Please cast your votes after the final siren ...

6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1

6. Nick Foot (central umpire)

5. Luke Farmer (field umpire)

4. Brett Dalgliesh (boundary)

3. Brendan Hosking (field)

2. Nathan Doig (boundary)

1. Max Gawn

6. N Jones

5. Kent

4. Gawn

3. Petracca

2. Frost

1. Stretch

6. Kent

5. Gawn

4. Jones

3. Watts

2. Petracca

1. Vince

N Jones

Gawn

Watts

Viney

Frost

M Jones 

6 - N.Jones - some brain fades but was indefatigable and prolific

5 - Gawn - dynamic and dominant in the centre

4 - Frost - may have come of age.. a joy to watch coming out of defence

3 - Kent - aggressive , feisty and clever

2 - Watts - has been better this year but performed all over the field

1 - M.Jones - unfashionable but has improved significantly over the year

Edited July 23, 20169 yr by joeboy

6. Gawn

5. Jones

4. Watts

3. Kent

2. Petracca

1. Tyson

6. N Jones

5 Gawn

4 Vince

3 Viney 

2 watts

1 frost 

6.  N. Jones

5.  Gawn

4.  Frost

3.  Watts

2.  Kent

1.  Petracca

6. N Jones - Th next person who says this bloke isn't an A grade footballer needs to uppercut themselves immediately

5. Gawn - Star

4. Frost - Best of the back six. Finally starting to use his size and strength along with his speed

3. M Jones - Have to go close to his best game for the club. Didn't do a thing wrong all day that I can recall

2. Kent - A mixed bag but the good outweighed the bad. Very laconic at times, to put it kindly

1. Tyson - Lots of the ball, lots of tackles, lots of work rate, could've used it lots better

 

6 N.Jones

5 Gawn

4 Frost

3 Kent

2 Watts

1 Tyson

 

-5 o.mcd ... thats negative 40. 8 poor games in 9 weeks. o.mcd is a LIABILITY (Dunn and Garland must be wondering about the fairness in selection).

6 N. Jones

5 Tyson

4 Gawn

3 Viney

2 Petracca

1 Hunt

6. N.Jones

5. Gawn

4. Viney

3. Tyson

2. Frost

1. Stretch

6 Nathan Jones : playing outside mid

5 Matt Jones

4 Max the magnificent

3 Jack Watts

2 Tmac

1 Billy Stretch/Petracca 

Jack Viney got caught too many times trying to gat onto his left side . Good side will block him off too easy

We continually criticise tornoveres from the defence, but ignore the midfield turnovers whic leave us even more vulnerable

 

6 Gawn

5 N Jones

4 Kent

3 Garlett

2 Frost

1 Jetta

 

6 Gawn - Really tried to lift us and was noticeable when he was off because Watts was killed in ruck area.

5 N.Jones - Not always clean but kept working. 

4 Frost - Great dash from the backline. Why did we all have to wait until Round 11 for him to be played as a defender.

3 T Mac - A couple of late kicking howlers spoiled what was a superb game - he wasn't Robinson Crusoe with the poor kicks though - hence no Vince or Viney this week.

2 Kent - Ran his heart out pressuring and if only Dawesy had figured out he was free early in last quarter.

1 Petracca - Great to see him really use his kicks well. He will be something - just not this year.

Apologies: Yes I did notice Matt Jones and had him in my top four Dees at half time. He faded in second half though. His best game yet for us though and there won't be any calls from me for his omission next week. Indeed it would be hard to find anyone worthy of the axe next week. We kick well and we win away by five goals.

Sorry I just realised I left out Tyson - who was our best player to half time. With more time he gets 3 from me and the others move down one.

Edited July 23, 20169 yr by Deespicable

6  Gawn

5  Tyson

4  N Jones

3  Watts

2  M Jones

1  Petracca/Frost/TMac/Kent/Garlett

6.  N. Jones  

5.  Gawn

4.  Tyson

3.  Frost

2.  M.Jones

1.  Kent

6. N. Jones

5. Gawn

4. Tyson

3. Tmac

2. Petracca

1. M Jones

 

Surely Wellingham gets a vote or two for us. 

6 N Jones

5 Gawn

4 Tyson

3 Viney

2 Watts

1 Kent

Love it when it's difficult to limit the votes to 6 and pray for the days when this is a regular occurrence

6. N Jones -awesome captains display willed himself to win contests and was everywhere with his run on the outside 

5. Gawny - went up against 2 ruckmen intent on jumping into him all day and a 3rd man up but won hands down and was influential around the ground 

4. Kent - fantastic run and pressure acts all day. Used the ball really well and providing more than just dash at last

3. Frost - clear best defender on the ground who not only dominated with muscle and size but provided plenty of dash out of the backline 

2. Viney -just hard at it all day ran himself into the ground to get on the end of kicks and handballs to provide a link up

1. Petracca - very clean in conditions which weren't helpful to this but his ball use was exceptional. Showed great strength and power

Apologies to Watts Matty Jones Tyson and Stretch 

1.  Jones

2.  Gawn

3.  Tyson

4.  Viney

5.  Stretch

6.  Watts

 

Watts and Stretch get in because every time they get the ball we get another possession.  The rest are self explanatory.  I'm surprised by the love for Kent.  Great last half but he touched it 4 times in the first half and in addition tried to mark a ball in the square that was going through. If he'd reversed his half's he wouldn't have got much recognition.

We desperately need him to get some consistency through games because he adds so much when he's on.  He never inspires confidence with the ball and misses what many get. To me he's a very frustrating player.

19 hours ago, Return to Glory said:

6. Nick Foot (central umpire)

5. Luke Farmer (field umpire)

4. Brett Dalgliesh (boundary)

3. Brendan Hosking (field)

2. Nathan Doig (boundary)

1. Max Gawn

They did seem to have an influence, didn't they? 

1 minute ago, RalphiusMaximus said:

They did seem to have an influence, didn't they? 

Less angry today but, yes, there's no doubt they did yesterday. We do need to take it out of the umpire's hands though.

If West Coast has a three goal advantage at home we need to be a four goal better side (Confucius)