I thought they were cutting down on this? Didn't Clarry get a fine in the JLT for less than this.

 

Typical double standards of the AFL; hysterical about some forms of violence, uninterested in other forms.

Pathetic!

So you are now allowed to punch someone in the guts with the ball no where in sight?

Great game we have this AFL

How that umpire standing on the edge of the square didnt see it or even pay a free is beyond me. It was a cheap shot. 

37 minutes ago, Demonland said:

I thought they were cutting down on this? Didn't Clarry get a fine in the JLT for less than this.

 

Seriously what do you really expect from such a corrupt and compromised organisation as AFL and their henchman at match review.

Blatant double standards.

I will never forget Bernie being reduced to vomiting after some north thug gut punched him which was also ignored.

Such a bunch of bloody blatant hypocrites.

 Behind the play

At stoppage

Fist punch

Body

Medium impact

2- weeks with 1-week I’m guilty plea

a fine is a joke !!!!!! Sums up the ridiculously bad umpiring and those in control !!  

FFS this makes me angry. if you look at where that punch is aimed its right on clarrys  solar plexus. Which, if youve ever been punched there is both painful and a bit debilitating. Honestly..how the f@uck does he get away with that??! Imagine if it were the other way around. Im really sick of the shite this club and especially this player puts up with. Wish SOMEONE in this, What often seems like an overly polite, [censored] weak club would speak up for us. This is the trouble with taking AFL money I suppose. 

To be accurate, he did get a penalty ($1500), but no suspension. 

While we're talking about the 20/20 sight of maggots, did anyone see the Boundary maggot who paid out of bounce, when behind play, on the boundary, where he would have had to have seen through two players, when another Boundary maggot who was ten metres ahead of play on the boundary, didn't call the ball out at all. I guess they were just watching the great game.......

8 minutes ago, monoccular said:

Seriously what do you really expect from such a corrupt and compromised organisation as AFL and their henchman at match review.

Blatant double standards.

I will never forget Bernie being reduced to vomiting after some north thug gut punched him which was also ignored.

Such a bunch of bloody blatant hypocrites.

I’m surprised at myself for getting angry over this. Just when I started to calm down. It’s not a joke anymore as it’s no longer funny. 

I suppose Steele threw his arms out saying he didn’t touch him. Is this the same schmuck that a threw a cheap one at Max’s back the first time we played them at Etihad 8 weeks ago?

Open hand to the stomach. Low impact.

Probably would have been looked at if Oliver didn't exaggerate contact. He needs to cut this out of his game.

Should have been a fine based on what Oliver copped in JLT.

 

I'm more peeved that we didn't get a free kick. Also wasn't the only time Oliver got hit at a stoppage.

6 minutes ago, BAMF said:

Open hand to the stomach. Low impact.

Probably would have been looked at if Oliver didn't exaggerate contact. He needs to cut this out of his game.

Should have been a fine based on what Oliver copped in JLT.

 

He was fined. 

43 minutes ago, DeeZee said:

Pathetic!

So you are now allowed to punch someone in the guts with the ball no where in sight?

Great game we have this AFL

A precedent. Barry Hall's preliminary final hit on the poor Saints player. A cheap shot straight in the guts. To be fair to Barry, it was in play. The ball was about 90 metres away so quite close really.

Do we ever niggle back

14 minutes ago, BAMF said:

Open hand to the stomach. Low impact.

Probably would have been looked at if Oliver didn't exaggerate contact. He needs to cut this out of his game.

Should have been a fine based on what Oliver copped in JLT.

 

BAMF - clearly YOU have never received a totally unanticipated punch in the guts.  Next there will be folk suggesting that Oliver is a serial diver (which is what you are implying) and maybe should be fined or even suspended for that.

Should Franklin have got a week also?

1 minute ago, SFebey said:

Should Franklin have got a week also?

Would have got two were he wearing red n blue, but he isn't and he is also Franklin.

Edited July 2, 20186 yr by monoccular

1 minute ago, monoccular said:

Would have got two were he wearing red n blue, but he isn't and he is also Franklin.

Between umpiring and MRP the game has me confused that’s for sure and agree totally, especially last year he would’ve got 3-4

arms by his side, not expecting it, right in the solar plexus,its enough to wind a person.

It's open season on our players from opposition players and umpires since we were 8-3. Will continue until we are out of contention.

15 minutes ago, monoccular said:

BAMF - clearly YOU have never received a totally unanticipated punch in the guts.  Next there will be folk suggesting that Oliver is a serial diver (which is what you are implying) and maybe should be fined or even suspended for that.

Actually, the reason why I have such a strong opinion is because I HAVE been punched in guts unanticipated.

Well, to be fair, as a 17 year old who could run all day and had pace to burn playing against men in a tough league I was always sort of expecting some attention. Nothing like a punch in the gut to slow a young player down to your speed. I have copped much worse than that hit on Oliver.

I completely feel for Oliver. He was coping a hard tag, and while I didn't see any other physical contact, no doubt there was.

I am glad the AFL are issuing fines to stomp this out. 

I feel he goes to ground too easily. The contact is there, but he exaggerates. He has done it a few times. Its not too late for him to stop.

I also dislike how Vince does it on regular occurrence.

I also have a severe dislike for Rance, Lindsy Thomas, Toby Mclean and Rhys Matherson.

I think a fine is what it deserved. Players are shoving chests every game and Steele went a bit low and caught Clarry by surprise. Low impact blah blah move on.

I am more interested in the fact that it was the easiest free kick for the umpires to call all day. Hits before the bounce like that are called often. The umpire at the centre bounce had his back turned but there were at least two other field umpires watching what occured. I watched them sort of flinch and then relax as the umpire bounced the ball but it felt like more then enough time. I'd like cheap hits before the bounce in the centre to be something umpires look at.

Maybe it can be rule of the week.

1 hour ago, BAMF said:

Open hand to the stomach. Low impact.

Probably would have been looked at if Oliver didn't exaggerate contact. He needs to cut this out of his game.

Should have been a fine based on what Oliver copped in JLT.

 

exaggerated? he was caught totally unawares, didn't see it coming, check the video

not even sure it was open handed either

most annoying was not one maggot saw it and paid a free even though one would have to be blind

Are you guys still surprised that the umpires and MRP are sh*t?