Nah because if we lost to collingbog in the Gf, I could never live that down.

I was thinking that if we beat the Eagles, then either the QB game or the Anzac Eve game is the GF replay next year ... should be bigger than ever!

17 hours ago, Deeoldfart said:

I think Richmond will win, and purely from a selfish perspective, that's the way I'd prefer it to go.  My rationale:

• I 'dees-pies' Collingwood so much that the thought of them playing off in a Grand Final makes me want to puke;  and
• if we happened to play Collingwood in the Grand Final, Grundy has the capacity to reduce the influence of our major trump card in big Max, making a win more difficult for us.

It hurts me to say it, but I want a Richmond win tomorrow night.  Maybe by a big margin, so they drink a tub full of their own bathwater before facing a rampant Dees outfit. 

Me too.

Richmond have not faced anything like us this season (or last season), playing the way we are playing now.

We've seen all the other teams trying various tactics to beat them, whereas we would be right up in their face, attacking their strength and playing them at their own game. Fire vs Fire stuff. I'd be fascinating to see who comes out on top.

I also salivate at the prospect of Viney/Harmes vs Martin.

First however, West Coast...

14 hours ago, Whispering_Jack said:

I would be very surprised if Collingwood were to win against Richmond on their showing against GWS. The intensity of their game last week was a few notches below that of the night before and they will need to lift to match it with Richmond.

Agree. I was at the Pies/GWS game last week and IMHO I thought we would have definitely beaten the Pies had we been playing them.

Just don’t think Pies are capable of scoring enough to challenge the Tigers

Tigers are a high scoring club, as are we

Should be a cracking game

Got this awful feeling in the pit of my stomach that the filth might cause a massive upset here... 

I’d love to play the pies in a grand final. How good would it be watching Eddie sob as chunk and goody lift the cup 

Think the Richmond forwards will just be a bit much for the Pies backline in the end. I do think it will be a tough contest though.

22 minutes ago, whatwhatsaywhat said:

Just don’t think Pies are capable of scoring enough to challenge the Tigers

Tigers are a high scoring club, as are we

Should be a cracking game

They seemed to score quite freely against us on Queens Birthday...

going to be a rugby scrum of a game.  if pies keep the intensity up all game, 60 points could win it.

BANG!!!!

Really looking forward to tonights game. 

I hope they hit each other real hard and force this game into a triple OT. 

 

2 hours ago, Mondê said:

They seemed to score quite freely against us on Queens Birthday...

Frost didn't play that day. Any game Melbourne played at the G this year without frost  is irrelevant. 

The MCG should be renamed Boganville for tonight.

Astbury a chance to miss.  he has been quarentined with illness

may all 44 players contract the virus!  ?

 

No doubt that Mason Cox holds the key in the sense that the Pies just seem to lack goal kickers.

Was going to run a thread as to who was the better VFA pick up between Brody Mihocek and Bayley Fritsch but the air went out of that balloon.

4 hours ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

The MCG should be renamed Boganville for tonight.

HEY! I'll be there bringing at least a modicum of taste to the MCC (and relieving a Filth or Tuggers fan of a seat).

Tomorrow, Perth. Sunday, VFL...

To be honest if we win tmrw I don't care who we play in a grand final. I just hate the filth so I hope the tigers bog all over em.

Can't bear the thought of C'wood in the GF. No, they must not get there. Even for the chance of beating them.

 

C'wood and Tiges to belt the living sh*t out of each other and the least worst team to limp into a GF thrashing at the hands of the MIGHTY DEMONS

All this revolves around the big “if” at 3.20 tomorrow. If the dream continues tomorrow, I simply don’t care who we play - payback to either - ANZAC Eve or Queens B’Day - take your pick!

still reckon tuggas over the filth by 42

4 hours ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

The MCG should be renamed Boganville for tonight.

A time least the crime rate will be down tonight!

As for the game, Richmond by 47

The channel seven pre-game reminds me how much I love the mute button on the remote control!

I’m going for the Pies. I think we would have a better chance of knocking them off next week than the Tigers should we progress beyond tomorrow.

I also have an intense dislike for Rance and his sooky behaviour.

 

Edited September 21, 20186 yr by jane02
Edit

Conflicted. Want to face collingwood in the grand final, but if we lose to west coast its the two clubs I personally hate most in the final.. 

Seriously, Bwooce is a complete [censored] on nights like these!