Proven right today. So many non-perceptive fans with their blinkers on in this forum who couldn't see how St Kilda's winning performances were a more mature brand of football than ours.

Edited July 17, 20169 yr by johndemons

Just now, stuie said:

Tired.

 

Nope we're not good enough when it matters. If Wagner, OMac, Hunt, Brayshaw, petracca, Harmes, White, etc stick around and play 30 games together they'll get there.

We've been outcoached today.  Simple as that.  After quarter time they shut down our half back line and stopped our half forwards from being damaging as well.

Plus it doesn't help when you kick long to the wing so they can pick it off easily.  

Again, they have a system at stoppages.

We have British Bulldogs

2 minutes ago, Mickey said:

When they get tackled, they put it on the boot and get it moving forward. When we get tackled, we handball...

This

That last passage of play was frighteningly bad

1 minute ago, dee-tox said:

Nope we're not good enough when it matters. If Wagner, OMac, Hunt, Brayshaw, petracca, Harmes, White, etc stick around and play 30 games together they'll get there.

Yeah just beaten comfortably by an experienced top 4 team today.... Oh wait...

 

Edited July 17, 20169 yr by stuie

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!

thank f**k I didn't go 

Can we start by trying to win the tackle count for once please

1 minute ago, johndemons said:

Proven right today. So many non-perceptive fans with their blinkers on in this forum who couldn't see how St Kilda's winning performances were a more mature brand of football than ours.

yes and two of their better performers have been Roo and Joey.  Will be so happy when these two retire.

They play one on one when we have the ball... There is no zone. Then they work their ass off the other way

Just now, Wiseblood said:

We've been outcoached today.  Simple as that.  After quarter time they shut down our half back line and stopped our half forwards from being damaging as well.

Plus it doesn't help when you kick long to the wing so they can pick it off easily.  

We need a game-day tactician on the coaching panel.

I've forgotten about it already.

White, Grimes, Omac and Wagner does not a backline make. 

We really over rate our lot

I feel more confident playing Hawthorn than St Kilda

Just now, Akum said:

We have no system at stoppages. Gawn just hits it & 3 dive on the ball. That's not a system.

Every other team has a system. One goes for the ball, the other two wait for the give.

Dumb.

This is a team we should beat every time.

 

Why should we beat them every time? They're a better team than us by every measure. This idea that we're better than St. Kilda is just delusional. Please tell me how you work it out? 

We are not better than the Saints, Melbourne fans need to stop saying that we are. BUT we should be at least close to on par and therefor we should be at least winning close to 50%, the fact we aren't shows a massive mental weakness.

Just now, Mickey said:

They play one on one when we have the ball... There is no zone. Then they work their ass off the other way

Yes, but is it a workable game plan going forward - i.e. do you think they'll be winning finals games with that plan in the next couple of years?

Love Jack  Grimes but think game    100 will be his last

Would be nice to play this mob of [censored] on the MCG in Winter next year... Soft pricks can keep your indoor arena!

Roos better not say we were tired. Will lose my [censored]

We are kidding ourselves!!

We look so ...... TIRED