Who are the best six kicks in our mighty team?

[jumbo returns 6,619]

You forgot Terry Gleeson!

Elaborate please? Can't remember him either....

[deeflog 679]

In no order

Watts, Salem, Tyson, Dunn, N Jones, Vince

There is no way Howe is in out best kicks

[Ted Lasso 17,318]

Watts

Salem

Vince

Toumpas

Tyson

Dunn

[kieranbj 111]

really surprised to see Howe in so many lists.

I consider his set shot kicking below average and his field kicking just average.

For mine I think a top 6 would include

Watts

Dunn

Salem

Strauss

N.Jones

Kent

[Vince Vega 40]

Powell

Ingerson

Holland

Hopgood

Seecamp

Godfrey.

Sorry, I'm playing - I'm still in a good mood

Thank you jumbo, I needed a laugh!

[Older demon 2,323]

The only elite kicks are IMO Watts, Salem and Vince. Next level are Dunn (long but not always accurate), N. Jones when he kicks long, Kent (but need to see more of what he has) Tyson (when he gets it right but still makes too many clangers). Hmmm that is 7 the rest are iffy

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I love Tyson, but his kicking is by no means a strength of his.

[Roger Mellie 3,668]

Watts

Salem

Vince

Kent

Toump

Strauss

[Dees2014 2,377]

I think a more relevant question is who are the worst kicks???

I would say

Matt Jones

McDonald

Mckenzie

Jamar

Viney

I think someone like Viney will improve with age. At the moment, he is not a long kick. This will improve. I'd put JKH in the same category.

Tyson though I think is an inaccurate short range kick, but he sure seems to be able to slott them in from 50 meters out at crucial times in games. Garland at times is an inaccurate short range kick also. Chip needs to work on his goal kicking

[Biffen 12,563]

Watts

Salem

Dawes

Vince

Jetta

Trengove

[Nasher 33,246]

Powell

Ingerson

Holland

Hopgood

Seecamp

Godfrey.

Sorry, I'm playing - I'm still in a good mood

Scott Chisholm would have to be close to the worst I've seen in my lifetime.

[robbiefrom13 877]

Greg Parke?

[beelzebub 22,724]

we need more than 6

[rjay 24,193]

I love Tyson, but his kicking is by no means a strength of his.

The long goals are, he does miss some of his passes but his is a penetrating kick and will get better.

[Little Richard 5,943]

I love Tyson, but his kicking is by no means a strength of his.

Tyson is very hit and miss I feel - as rjay says his kicking has great penetration and he lays out some great 40m pin point passes but fluffs some easy ones.

Here's my top 6. Watts the best and the following 5 in no particular order:

Watts

Salem

Kent

N. Jones

Dunn

Viney

Wouldn't have Jetta in there; he's doing some great things at the moment but I don't think he's in our top 6 kicks. Viney is very underrated I feel and his left foot is pretty dangerous at times, not missing many targets and often out of congestion.

[JackVineyForPresident 310]

Watts

Salem

N Jones

N Jetta

L Dunn

B Vince

Cant believe some people wouldnt have Vince or N Jones in that list. Both amazing kicks.

[dimmy 1,188]

Tommy Mac standing still or running .

Dean Terlach when he is running

Jack the Grimes when not under pressure

Jordie when he is under pressure

Spence

Seriously :

Watts,Watts, Watts, Salem,Howe, Dunn , Jack G (when he concentrates) ,Dawes

[wattsjurrahdunne 88]

Watts, Vince, Salem, Dunn then daylight to Nathan Jones. Forget the rest as they are average to poor.

[monoccular 16,654]

In no particular order these are the guys I'd like kicking for my life:

Jack Watts

Christian Salem

Lyndon Dunn

Jeremy Howe

Bernie Vince

Chris Dawes

Depends a bit on the context:

Watts to deliver to the leading forward

Salem or Dawes set shot - Dawes if > 50 m

Dunn out of deep defence

Vince on the run from 50+ m (if the bloody maggot doesn't recall it !)

Kent - limited exposure this season but looking pretty damn good

No love for Strauss? Though he's not exactly in the team, is he...

Can't tell how good a kick he is unless he gets the ball.

Edited June 17, 2014 by monoccular

[monoccular 16,654]

You forgot Terry Gleeson!

Elaborate please? Can't remember him either....

Terry was one of our ruckman (?#28) in the mid to late 1950s - our Golden years, in tandem with Big Bob Johnson #16. Can't remember seeing him kick. Maybe he didn't / couldn't

I think a more relevant question is who are the worst kicks???

I would say

Matt Jones

McDonald

Mckenzie

Jamar

Viney

I think someone like Viney will improve with age. At the moment, he is not a long kick. This will improve. I'd put JKH in the same category.

Tyson though I think is an inaccurate short range kick, but he sure seems to be able to slott them in from 50 meters out at crucial times in games. Garland at times is an inaccurate short range kick also. Chip needs to work on his goal kicking

It took his dad quite a few years but in the latter part of his career he became a fairly decent kick. Pretty bloody awful early though, as I recall. (Made up for it with ridiculous courage and attack on ball, and the man in a fair but brutally hard manner).

[whatwhat say what 20,401]

unbelievably, at this stage i'd rate salem as the best kick at the club, he just looks the most natural.

jones just ahead of watts.

salem

n jones

watts

dunn

vince

tyson

kent and jkh not that far behind tyson at this stage - so far, he looks like a lovely user of the ball.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,534]

Any discussion on best kicks should consider (a) right foot long, (b) left foot long, © right foot short and (d) left foot short. You could also include set shots v on the run as well as those trick shots for goal invented (or, at lest, perfected) by Peter Daicos.

On that basis, the best kick on the ground last Sunday was Michael Hurley, the only player who could kick with either foot naturally.

As I haven't yet seen Salem kick with his right foot, I think Jack Watts is our best. But Salem may turn out to be better.

[Dee Dee 1,060]

Brian Dixon would beat that mob.

Geoff Tunbridge! Now there was a kick!

[TGR 1,367]

Best....

Watts

Chopper Lovell

Garry Lyon

Warren Dean (Dist.)

I reckon JKH (I haven't seen as much of Salem) will have a good record by the time he is finished.

There needs to be some accuracy formula that takes into account degree-of-difficulty variables such as angle (pressure is a harder one, but Salem's was max pressure I would have thought).

As far as non-MFC, Jack Riewoldt is a dead-eye...apart from last week.

[Satyriconhome 10,091]

Watts' kicking skill allows him to be a bastard now and again

Dean Kent had an urgent requirement at training today and raced off to the nearest tree, unfortunately because the group was training in the middle of the ground, this left him only about 30 metres from the fence and all the other players getting a drink, Watts picked up a ball, took one step, kicked it under the fence, and it bounced perfectly towards Kent who was furiously concentrating on the job on hand, as there was a female approaching (much to everybody elses' amusement), Kent was kneeling on one knee against the tree, the ball took it's final bounce just before him and cleared his head by about an inch....to cheers....