Would we take $cully back?

[durango 1,979]

If you remember he's only played 1 game last year and had some knee problems so it is a risk to get someone who may not lineup for the team, maybe GWS has some medical knowledge that he was going to play restricted games due to the problems

[old55 21,352]

Will be fascinating to see how the Hawks get Wingard and Scully.  Still after that Hannebury trade I'll believe anything!

[Deevout 449]

30 minutes ago, TGR said:

Contrast the way that the Geelong supporters handled Ablett's departure, versus the way our supporters handle Scully's departure.

During his time here, we were a rabble.  Senior players and staff used to pull Scully down with the "over-training" accusation, rather than seeing that a 19 year old was actually setting decent training standards.

Why would he come back here, playing for supporters that really have half a brain.

 

Clarko is on the money.  Scully has had his pay-day and will now accept unders.  Clarko is reaping the rewards of trading out dead wood when it should happen; not 3 years after.

Ablett was instrumental in getting the GFC it’s long awaited premiership. Son of a club legend.

Everything you say about Melbourne being a rabble at the time $cully was at the club would be most certainly true. Also his standards for training would be the same however....

A lot of us on this site are questioning him as a human being not a footballer. Liars are not my favourite kind of people. 

As for “supporters that really have half a brain” I would instead say many of them have honesty  and loyalty as a standard in their lives. EG: We love our club. 

Yes Clarko is the smartest and the best coach going around, but on this occasion for me, he is welcome to the $culldog. 

[Vineytime 783]

Hawks very smart, give up Burton and a couple of mid teen first round picks and land Scully / Wingard, draft picks are hit and miss, established players are not. 

Back into premiership contention IMO. 

[daisycutter 28,564]

whoever started this thread must be the sickest guy in the demoniverse

i feel dirty just opening this thread

[Demon3564 9]

22 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

whoever started this thread must be the sickest guy in the demoniverse

i feel dirty just opening this thread

I know who you are Daisycutter

 

Edited October 12, 2018 by Demon3564

[Balls14 29]

This is a serious chance of happening. 

Not naming sources. But this is a very, very serious chance of happening.

[Dwight Schrute 16,797]

Giants happy to accept an early second round.... 

5&23 for hogan 

so for hogan we’d get May, Kolo and Scully potentially. Fills 2 major holes and we are a massive show for the flag. 

[Matt Demon 1,385]

14 minutes ago, Balls14 said:

This is a serious chance of happening. 

Not naming sources. But this is a very, very serious chance of happening.

If we get what we want for Hogan I'd say May & Scully will both be at Melbourne next year.

[Bang Bang Bang 5,490]

15 minutes ago, Balls14 said:

This is a serious chance of happening. 

Not naming sources. But this is a very, very serious chance of happening.

To us?!?

Balls14 doesn't have an extensive posting history but appears to be a normal fan with no history of big noting.

Scully coming back would break these servers forever.

[Demonland 65,270]

I'll take him back if GW$ pay his salary.

[Diamond_Jim 11,781]

16 minutes ago, Patches O’houlihan said:

Giants happy to accept an early second round.... 

5&23 for hogan 

so for hogan we’d get May, Kolo and Scully potentially. Fills 2 major holes and we are a massive show for the flag. 

get away Satan

[Wiseblood 24,636]

It's a shame it's Scully as he's the exact type of player we need.

I doubt, after the fall out of him leaving all those years ago, that he would want to come back here or feel comfortable doing so.

[Guest]

The Saints are now expressing interest in Voldemort.

If he was upset at the party atmosphere at Melbourne, I wonder if he has heard of a little thing called the Saints Disco? 

[demon191919 60]

.@TomBrowne7 reports Hawthorn is satisfied with Tom Scully’s medical and he will join Hawthorn for a relatively late pick. Only finer details of trade being finalised with announcement in the next few days. #7AFL #7News

[Diamond_Jim 11,781]

Just now, Wiseblood said:

It's a shame it's Scully as he's the exact type of player we need.

I doubt, after the fall out of him leaving all those years ago, that he would want to come back here or feel comfortable doing so.

yeah but within a week we'd be killing the fattened calf and telling the story of the return of the prodigal son.

Memories are short whatever people like to think

[Demonland 65,270]

Just now, demon191919 said:

.@TomBrowne7 reports Hawthorn is satisfied with Tom Scully’s medical and he will join Hawthorn for a relatively late pick. Only finer details of trade being finalised with announcement in the next few days. #7AFL #7News

The Giants must be in serious Cap trouble if they have to unload Scully for a "relatively late pick" with Shiel leaving as well. Happy that the throwing around of money has bit them on the bum.

[Demonland 65,270]

3 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

It's a shame it's Scully as he's the exact type of player we need.

I doubt, after the fall out of him leaving all those years ago, that he would want to come back here or feel comfortable doing so.

Not a chance he is coming back.

Agree that he is exactly what we need and we in turn fit what he is looking for in a team within the premiership window but there is just too much bad blood. This is not even remotely like Ablett returning to Geelong.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Just now, Demonland said:

The Giants must be in serious Cap trouble if they have to unload Scully for a "relatively late pick" with Shiel leaving as well. Happy that the throwing around of money has bit them on the bum.

'Satisfied' with his medical suggests that he may take some time to get back to full fitness.  I can't see GWS off loading Scully, who is apparently only on 500k next year, for peanuts if they don't believe there is a potentially serious issue with his ankle.

[Jaded No More 58,035]

All this does is give them the ability to keep Kelly and Weitfield which is bad for us.

Scully [censored] us again!

Edited October 12, 2018 by Jaded

[Balls14 29]

All I will say at this stage is what I was told yesterday morning:

1. Scully was also told the same thing as Dylan Shiel. Scully didnt take kindly to this. GWS still need to clear cap space.

2. Scully's put the feelers out. We were keen.

3. This was discussed by people within the club yesterday with little resistance. Only one person with in management was dead set against the idea.

4. Three way trade involving Fremantle, GWS & Melbourne had preliminary discussions after the initial Fremantle offer for Hogan was declined. Lobb, Scully, Hogan and a flurry of picks have been discussed. Melbourne are trying to get their hands on 5 (which is public knowledge) to get May done and GWS are looking to find a suitable deal to clear Scully off their books. 

5. Hawthorn have been deep into Scully for two weeks now and have had discussions with Hawthorn about a trade. GWS dont think Hawthorn have the currency to suffice them. 

[Demonland 65,270]

Just now, Jaded said:

All this does is give them the ability to keep Kelly and Weitfield which is bad for us.

Scully [censored] us again!

This post is on the money. Pardon the $cully/GW$ pun.

[Diamond_Jim 11,781]

1 minute ago, Demonland said:

The Giants must be in serious Cap trouble if they have to unload Scully for a "relatively late pick" with Shiel leaving as well. Happy that the throwing around of money has bit them on the bum.

no doubt that they had identified the last two years for premierships and that next year was a bonus.

and of course Lobb is going as well... that's $2M to $2.5M and no one coming in of note

[SFebes 4,692]

7 minutes ago, demon191919 said:

.@TomBrowne7 reports Hawthorn is satisfied with Tom Scully’s medical and he will join Hawthorn for a relatively late pick. Only finer details of trade being finalised with announcement in the next few days. #7AFL #7News

Late pick, bloody hell thats a steal.

[Demonland 65,270]

Just now, Balls14 said:

5. Hawthorn have been deep into Scully for two weeks now and have had discussions with Hawthorn about a trade. GWS dont think Hawthorn have the currency to suffice them. 

What currency do we have that Hawthorn don't. We're pick paupers at the moment.