Off vision I have seen to date (not best quality) Hogan looks like he threw a perfect jab, that would earn him a point in the ring, and a week in the naughty corner. However I think Lewis and Vince are playing to instructions, and the suggestion of internal club fines is ludicrous, the team is searching for an edge, I think Goodwin is willing to risk the sanctions. However Hogans' snap though was not niggle or unsociable - not his role, he already strikes me as pretty bloody 'anti-social' .  

It wasn't a perfect jab. It was a closed fist but he hit with his palm side, fingers facing up. You can pause it and see that clearly. 

To cop a week they'll need to say it was worth 2 Was it? No way in my eyes. Should be a fine. Gut feel is they'll say 2 down to one because we get no luck with those inconsistent idiots. 

 

Lewis I can't really tell how hard he hit him, I'd be saying Cripps took a dive and then Viney ran him over which is why he stayed down like he was playing for Man United. 

Hey DA, managed to check it out again, maybe not Sugar Ray but pretty decent all the same, I thought the speed was good didn't you? I think the same re sanction.

      I don't  know  who  will  get  what,  but  I  do  know  the  Lewis  one  was  STUPID.  As  a  result  of  a  contest  to  see  who  can  [censored]  up  a  wall  higher, and  the  wrestling  continued,  the  umpire  threw  up  the  ball  in the  center  of  the  ground,  and  we  only  had  THREE  to  contest  the  ball  up.  And  guess  who  did  the  ruck  work?  Yes  our  premier  ruckman  number  13,  Oliver.

    How  professional  was  that?  STUPID.  By  the  way  they  easiely  won  the  center  clearance.

9 hours ago, Unleash Hell said:

Unsociable Dees

Like

Key players not getting rubbed out

Like

1 minute ago, Nasher said:

Key players not getting rubbed out

Like

No cheap shots off the ball, like even more.

9 hours ago, Unleash Hell said:

Unsociable Dees

Like

But it is so counterproductive if you are sitting in the stand following week(s). Does anyone actually believe that off the ball stuff had a positive effect for us? Attack the ball hard, attack them hard when they have the ball but leave the cheap shots out of it

The only thing unsociable about it is you don't get to run around with your mates the next Saturday 

"5. Jordan Lewis was the poster boy for the 'unsociable Hawks' during that club's dominant era. But now it is Melbourne's turn to face that anxious wait for the Match Review Panel to do its thing every Monday morning. Lewis should just be OK for the clash with Carlton's Patrick Cripps, as should Jesse Hogan for his incident with Sam Rowe. If not, then a terrific twilight game next Saturday against Geelong will be that bit tougher for the Demons, who are 2-0 for the first time since 2005, to negotiate."

 

There is a lot of delusion on here. 

Hogan was was round left jab. In slow mo the Carlton players jaw goes sideways. 

He was dropped and dazed.

4 weeks with good record down to 3 IMO

The last time we were unsociable was during the Northey years. For long periods after it was an aberration for one of our players to get reported. 

Edited April 2, 20178 yr by america de cali

Intentional. High contact. 1 million points

Edited April 2, 20178 yr by gOLLy

9 minutes ago, gOLLy said:

There is a lot of delusion on here. 

Hogan was was round left jab. In slow mo the Carlton players jaw goes sideways. 

He was dropped and dazed.

4 weeks with good record down to 3 IMO

 I'm sure it was April fools day yesterday. If he gets done for more than 2 I'll be shocked. My gut feel is 1 week down to a reprimand. I don't think he even needed a concussion test. 

If he gets 1 week then so be it. 

1 hour ago, Nasher said:

Key players not getting rubbed out

Like

 

46 minutes ago, fndee said:

But it is so counterproductive if you are sitting in the stand following week(s). Does anyone actually believe that off the ball stuff had a positive effect for us? Attack the ball hard, attack them hard when they have the ball but leave the cheap shots out of it

The only thing unsociable about it is you don't get to run around with your mates the next Saturday 

Not attacking u guys personally 

There wasnt much in both incidents. 

Apparently we have depth so it's a good opportunity to test it.

At least find out the results before you guys sook it up.

I'll take unsociable over the p weak crap dealt up in the past any day.

Didn't we beat the cats without hogan and lewis in 2015?

#raisehell

#hardenupyblokes

#pissweskclubispissweak

I'd say Hogan gets 2 down to 1. It was intentional, high contact, minimal force. Exactly the same as Vince. 

The only thing working in his favour is no track record.

Lewis is hard to tell, could be 1 or just a fine. Cripps only fell over when Viney bumped him.

11 hours ago, small but forward said:

I'm sure the MRP have a spinning wheel which decides the penalty, so they won't know either until the wheel stops

Absolutely!!

Hogan will get 1 week, reduced to a fine.

I don't even think Lewis got Cripps in the head.  He'll be fine.

Bernie Vince on the Sunday rub said that the only reason he got the 1 week was because Wright he went off for a concussion test. Vince said that even though he passed the test he he still had no argument whatsoever.

 

If thats the case both players didn't go off after the incident for any tests. Lewis i think will get a fine and Hogan well who knows.

Just heard on SEN that the general consensus was that Lewis would get 2-3 weeks and Hogan 1 week. Hope they are wrong. 

Hogan 2 weeks, Lewis 1. Stupid form both players!

Just now, qwerty7 said:

Just heard on SEN that the general consensus was that Lewis would get 2-3 weeks and Hogan 1 week. Hope they are wrong. 

Surprised they would say that about Lewis.  I know he has a dodgy past, but it clearly looks as though he gets him in the shoulder.  Cripps doesn't even look like going down until Viney shoves him in the back.

Hogan should be a reprimand. His opponent went for him shortly beforehand and Hogan responded in kind.

There was not much in it.

It looked to me like a round arm slap and the Blue made the most of it, but then I have not studied the footage in slow motion. If the Blue's jaw went sideways like some here are describing he must have roller bearings rather than the conventional ligaments that operate the mandible.

I think Rowe took his acting career to the next level when he stood up and rolled his eyes into the back of his head. 

15 hours ago, Bimbo said:

Rowe should get a week for acting

And, to think, Carlton once accused us of playing 'bruise-free football'. The irony.

Rowe went down like a show pony striker playing for Uruguay against the Socceroos in a World Cup Qualifier.

 

They'll both be fortunate if they get only 1 week.

24 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Surprised they would say that about Lewis.  I know he has a dodgy past, but it clearly looks as though he gets him in the shoulder.  Cripps doesn't even look like going down until Viney shoves him in the back.

Spot on.

The force that would Cripps down was Viney and this is why i think he will get off. Cripps stayed on the field and continued on. If it was such force to the head he would have done a concussion test which was proven to have gottwn Vince the 1 week.