Essendon vs Melbourne MCG Round 2

[ManDee 7,162]

1 minute ago, daisycutter said:

what better satisfaction could you get than witnessing a jolly good thrashing?

Tempting.

[beelzebub 23,380]

2 minutes ago, ManDee said:

Tempting.

Not just beating them but wiping that smug grin off their faces. There in for years of pain , courtesy of Karma Inc

[Bitter but optimistic 22,242]

19 minutes ago, DubDee said:

I assume it will allowed for dees supporters to bring banners saying

beat the cheats and drug cheats etc? I'll be getting the textas out! Once I think of something witty enough

Keep it (very) simple mate.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,242]

14 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Can't believe people would contemplate boycotting the game. You're love of the Dee's should outweigh the hatred of Essendon. 

Hopefully I can make it over and grace you all with my presence. 

Please inform if you are Ethan and you can have the pleasure of buying me alcohol.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,242]

22 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

what better satisfaction could you get than witnessing a jolly good thrashing?

Administering a jolly good thrashing comes readily to mind.

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,400]

On 4 March 2016 at 1:55 PM, daisycutter said:

what better satisfaction could you get than witnessing a jolly good thrashing?

BBO?

(beat me to it....posting whilst driving)

[old55 23,625]

1 hour ago, beelzebub said:

remind me again what the punishment was actually  for ?

not tanking

[beelzebub 23,380]

56 minutes ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

I'll be there - louder and more obnoxious than usual, and I will be handing out plenty of free advice to all Essendon supporters within earshot.

is that even possible BBO ?  or are you taking a cue from the team and stepping up this season  ? 

[P-man 13,366]

1 hour ago, ManDee said:

So exactly what penalty did the club receive after the 34 were found guilty of receiving PED's?

You do mention some self inflicted wounds, but they have received no penalty.

How are fines and suspensions "self inflicted wounds"?

Much like our punishment for "bringing the game into disrepute..but definitely not tanking", Essenson have been punished. There have been some detours along the way, but they've been punished. How do you want to further punish them? More fines? Jail time? The club is stuffed for years to come. I hate them as much as anyone but get serious.

Your protest on the grounds they haven't been punished is flimsy at best, and ultimately meaningless. Attend the game and support YOUR team.

[pineapple dee 2,892]

This is a game I'll attend with relish. I went to the Essendon game last year and promptly went to Dan Murphys, bought a bottle of Oban whiskey and drank a third of it. Who says alcohol is not the answer ????

[ManDee 7,162]

4 minutes ago, P-man said:

How are fines and suspensions "self inflicted wounds"?

Much like our punishment for "bringing the game into disrepute..but definitely not tanking", Essenson have been punished. There have been some detours along the way, but they've been punished. How do you want to further punish them? More fines? Jail time? The club is stuffed for years to come. I hate them as much as anyone but get serious.

Your protest on the grounds they haven't been punished is flimsy at best, and ultimately meaningless. Attend the game and support YOUR team.

What fine or suspension did the club receive after the 34 players were found guilty of using PED's? --- NONE

If one attends the game one supports their team. Financial benefit. 

I will stick to my meaningless boycott and you can help fund EFC.

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,400]

The last Dees/Bombers game I went to was when Jordie was involved twice in our last passage of play which saw the ball ultimately fall into the hands of Salem who calmly slotted the goal.

[Deecisive 1,709]

It would be very disappointing for our players if the ground was only filled with opposition supporters. We should be there for our players not theirs. This is a game that we dare not take to lightly, they will have 24 players out their trying their best to beat us to prove a point. We need to have our best 24 players out their to prove our point and to take the points. Essendon's VFL side pantsed us last year, we must not let that happen again. Every demon support who can go should be there to cheer our team on and boo the opposition when appropriate.

 

Go Dees..

[Bitter but optimistic 22,242]

41 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

is that even possible BBO ?  or are you taking a cue from the team and stepping up this season  ? 

I constantly strive for self abuse  improvement bbub!

[P-man 13,366]

20 minutes ago, ManDee said:

What fine or suspension did the club receive after the 34 players were found guilty of using PED's? --- NONE

If one attends the game one supports their team. Financial benefit. 

I will stick to my meaningless boycott and you can help fund EFC.

Suit yourself. You are your own person. Make no mistake though that your "boycott" only achieves one less voice to cheer on the boys.

I can only hope others don't follow your idiotic example.

[GoldMember 15]

I wouldn't miss this game!

A really poor approach from the EFC i believe- I hope we really stick it to them & bury the bastards!

[ManDee 7,162]

18 minutes ago, P-man said:

Suit yourself. You are your own person. Make no mistake though that your "boycott" only achieves one less voice to cheer on the boys.

I can only hope others don't follow your idiotic example.

P-Man, I have not critised your view, you have been unable to answer the questions I posed, perhaps because it does not suit your argument. 

I donate money every year to our club, I have my view about Essendon and that is different to yours. I will barrack for our team from home. I hope we win and those attending have a great day.

 

Edit:- P-Man it is a five hour round trip for me and that means plenty of thinking time. The EFC saga rolling around in my head for that period of time is enough reason not to go. I hope you and all the other supporters that go have a great day and enjoy beating the cheats. It is too hard for me to forget  and I don't need the anger that I feel watching EFC and co.

Edited March 4, 2016 by ManDee

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

would like to break 100 margin for the first time since

Round 6, MCG, Attendance: 38799
Sunday, 2nd May 2004, 2:10 PM AEST
Brownlow Votes: 3: C Bruce, 2: A Yze, 1: J White        
Team             Q1     Q2        Q3       Q4         Final
Melbourne     6.3     12.5     19.9     25.10     160
Carlton           1.3     2.5        4.7        8.7       55

and Hogan for 10, of course

[P-man 13,366]

18 minutes ago, ManDee said:

P-Man, I have not critised your view, you have been unable to answer the questions I posed, perhaps because it does not suit your argument. 

I donate money every year to our club, I have my view about Essendon and that is different to yours. I will barrack for our team from home. I hope we win and those attending have a great day.

 

Edit:- P-Man it is a five hour round trip for me and that means plenty of thinking time. The EFC saga rolling around in my head for that period of time is enough reason not to go. I hope you and all the other supporters that go have a great day and enjoy beating the cheats. It is too hard for me to forget  and I don't need the anger that I feel watching EFC and co.

What questions? The ones about penalties? My previous answer will suffice. The fact they were not handed down after the CAS verdict is largely irrelevant. You should know the convoluted way the AFL works. The facts remains the club has been punished significantly.

If you are a long distance away then of course that changes things. I am in the same situation though I should hopefully be able to make it down. I assumed you were local. If however you are mainly choosing not to go because you feel a couple of dollars to Essendon (who are millions in the hole anyway and about buried deeper) outweighes the importance of supporting the MFC, then I'm afraid what you're really boycotting is your right to say that your loyalties lie first and foremost with the club.

It is the first game of the season, at our home ground, in a vitally important start to the year, in what is a pivotal season for the team's development, where we will be vastly outnumbered by opposition supporters to begin with. Within THAT context, I believe that your boycott is petty and ill-considered.

The one thing I do appreciate is your distaste for the EFC and what they've done to our sport. But this isn't the right way to express it.

[ManDee 7,162]

15 minutes ago, P-man said:

What questions? The ones about penalties? My previous answer will suffice. The fact they were not handed down after the CAS verdict is largely irrelevant. You should know the convoluted way the AFL works. The facts remains the club has been punished significantly.

If you are a long distance away then of course that changes things. I am in the same situation though I should hopefully be able to make it down. I assumed you were local. If however you are mainly choosing not to go because you feel a couple of dollars to Essendon (who are millions in the hole anyway and about buried deeper) outweighes the importance of supporting the MFC, then I'm afraid what you're really boycotting is your right to say that your loyalties lie first and foremost with the club.

It is the first game of the season, at our home ground, in a vitally important start to the year, in what is a pivotal season for the team's development, where we will be vastly outnumbered by opposition supporters to begin with. Within THAT context, I believe that your boycott is petty and ill-considered.

The one thing I do appreciate is your distaste for the EFC and what they've done to our sport. But this isn't the right way to express it.

Round 1 Melb V GWS home game at the G see you there.

Round 4 

Round 5 

Round 8

Round 9 etc see you there.

---Round 2 Away Ess V Melb I will take the day off.

Edited March 4, 2016 by ManDee

[Sir Why You Little 37,052]

1 hour ago, P-man said:

How are fines and suspensions "self inflicted wounds"?

Much like our punishment for "bringing the game into disrepute..but definitely not tanking", Essenson have been punished. There have been some detours along the way, but they've been punished. How do you want to further punish them? More fines? Jail time? The club is stuffed for years to come. I hate them as much as anyone but get serious.

Your protest on the grounds they haven't been punished is flimsy at best, and ultimately meaningless. Attend the game and support YOUR team.

2 Year complete ban of the entire club would have been a suitable verdict for me

No club would EVER go near Peptides again if that was enforced...

[Sir Why You Little 37,052]

41 minutes ago, Curry & Beer said:

would like to break 100 margin for the first time since

Round 6, MCG, Attendance: 38799
Sunday, 2nd May 2004, 2:10 PM AEST
Brownlow Votes: 3: C Bruce, 2: A Yze, 1: J White        
Team             Q1     Q2        Q3       Q4         Final
Melbourne     6.3     12.5     19.9     25.10     160
Carlton           1.3     2.5        4.7        8.7       55

and Hogan for 10, of course

Aah yes i have that game on VHS Name a Game tape.....

[Buzzy 992]

3 hours ago, old dee said:

There is your problem AJ we are a vastly different team to 4 - 5 years ago.

 

Do you not remember the game against this exact team last year?  Yes we kicked badly but Essendon managed to beat us with a vastly under-strength team (which will be similar to 2016), coming off a 110 point loss to St Kilda.

[Deestar9 1,636]

Sorry ManDee.....by not turning up you are letting down your team as a supporter. I assume you are either a MFC or MCC supporter  & unless you choose otherwise there should be no monies sent Essendon's way.  I totally agree with Dave Colberts tirade this morning & I think it is a really good idea with his comment that all other football supporters should turn their backs when they commence their applause ......I would rather show my displeasure publicly than not turn up to support my team 

[Sir Why You Little 37,052]

3 minutes ago, Deestar9 said:

Sorry ManDee.....by not turning up you are letting down your team as a supporter. I assume you are either a MFC or MCC supporter  & unless you choose otherwise there should be no monies sent Essendon's way.  I totally agree with Dave Colberts tirade this morning & I think it is a really good idea with his comment that all other football supporters should turn their backs when they commence their applause ......I would rather show my displeasure publicly than not turn up to support my team 

I will proudly turn my back on that Filthy scum...