfield, Toby Greene, etc, etc.

The list can always be improved and if we think it can't, we will go backwards.

[Redleg 41,782]

Carlton looms as one potential candidate for Lewis Young as it searches for key position depth. 

The Blues have also been linked to a possible play for West Coast's Jarrod Brander.

With Cerra and Hewitt, it looks like Carlton will get every player changing clubs in the AFL.

[Jjrogan 1,444]

1 hour ago, BAMF said:

We need Casey players.

We had a blessed run with injury this year and are cutting a lot of depth.

Jones, Jetta, Vanders, Lockhart and potentially Melksham. All of them got a bit of game time this year and were ready if needed.

I was happy that all these players were there for depth this year and likewise happy that we are moving them on now.

The weird thing is that with Brayshaw, Harmes, Jordon and Sparrow all being best 22 (or 23) we are actually light on for inside bulls at Casey!

We will also want to draft a young kpf and young ruck at some point soon.

This is on the right track  Jt's podcast later in the year suggested quality ball users through the middle and another ruck. 

[Demon Disciple 12,337]

28 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Carlton looms as one potential candidate for Lewis Young as it searches for key position depth. 

The Blues have also been linked to a possible play for West Coast's Jarrod Brander.

With Cerra and Hewitt, it looks like Carlton will get every player changing clubs in the AFL.

They’re bound to get one right eventually

[BAMF 4,418]

.

Edited September 30, 2021 by BAMF

[BAMF 4,418]

1 hour ago, Redleg said:

Sertiously? Bont wouldn't help, Walsh, Dusty, Max King, De Goey, Andy Brayshaw, Luke Ryan, Whitfield, Toby Greene, etc, etc.

The list can always be improved and if we think it can't, we will go backwards.

Obviously. But we are not going to pick up any of those players are we? Who are we actually a realistic chance of picking up with our currently limited currency?

It will likely be delisted players, cheap fringe players or simply take our picks to the draft.

Anything else means we will have to create trade currency which means giving up something that many won't want to give up.

[FireInTheBennelly 4,099]

9 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

A [censored] load better.

Nah look in terms of VFL this year Baker played 7 games and averaged 18.2 disposals this year compared to Naish's 28.5

For me then you really have to look at what you can get for Baker. If you can get a trade for him and pick up a decent replacement for free you've improved your list. What is Baker worth? 

[BAMF 4,418]

4 hours ago, FireInTheBennelly said:

For me then you really have to look at what you can get for Baker. If you can get a trade for him and pick up a decent replacement for free you've improved your list. What is Baker worth? 

Future third round pick at best.

More likely that there is no interest at all.

[dazzledavey36 55,476]

5 hours ago, FireInTheBennelly said:

For me then you really have to look at what you can get for Baker. If you can get a trade for him and pick up a decent replacement for free you've improved your list. What is Baker worth? 

4th round pick.

[Redleg 41,782]

7 hours ago, BAMF said:

Obviously. But we are not going to pick up any of those players are we? Who are we actually a realistic chance of picking up with our currently limited currency?

It will likely be delisted players, cheap fringe players or simply take our picks to the draft.

Anything else means we will have to create trade currency which means giving up something that many won't want to give up.

Agree.

We are really lucky to have JT and his team, because there are better players coming through, that will not necessarily be high draft picks, who will be better than many of the players currently changing clubs.

Good development and shrewd drafting are the foundation of future success and we are now good in both those areas.

Given we have a good young list, we can cherry pick a player or two and otherwise draft for the future.

That is why a Mac Andrew is less of a risk for us, than other clubs using a high draft pick, as he will not be an instant AFL player. Clubs below us want an instant return, whereas we can take some time to develop players to replenish the list as our current list is a young one that has proved itself.

[durango 2,023]

The fact is the best 22 in 2021 was the premiership team and 10-12 extra for depth but you have to improve your list by going out and getting players that are not depth players but part of best 22 players each year.

There are 2 methods of doing that by improvement in the 10-12 extra depth players or going to get players in the draft.

This team has 7 player who were 21 and under as at the Grand Final so these players need to be better next year because the premiers become the hunted.

A famous athlete Carl Lewis once said 'when you are number 1 you have to train like you are number 2', so this team cannot rest on their laurels and expect the competition to allow them to do it again without a fight.

Carlton is an example of the scattergun approach to recruiting, were they recruit anyone they can without development of their skills hoping they will bolster the team.

[Demons1858 1,772]

10 hours ago, Redleg said:

Sertiously? Bont wouldn't help, Walsh, Dusty, Max King, De Goey, Andy Brayshaw, Luke Ryan, Whitfield, Toby Greene, etc, etc.

The list can always be improved and if we think it can't, we will go backwards.

In the context of what players appear to be available and haven't already nominated a club, not sure anyone left will add to our list. Expecting a very very quiet trade period, with players more likely to go out than come in

Edited September 30, 2021 by Demons1858

[MadAsHell 4,217]

I'm not expecting us to bring in any experienced players this off season and will instead just focus on drafting and developing new kids. I reckon we'll only target specific mature players (Cerra for example) and if we miss out, we simply move on. Save the money for managing contractsgoing forward.

 

We may well try and trade up on the draft to get Mac Andrew and trade out Melksham to improve our draft hand, but that's about all I expect.

 

I know some others have mentioned recruiting more depth for Casey given the departures of Jones, Jetta, Vandenberg etc. However don't forget, we have the likes of Brayshaw, Harmes, Nibbler etc in our best 22 who could play more midfielde minutes should we get key injuries. Their roles could then be filled by the likes of Hunt, Laurie, Chandler, Bedford etc.

[Fat Tony 5,291]

17 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

Richmond have had major injuries in each of the last 3 years and they've pretty much taken a look at Naish each time and quickly got him out of the team. Only this year when they probably knew they had to have an extended look at him did they give him 4 games in a row and he did nothing.

I'm not sure why exactly we are keeping Baker but my guess is they know he's much fitter now and his pace is still a rare attribute even if his kicking, contested work and decision making is a way off it. He has that one quality attribute and they can work on adding to the rest of his game. Plus he knows the system and can shadow Langdon all summer again.

Naish has a lovely boot but the weaknesses in his game - size, speed and more than anything his competitiveness probably just aren't going to improve. Doesn't matter how good you were as a junior and how good your VFL form is if you can't handle the step up in physical pressure at the top level.

Declase probably gets the nod as that taller more defensive winger as back up to Brayshaw and that's definitely not a role for Naish.

Didn't they (stupidly) sign Baker for two years.

[Ethan Tremblay 31,170]

I wouldn’t be surprised if Geelong made inquiries into J.Hunt

[Ethan Tremblay 31,170]

12 hours ago, Chook in Perth said:

Cerra was coming if they could get it done. There was much confidence they could. They couldn't. So he isn't.

Yep I also heard if Cerra chose us and we got the deal done he would have played with us. 

[Bitter but optimistic 22,289]

1 minute ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Yep I also heard if Cerra chose us and we got the deal done he would have played with us. 

You're going out on a limb there Ethan!