6. Viney

5. Gawn

4. Tyson

3. Garlett

2. Vince

1. Kent

 

6. Viney

5. Gawn

4. Tyson

3. Vince

2. Kent

1. Garlett

 

Hard to give TMac votes because of that disposal.

Pedo, Bugg, etc unlucky.

6 . Gawn

5. Viney

4. Tyson

3. Vince

2. Garlett

1. McDonald

6. Viney

5. Gawn

4. Tyson

3. Garlett

2. Vince

1. McDonald

6. Gawn - Absolute beast. Set up our offense. Gawn shows the true value of a quality ruckman, his tap work is invaluable.

5. Viney - Grunt work exceptional. Second and third efforts didn't go unnoticed, an absolute bull, a real leader of men.

4. Garlett - Forward pressure amazing, ability to kick goals when we need them - impressive. Any other day he would be BOG, top 2 had amazing days.

3. Tyson - Massive day today. Tyson is capable of big days, he is levels above his recent output, and today shown that. Great game, more of it plz.

2. Vince - Classy performer, tough as nails.

1. Kent - Continues to impress, ooozes potential - starting to deliver.

 

Honorable mentions - Hunt, Bugg, improved game from Salem, Jetta steady. TMAC stiff to miss the votes.

6  Gawn

5  Viney

4  Tyson

3  Vince

2  TMac  an Alpha athlete, in spite of 2 lousy disposals

1  Watts   Selfless, skilled & consistent

 

Garlett great

 Kent stiff

6 hours ago, Dee Dee said:

6: Viney

5: Gawn

4: Tyson

3: Watts

2: McDonald

1: Garlett

My votes are as per Dee Dee (above)

6 Viney - what a second half, was absolutely amazing, which makes it 3 x BOGs so far by my count

5 Gawn - awesome first half where he was everywhere

4 Tyson - contemplated giving him 6 because he was god for 4 quarters, but couldn't ignore the sheer impact of the above 2

3 Garlett - one of my favourites, took his chances and and makes defences nervous

2 Kent - that is now a consistent 3 week block where he has impacted games throughout, rather than just small cameos

1 McDonald - cut off so many attacks with some great intercept marking, but was let down by some poor disposal

6.Gawn

5.Viney

4.Tyson

3.Garlett

2.McDonald

1.Watts

I was a little too "tired" to post last night but here' s my view from the good seats

Max Gawn. Simply a colossus 

Viney. As usual a powerhouse in and around the contested ball

Garlett. Kicked 4 and had a hand in another 4.  A key member of the team.

T Mac. Strong marking and provided a real barrier in defence

Vince  Classy always and a good finisher. Also provides a bit of mongrel

Tyson's more even effort just pips JW for my final vote

Interesting...

Two years ago it would have been:

6:.Jones

5: er gee who else can I think of

etc. etc.

Now- Where's Jonsey? Mind you he was OK but as shown above we now have a team of contributors and not a one man team!

6 - Viney

5 - Gawn

4 - Garlett

3 - Kent

2 - Tyson

1 - McDonald

6. Gawn

5. Viney

4. Garlett

3. Tyson

2. Vince

1. Kent

6 - Viney - he is in AA form at the moment and was just a beats at every contest, he loves the jumper and the club and it shows, he is the leader this club has been crying out for

5 - Gawn -dominant around the ground and imposed himself seems to have the belief in himself and IMO just behind Goldy and ahead of Mummy as the leagues best ruckman

4 - Tyson - best game he has played for the club and an upgrade on his 2014 form

3 - Garlett - 4 goals isn't all he done his harassment and heat at the drop of the ball created uncertainty in with the Tigers defenders throughout the game, glad we got him right before bringing him back in  

2 - Vince - had the experience and poise at vital moments when the Toiges were coming I don't care that we gave up pick 20 for him, he has been invaluable to the club and to the development of Viney

1 - Kent -  gut running, hard chases and good decision making which is something if he does consistently will make him the player he can be  

3 hours ago, Dee Dee said:

Interesting...

Two years ago it would have been:

6:.Jones

5: er gee who else can I think of

etc. etc.

Now- Where's Jonsey? Mind you he was OK but as shown above we now have a team of contributors and not a one man team!

And where is Hogan when we kick over twenty goals like last night?

Edited April 25, 20169 yr by CBDees

5 Viney      top 3 split 6+5+4 all equally influential in final result

5 Gawn

5 Garlett

3 Tyson

2 Vince

1 Watts

 

6 . J Viney

5. M Gawn

4. T Bugg

3 . D Tyson

2 . T mac

1 . J Garlett

6. Gawn

5. Viney

4. Tyson

3. Kent

2. Vince

1. McDonald (even with those heart-in-mouth disposals)

6 - Viney

5 - Gawn

4 - Tyson

3 - Garlett

2 - Vince

1 - Kent

1.  Viney - four quarter effort and willed us to victory in the last.

2.  Gawn - exceptional first half

3.  Tyson - goal kicking mids are gold.

4.  Vince - silk

5.  Garlett - creative

6.  Salem - terrific first half and good second half.  Creative use by hand and precise kicking.  Very good decision maker and hurts the opposition when he gets it.  Underrated game.

Apology:  T Mac.  He would almost have been BOG but his turnovers hurt.  Just misses a spot in the six.

6 Viney 

5 Gawn 

4 Tyson

3 Vince

2 Watts 

1 Garlett 

6. Gawn

5. Tyson

4. Viney

3. Watts

2. Kent

1. Jeffy

Apologies to Salem, Wagner, Vince, Dunny, Lumumba and Nev

6. Viney

5. Gawn

4. Tyson

3. Vince

2. Garlett

1. Kent

6.  Viney

5.  Gawn

4.  Tyson

3.  Vince

2.  Garlett

1.  Tmac

6. Viney

5. Gawn

4. Tyson

3. Garlett

2. MacDonald

1. Vince