Adam Tomlinson

[Young Blood 2,636]

He is versatile too. Can play as a tall on the wing with his elite endurance running for his size.

I like that he can go forward or back. Could tag team with Frost if he can improve his defensive side a bit more.

I feel this is a realistic and potentially great pickup if Melbourne can get him.

Is close with Dom, both went to Trinity Grammar and are good mates. Said it made things easier for him up at GWS with Dom around.

Come home!

[TheoX 1,222]

Carltank will be after him too.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Has he said that he wants to be traded?

[beelzebub 23,384]

Carltank will be after him too.

Carlton will need to go after a lot of ppl..lol

[Gator 17,607]

Playing Watts as a third tall works also because he is not a contested pack marking forward and wouldn't get in Hogan's way. But again, he'd need to be really willing and understanding of where to lead, run and make space.. He's a natural forward runner so it suits him, we've seen him push hard into space when he knows there's ball on offer..

Watts played forward and wing for the grand total of 10 goals.

It would have been great if he could have been our 'Gunston", but, unfortunately, he offers very little value.

[Young Blood 2,636]

Would love to see him running around HF with Watt's, AVB, Pederson, Frost and Jesse. Would add to our taller player stocks quite nicely.

Carlton have been reported as interested but I think Roos would like this kind of player on our list next year.

Really hope we get him. I think he has a higher ceiling then his current performance.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

Has he said that he wants to be traded?

I don't think so.

Spirit of norm smith just likes to float through threads with trade ideas. This then bumps up a thread like this that has no news at all.

[rpfc 28,832]

Watts played forward and wing for the grand total of 10 goals.

It would have been great if he could have been our 'Gunston", but, unfortunately, he offers very little value.

He's been a diabolical dud. To rate him "incredibly highly" is utterly nonsensical.

Thankfully, it looks like he'll reach his potential, which is so far from his draft selection it's not funny. Nonetheless, we're grateful for small mercies.

He's a mistake. But he's a mistake that's becoming a valuable entity as we move forward.

I just had to waste 5 minutes finding this - just a shame you used the very same word...

[Gator 17,607]

I just had to waste 5 minutes finding this - just a shame you used the very same word...

I'm flattered you took the time.

I dare say I've been pretty consistent on Watts, but I'm not immune to a contradiction. Although you'll note the tenet of my discussion is remarkably similar.

He had a good few weeks when his urgency improved, however, I see no real value in him. He'll never stand up to the heat of a final and 10 goals for the year just highlights his lack of possessions.

I accept some are emotionally wedded to him.

[binman 44,174]

I'm flattered you took the time.

I dare say I've been pretty consistent on Watts, but I'm not immune to a contradiction. Although you'll note the tenet of my discussion is remarkably similar.

He had a good few weeks when his urgency improved, however, I see no real value in him. He'll never stand up to the heat of a final and 10 goals for the year just highlights his lack of possessions.

I accept some are emotionally wedded to him.

Credit where credit is due. You have been consistent about Watts from the get go. As someone who is most definitely emotionally wedded to him it pains me to say you have largely been proven correct in your assessments of him. He did improve this season but you're right he simply does not get enough of the pill.

Still i hope he stays.

[TheoX 1,222]

Has he said that he wants to be traded?

Not officially but one of the journos Tom Browne said on twitter that he wants to come home to Vic.

Edited September 30, 2015 by TheoX

[MadAsHell 4,217]

Doesn't excite me to be honest. Think there's better and just as gettable options out there.

[blue and red in the head 95]

Doesn't excite me to be honest. Think there's better and just as gettable options out there.

Who??

[CBDees 3,167]

Credit where credit is due. You have been consistent about Watts from the get go. As someone who is most definitely emotionally wedded to him it pains me to say you have largely been proven correct in your assessments of him. He did improve this season but you're right he simply does not get enough of the pill.

Still i hope he stays.

Don't worry he is staying!

[Neitz the Great 555]

From what I saw of the last couple of rounds of him in GWS games, it looks like he has a pretty ordinary disposal

[spirit of norm smith 16,596]

Wiseblood...

Cheapshot from someone that is negative and adds no value. No evidence just a crack. Waste of air for the rest of us.

GBTTSA...

(edit)

You suggest we shutdown all threads unless players have signed contracts with MFC.

Edited September 30, 2015 by spirit of norm smith

[binman 44,174]

Don't worry he is staying!

Great. And I'm not being sarcastic.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

Wiseblood...

Cheapshot from someone that is negative and adds no value. No evidence just a crack. Waste of air for the rest of us.

GBTTSA...

(edit)

You suggest we shutdown all threads unless players have signed contracts with MFC.

I'm not being negative - why bring up a trade idea in a thread that's been dormant for a while? We see it rise to the top and think "oh, there must be some news on this front..." and it ends up being a trade idea that makes no sense as GWS are not interested in Howe, something that's been reported by a few journalists now. THAT, my friend, is adding no value.

[rpfc 28,832]

I'm flattered you took the time.

I dare say I've been pretty consistent on Watts, but I'm not immune to a contradiction. Although you'll note the tenet of my discussion is remarkably similar.

He had a good few weeks when his urgency improved, however, I see no real value in him. He'll never stand up to the heat of a final and 10 goals for the year just highlights his lack of possessions.

I accept some are emotionally wedded to him.

Yes, yes, you are always flattered...

I have argued that he is worth far less to other teams than to us simply because we don't have to sacrifice a pick to get him.

I came to terms a while back that he will be nothing more than a flanker with an excellent leg. There is value in that though...

[Gator 17,607]

I came to terms a while back that he will be nothing more than a flanker with an excellent leg. There is value in that though...

I don't think so and I doubt the club does either.

After 7 years he's been dropped twice in 2015, averages 16 disposals when disposals have never been easier and kicked the grand total of 10 goals.

It's a bust.

Edited September 30, 2015 by ProDee

[MadAsHell 4,217]

Who??

Any of:

Kurt Tippett (getable for our 1st round pick given Sydney's need for points for Mills/Dunkley)

Ben Griffiths

Josh Walker

Michael Apeness

Mason Shaw

Mitchell Harvey

If we're going to recruit a 2nd key forward, we need one who can also go into the ruck when required. The above 6 can do that. Tomlinson not so.

[CBDees 3,167]

I don't think so and I doubt the club does either.

After 7 years he's been dropped twice in 2015, averages 16 disposals when disposals have never been easier and kicked the grand total of 10 goals.

It's a bust.

He might have kicked 10 goals but he got more goal assists which adds more value and illustrates that he is a team player!

[At Least I Saw a Flag 5,304]

I know for certain that Tomlinson hates being at GWS (for various reasons) and wants to come back to Melbourne.

[Gator 17,607]

He might have kicked 10 goals but he got more goal assists which adds more value and illustrates that he is a team player!

You're easily pleased.

The guy has been an unmitigated disaster, but still has fans.

I've long concluded that he could be Lucas Cook and he'd still have some supporting him.

[rpfc 28,832]

You're easily pleased.

The guy has been an unmitigated disaster, but still has fans.

I've long concluded that he could be Lucas Cook and he'd still have some supporting him.

'Unmitigated disaster?'

Language used to mean something...

How's your coffee?

'It's an unabashed totalitarian waste.'

un·mit·i·gat·ed

(ŭn-mĭt′ĭ-gā′tĭd)

adj.

1. Not diminished or moderated in intensity or severity; unrelieved: unmitigated suffering.

2. Without qualification or exception; absolute: an unmitigated lie.

dis·as·ter

(dĭ-zăs′tər, -săs′-)

n.

1.

a. An occurrence causing widespread destruction and distress; a catastrophe.

b. A grave misfortune.

2. Informal A total failure: The dinner party was a disaster.

3. Obsolete An evil influence of a star or planet.