5 minutes ago, Lace Out said:

Now that may make more sense if Viney has in fact extended his contract. 

The mail was 1 + 1

16 minutes ago, Graeme Yeats' Mullet said:

The mail was 1 + 1

What does that mean? 

2 minutes ago, A F said:

What does that mean? 

Put 1 and 1 together

Gus didn't strike me as the type to lose sleep at night about losing. I understand the issues about being played out of position, though. 

Given it seems we've signed Viney, you'd think it'd be difficult to fit Gus in if we're also looking at any other mids on the market/convincing them to pursue a trade with us.

I would consider Polec for Brayshaw

10 minutes ago, Half forward flank said:

I would consider Polec for Brayshaw

You would, why would that surprise me, but it is not gunna happen

Just now, drysdale demon said:

You would, why would that surprise me, but it is not gunna happen

I hope not. Brayshaw would eat Polec for Breakfast. Polec is not that good and is bad news. Forr me Brayshaw has more upside remembering he came 3rd in the Brownlow only 2 years ago.

14 hours ago, goodwindees said:

Hi Rab. He phoned D’Orazio who is his Manager on Saturday night. I genuinely believe Christian loves the Club and probably loves every single person in it, however, I suspect that Christian genuinely believes he’s built for Grand Finals and has a burning desire to play in a FEW before he’s finished and might have just had some doubts.

He’s contracted for two years so that’s that, however, I’d be very worried that if the Dees aren’t a GENUINE Premiership contender at the end of this Contract, he won’t finish his career at the Dees.  Time will tell. 

I think you may be stretching things a bit too  far now, but you are likely to suck a lot in.

13 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

I'm not questioning you @goodwindees, but I just question the seriousness of the story.

I am

5 hours ago, Tony Tea said:

This has been my worry for several years now. We are never going to win a flag if every time we start to build a list we lose a key player.

Who have we lost recently? Like the last 4 years?

Please don't say Jesse Hogan. Pick 6 for him was a steal. He's spent 

Watts? Nah!

Edited September 25, 20205 yr by Moonshadow

46 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

Who have we lost recently? Like the last 4 years?

Please don't say Jesse Hogan. Pick 6 for him was a steal. He's spent 

Watts? Nah!

jesse hogan.

8 hours ago, Half forward flank said:

I would consider Polec for Brayshaw

??‍♂️

8 hours ago, Half forward flank said:

I would consider Polec for Brayshaw

Norf has screwed us enough over the past 10 or so years, I'd rather not let them do it at the trade table.

Keep losing, wasting everyones time and all our guns will leave. The past two years are enough losing.

10 hours ago, Docs Demons said:

I hope not. Brayshaw would eat Polec for Breakfast. Polec is not that good and is bad news. Forr me Brayshaw has more upside remembering he came 3rd in the Brownlow only 2 years ago.

I dont give a stuff about the Brownlow

10 hours ago, Docs Demons said:

I hope not. Brayshaw would eat Polec for Breakfast. Polec is not that good and is bad news. Forr me Brayshaw has more upside remembering he came 3rd in the Brownlow only 2 years ago.

Note, I said consider. Beyond that identicial disposals over career as well as player rating. One is a mid we cant fit into a midfield lacking variety and another is outside creativity and run. How stupid of me to consider a trade like that.

21 minutes ago, Half forward flank said:

Note, I said consider. Beyond that identicial disposals over career as well as player rating. One is a mid we cant fit into a midfield lacking variety and another is outside creativity and run. How stupid of me to consider a trade like that.

One would be moving to his 4th club, which shows he has some major flaws.   The only way this works if Nth passed over the pick we gave them last year 

14 hours ago, whatwhatsaywhat said:

Tell that to Bobby Skilton

"Mainly"

From a list management perspective Clarry and Trac are must keep at all costs. They are our match winners and game breakers. From an inside mid perspective I’d say Brayshaw Viney and Harmes (although played out of position) are tradeable. 
I think Gus most likely to move on. Then Harmes back in the midfield mix to run with and block etc for Clarry and Trac. Our best starting midfield is Gawn Clarry Trac and Viney. 

Brayshaw is a must keep. If Clarry or Trac get injured to have him there is a need. They should be looking at resting both those up guys forward more next year and while running Brayshaw through the middle. Having Clarry or Trac playing out of the goal square at times will only help Weid and Jackson. 

Brayshaw has much more upside than Polec.

My brother an avid Nth supporter, says Polec is good but slowing down and losing his speed and run.

If we did this trade we would regret it.

5 hours ago, Hunt29 said:

From a list management perspective Clarry and Trac are must keep at all costs. They are our match winners and game breakers. From an inside mid perspective I’d say Brayshaw Viney and Harmes (although played out of position) are tradeable. 
I think Gus most likely to move on. Then Harmes back in the midfield mix to run with and block etc for Clarry and Trac. Our best starting midfield is Gawn Clarry Trac and Viney. 

Would rather than Harmes than Gus.He has a higher footy IQ and is a much better player. 

The bottom 6 are slop, selection is all over the shop, game plan ? and over offering recruits that under perform. 
Players talk..if you want success as a player you would think twice about staying at MFC. 
Not surprising really. 

22 hours ago, Half forward flank said:

I would consider Polec for Brayshaw

?