Just watching this game and the domination of the GWS midfield stars.  As a hypothetical, assuming we could get the trade done and GWS played ball, which one would you take? 

No brainer for me - Josh Kelly.

Kelly as he is just the type of player we need.

But Shiel is my fave.

it's like being asked to pick from the chocolate box........so many........so good.............I don't know

So do we judge last week, this week or next week?

Edited September 16, 20178 yr by Satyriconhome

Kelly for me is the best inside/outside mid. Although Shiel is only just behind him. 

Virtually any of them would drastically improve our side. 

Given our good trading relationship with GWS, I wonder if we have approached them for anyone.

Kelly suits our needs most, but Coniglio does it all. One of best all round mids in the game.

i'd rather see them boiled.

Scully

And then I would play him at Casey every week.

Yes, I am that vindictive.....

Other- Toby Greene, I don't care what position he plays.

Any of their midfield walks into ours.....

Scully's gut running is what we need 

Oliver will be better than all of them.

From what I saw last night, Coniglio.

I would trade Dom Tyson and Salem for Josh Kelly?

Bring back Tom all is forgiven!

9 hours ago, jackaub said:

Bring back Tom all is forgiven!

That would be one of the funniest turn of events ever! 

With GWS signing up Kelly maybe we should look at making a play for one of their young midfield guns, I'm not across their list like others are but I remember when the snatched Scully from us we vowed to get one back on them. So far Tyson, Frost, and Bugg are the only players of significance to come across and they aren't amazing in the grand scheme.

Jacob Hopper looks a player with a big future. Would be very handy in most teams.

i'd like to punch Greene and poach Kelly.

5 hours ago, Biffen said:

i'd like to punch Greene and poach Kelly.

Lucky we've got Buggy and I 'd poach $cully !

3 hours ago, puntkick said:

Lucky we've got Buggy and I 'd poach $cully !

Yeah, I'd poach Scully too.  With fava beans and a nice chianti.

Edited September 18, 20178 yr by ProperDee

On 17/09/2017 at 10:51 AM, Is Dom Is Good said:

Oliver will be better than all of them.

Probably, but he is only one. 

16 hours ago, ProperDee said:

Yeah, I'd poach Scully too.  With fava beans and a nice chianti.

Thanks, Dr Lechter.  I would prefer him deep fried in thick batter: his dad may object at not being invited to partake in the fest though.