Post Match Discussion - Round 23

[dave 183]

20 minutes ago, McQueen said:

Brownie just said that the Eagles will need to win by at least 25 points tomorrow.

I know we don't really deserve it after today but that's life.

Eagles will beat Crows by more than 25 because they know they have to and they're not mentally weak(at home) like we are

[Chook 15,022]

Let's analyse the performances of our leadership group today:

Nathan Jones: C. Tried hard but was ultimately ineffectual. Terrible disposal
Jack Viney: UG. Not there, and boy did we miss him.
Max Gawn: F. God-awful rucking, terrible effort around the ground, atrocious body language, and missed a crucial goal while his opposite number destroyed him offensively.
Jordan Lewis: D. Good early, but totally found out by the pace of the game.
Tom McDonald: F. Terrible body language, abysmal disposal, but also hard-done by the umpires.
Bernie Vince: F. Was possibly playing for Collingwood, I'm not sure.

Our young kids actually pulled this game out of the fire these blokes started.

[Bring-Back-Powell 15,068]

Special shout out to Bernie Vince for that putrid shot at goal in the last second that wouldve made West Coast's job that little bit harder.

[Webber 10,570]

23 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Just got home, haven't seen a second of the game, but it's clear that we went with the choke this afternoon.  So terribly deflating and disappointing.

I know our season isn't over just yet, but at the same time, I'd be shattered if it was as I'm not ready for it to be at all.  If this does end our season it will leave a very sour taste in the mouth.

For those who watched the game - what was the problem today?  Did we look nervous early and couldn't claw our way back in?  Or did the Pies simply want it more?

Poor mental prep for the start of the game.....played like they had a lot to lose, which we did, and coughed up the win. The bigger problem, and sad to say it's going to stop us going much further in the coming years, is our contested marking. We are the worst in the AFL, and oppo teams are now exploiting it. That and the fact we've lost our clearance and stoppage domination due to who knows what, means the future's not so bright as it might have appeared, finals or no. 

[jumbo returns 6,741]

I hope Peddo and Hoges recover quickly...

[Dockett 32 1,239]

Lost in the first quarter. Finally we conclusively know who can't cut it when it's all on the line. Get rid of them. Analysis made easy for list management staff.

[Demonstone 23,122]

Result of the Eagles/Crows will be irrelevant after Freo knocks off Essendon.

[McQueen 17,867]

Eagles will win tomorrow.

Nothing surer.

[goodwindees 2,586]

Absolutely smashed in the midfield.  Harmes hasn't touched it, Hannan has his usual 5 minute cameo, Tom Mac was nearly our worst again, really missed Frost's run out of the backline, field kicking was D Grade. 

Lever would be nice but gee we need some serious young midfielders as Vince is gone and the end is coming quickly for a couple of others. 

[dees189227 12,441]

Typical Melbourne. Making us wait until tomorrow night to see if we play finals.  

That 1st quarter killed us. No tackle pressure was just useless.  

We missed easy goals, did stupid turnovers and in the final moments just blazed away. 

I know goodwin is a calm coach but i hope he gave it to them after the game. 

[DeeZee 7,445]

All we can do now is barrack for the Crows

[GCDee 3,199]

Tommy Mac needs to stop sooking when not getting a free it looks appalling. 

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,464]

On the back of that crap :

Membership prices should be frozen for next year. 

The whole club should be on a Jack Riewoldt self media ban.

And no player should be seen celebrating anything on field again until we've won a flag. 

[Wiseblood 24,637]

2 minutes ago, RalphiusMaximus said:

5 frees to 0 in the first quarter to help the Pies build that match-winning lead.  Some absolutely baffling non-calls that could have helped us get back into it.  That being said, we were pathetic in the first and deserved to be well down. 

It's our forward 50 entries.  You can talk about the poor first quarter or the fact that Collingwood tackled more and we hardly tackled at all, but ultimately we had every opportunity to win this even with the [censored]-poor first quarter, the umpiring and the lack of effort.  Where we lost this game is exactly the same place we've lost most of our games.  We get into a good attacking position, then butcher the forward 50 entry and stand there scratching our collective head as the opposition run the ball back down the ground.  Chaplin has been a liability all season and I can't see any evidence that he's learning from his failures. 

Cheers Ralph.  That has certainly been a problem for us, especially in the second half of the year, and it looks as though it has reared it's ugly head again today which is disappointing.

We are doing most other things right, so hopefully Goodwin and co. can rectify this over the summer.

[Satyriconhome 10,880]

We have been trying not to lose for the last few weeks and playing accordingly, I went along expecting us to not handle the occasion, not even sure why some are surprised

[SaberFang 7,151]

Just now, demonstone said:

Result of the Eagles/Crows will be irrelevant after Freo knocks off Essendon.

Unlike us, Essendon will not fail at the prospect of beating a rabble to make the finals. It's the only guaranteed outcome this round, the Drug Cheats will win and secure their place in finals.

[dave 183]

Even it we do make finals, and we do not deserve it,  we'll be straight out anyway

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

Dont know what's worse.  Travelling home on the Glen Waverley with a whole bunch of grumpy Demon supporters grumbling or listening to the Pies chant....COLL.   LING  WOOOOD in the last 5 minutes

[At the break of Gawn 4,460]

3 minutes ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Special shout out to Bernie Vince for that putrid shot at goal in the last second that wouldve made West Coast's job that little bit harder.

That was so [censored] lazy. Pathetic

[Webber 10,570]

4 minutes ago, dave said:

Eagles will beat Crows by more than 25 because they know they have to and they're not mentally weak(at home) like we are

Seems very likely. 

[Age 485]

3 minutes ago, jumbo returns said:

I hope Peddo and Hoges recover quickly...

They've got about 6 months to get right now...

[Return to Glory 8,448]

3 minutes ago, leave it to deever said:

Thanks RTG I really needed a laugh.

So do I. In fairness, we've just seen a spot of black humour.

[leave it to deever 17,561]

Just now, Return to Glory said:

So do I. In fairness, we've just seen a spot of black humour.

Cheer up at least it makes tmws game worth watching.

[dee-tox 4,835]

Notice a couple of posters potting Jones. Not deserved.  Too easy a target. Other so-called leaders like McDonald, Vince and Gawn were awful.

[Demonsone 2,050]

8 minutes ago, watchtheeyes said:

If we make finals, we deserve finals. This whole 'we don't deserve to be in finals' is crap.

Are we ready for finals? No way..

If the playing group believed  they deserved finals they would have won...hate saying this,but  a typical MFC result!

Goodwin may say history has no  bearing on current  results but something is wrong with our leadership/culture that our players didn't turn up for such an important game with an opportunity to secure a finals spot!

Clearly either way if we don't or do play finals the list needs to find more mongrel  e.g. Hibberd