Eddie doing a Rex Hunt impression when Langdon? kicked in straight to Jetta. 'yeah,but,yeah,but,yeah,but'. Yes eddie, yibbada-yibbada - it's all over.

Ed sounds like he's dying.

Just watched the reply. Harmless stuff really. Just like any bunch of biased supporters following their team. "Straughney" (spelling?) is possibly the most unfunny comedian ever.

Are you joking? Talk about the age of outrage lol

I'll forgive you for not knowing what I had to put up with in the 80s and 90s from commercial tv. Sneer if you want, but this is hardly an isolated incident for me.

Ed said "we r 21 points down and need to kick 4 to win the game"

Really that is genius commentary from big ed.

Yeah I'd love to see Ox, Titus, Sheehan and Lyon do a press red for, but prob safer to wait a few years til we have a rough idea we are going to win that game.

Dr Turf would be brilliant

Ian Henderson for a bit of "cred" !!

Dr Turf would be brilliant

Ian Henderson for a bit of "cred" !!

No problem with that, but do you think it should be forced on all people who want to watch the replay, especially those who don't support the Pies? All replays are listed as the Ed version.

Fox Footy are idiots.

yup. i agree.

Dr Turf would be brilliant

Ian Henderson for a bit of "cred" !!

Hendo is the most bias one eyed Demon supporter ever! Classic.

Just record the game live, if we lose delete it from your planner. Doesn't everyone do this?

A completely common sense approach. One that I sadly can't support because I've convinced myself that we never win when I record the game live. That's only one of about 37 footballing superstitions that I'm cursed with.

This game is being replayed 4 times this week,each time with big fat ed's red head

[censored] you Fox Footy,you're all a bunch of C----

I wanted to keep this game for a long time

Pathetic

For what it's worth, Hudson called the actual game and was excellent. I found him annoying in the early years, but I reckon he captures the moment very well.

Need more professional comentators like him and Whately, than ex footy player boofheads, or try-hards like Basil and Hamish who try to fit in with the jocks.

For what it's worth, Hudson called the actual game and was excellent. I found him annoying in the early years, but I reckon he captures the moment very well.

Need more professional comentators like him and Whately, than ex footy player boofheads, or try-hards like Basil and Hamish who try to fit in with the jocks.

l watched the afl smart replay. dermie was so inane and painful i watched the last 3 quarters with the sound muted

Edited August 2, 201510 yr by daisycutter

I, for one, will be contacting Foxtel, The AFL, and the MFC tomorrow to complain. It is offensive that every replay of the game this week has this rubbish as commentary. Imagine if this was done to Collingwood on one of their wins

Agree, but probably not in the bailiwicks of AFL and MFC.

Go hard on Foxtel, but…..

A completely common sense approach. One that I sadly can't support because I've convinced myself that we never win when I record the game live. That's only one of about 37 footballing superstitions that I'm cursed with.

Needs it's own thread. I've been supersticiously wearing this stupid red and blue striped shirt every weekend because it was obviously the only reason we beat GC in the first round.

Edited August 2, 201510 yr by Skuit

For what it's worth, Hudson called the actual game and was excellent. I found him annoying in the early years, but I reckon he captures the moment very well.

Need more professional comentators like him and Whately, than ex footy player boofheads, or try-hards like Basil and Hamish who try to fit in with the jocks.

No need to rub it in Nasher.

This is like Roy & HG calling the Wimbledon Finals in the early '90's

"Tennis" purists were outraged, me i thought they wete comedy gold...

l watched the afl smart replay. dermie was so inane and painful i watched the last 3 quarters with the sound muted

I don't mind Derm. He does dribble a lot, but from time to time does have points of interest to raise. He knows the game I think, you just need to see through the waffle that intersperses it.

Funnily enough I reckon Eddie is a better commentator than most of the idiots on TV (when he is not doing the red-ed nonsense). Not being an ex-player he just describes what is happening rather than having folksy chats recalling old playing days, clubs we have known and bleeding obvious tactics like the others do.

I don't mind Derm. He does dribble a lot, but from time to time does have points of interest to raise. He knows the game I think, you just need to see through the waffle that intersperses it.

I’m in the “Derm’s not that bad” camp, but this time he was definitely more on the inane side.

"Miss miss miss miss miss miss miss miss"

Just watching the Fox replay now.

Absolutely disgusting commentary by Eddie, Shaw and that non-entity 'comedian' ?Strauney??

Just plain barracking - we, we ,we, they, they, they !!!!

Ruins any opportunity to fully enjoy the victory.

What a disgrace.

PS: still in first quarter - will maybe enjoy their grief at the end.

Edited August 2, 201510 yr by monoccular

Laugh a minute!

'Someone DO something'

'Don't go backwards!'

'Kick it long!'

'Miss! Miss! Miss! Miss!'

Easy listening

Just watching the Fox replay now.

Absolutely disgusting commentary by Eddie, Shaw and that non-entity 'comedian' ?Strauney??

Just plain barracking - we, we ,we, they, they, they !!!!

Ruins any opportunity to fully enjoy the victory.

What a disgrace.

PS: still in first quarter - will maybe enjoy their grief at the end.

Wouldnt be to concerned Mono it's exactly what eds broadcast is meant to be.

We as dees fans get the enjoyment of their commentary during the last quarter. It's gold!

Edited August 2, 201510 yr by DemonOX