AFL DRAFT Phantom Form Guide

[Whispering_Jack 30,640]

UPDATE: Phantom form guide

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

would we consider taking anyone other than aish at 2?

[Machsy 2,858]

Scharenberg would have to be tempting.

In terms of mids, we don't have a lot of big bodies ones.

[ignition. 1,466]

I like Callum Twomey, although I just think some of his ranking is idiotic.

[DEELIRIOUS 156]

If Bontempelli slips through, this man is a jet. Beatiful left foot, 191cm, can play midfield, wing, hbf and hff. Great mover and has the Scott Pendlebury's about him in a big way. I'd much prefer him over Dunstan at pick 20

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,408]

would we consider taking anyone other than aish at 2?

would we consider taking anyone other than aish at 2?

I wrote in the Aish thread earlier tonight. Kids from SA and WA were seen as ready made because they currently play against men. Gibbs, Trenners?? Myth busted. Josh Kelly looks a goer. We need to steal notes from Geelongs recruiter.

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

kelly is abit skinny for mine, his real asset is his endurance which wont be such an advantage at afl level, sheed or scharenberg would be worth chatting too

[spirit of norm smith 16,588]

IMO ...

1 GWS Tom Boyd

2 Melbourne James Aish

3 Western Bulldogs Matt Crouch

4 St. Kilda Dominic Sheed

5 GCS Matt Scharenberg

6 Brisbane Josh Kelly

7 North Melbourne Luke McDonald [father/son]

8 WCE Marco Bontempelli

9 Carlton Jack Billings

10 GWS Kade Kolodjashnij

11 Port Adelaide Nathan Freeman

12 Essendon Luke Dunstan

13 Richmond Christian Salem

14 Collingwood Ben Lennon

15 Fremantle Darcy Gardiner

16 Geelong Lewis Taylor

17 Sydney Billy Hartung

18 Hawthorn Isaiah Miller

19 GCS Blake Acres

20 GWS Jonathan Marsh

21 Melbourne Patrick Cripps

22 Western Bulldogs Darcy Hourigan

23 St. Kilda Trent Dumont

24 GCS Dwayne Wilson

25 Brisbane Issac Conway

26 North Melbourne Alex Spina

27 WCE Mitchell Honeychurch

28 Carlton Luke Reynolds

29 Port Adelaide Cameron McCarthy

30 Essendon Nick Bourke

31 Richmond Zac Merrett

32 Collingwood Jay Kennedy-Harris

33 Fremantle Cameron Conlon

34 Geelong Tom Cutler

35 Sydney Lloyd Perris (zone)

36 Hawthorn James Tsitas

37 GWS Will Maginess

38 Melbourne Zak Jones

39 Western Bulldogs Clayton McCartney

40 St. Kilda Nick Robertson

41 GCS Errin Wasley-Black

42 Brisbane Fraser Fort

43 Adelaide Jarman Impey

44 North Melbourne Cameron Giles

45 WCE Max Hayes

46 Carlton Nick Holman

47 Port Adelaide Cain Tickner

48 Essendon Aaron Heppell

49 Richmond Eli Templeton

50 Collingwood Mitch Harvey

51 Fremantle Dayle Garlett

52 Geelong Jason Cooke

53 Sydney James Battersby

54 Hawthorn Ben Cavarra

55 GWS Josh Scott

56 Melbourne Nathan Drummond

57 Western Bulldogs Louis Herbert

58 St. Kilda Aiden Franetic

59 GCS Tom Langdon

60 Brisbane Dallas Willsmore

61 Adelaide Nick Favretto

62 North Melbourne Billy Hogan

[ThreeOneSix 954]

would we consider taking anyone other than aish at 2?

Josh Kelly.

Ever since Knightmare has said that Kelly won't be suitable at AFL level - posters run with it, I think it's BS and I respect KM extremely highly, I just disagree.

Kelly and Aish are blue bloods as far as pedigree goes and on performance over the champs Kelly was top notch.

I've really warmed to Kelly lately.

I have been pro Dom Sheed the past few months, but blokes I speak to - who know better than myself - say they'd take Aish and Kelly before Sheed easily.

That doesn't mean a lot... But there will be an inside mid sitting around 20, one will slip.... no doubt, it's a quality first round - and apparently even.

Dumont is my favorite player of this draft, It would be a dream if he fell to 20/21.

Top 3 for mine would be..

1. Boyd.

2. Aish.

3. Kelly.

I'd have Billings top 5 as well.

[rjay 25,086]

I wouldn't be factoring Essendon into this draft either.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

I like Schatenberg myself. Seems ready made so I doubt we'll take him.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

Sorry bloody autocorrect!

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

Aiden Franetic? Now that's the most comic book star name since 'Dangerfield'

[hardtack 10,626]

I wouldn't be factoring Essendon into this draft either.

Not to mention that we are a possibility to get a first round priority pick which will change things quite significantly for us.

[Dee Only Way 1]

I have a gut feel that with the new recruiting staff, Scharenberg will be preferred over Aish

[Young Dee 1,303]

Can we get Aish on the peptides now?

I seriously don't have any patience left. I just cant listen to 100 "Aish" threads describing him as the next Chris Judd... in 7 years time.

I am a patient person but seriously it makes me sick thinking about development. If anyone has a time machine speak out now! (I will accept a time freezing device also)

[Axis of Bob 11,841]

I am a patient person but seriously it makes me sick thinking about development.

I am an undeniably handsome, 6'4 fighter pilot. And I am immortal.

Let's see if that works.

[ChaserJ 5,157]

I wrote in the Aish thread earlier tonight. Kids from SA and WA were seen as ready made because they currently play against men. Gibbs, Trenners?? Myth busted. Josh Kelly looks a goer. We need to steal notes from Geelongs recruiter.

It’s too easy to pick players recruited from SA & WA with senior experience that haven’t met or exceeded expectations and selectively ignore players like Cooney, Rich Lewis Jetta and Naitanui to name a few.

Gibbs and Trenners are far from complete busts. Both probably have individual sets of circumstances that might explain why they haven’t met expectations, and I’d suggest the clubs they’ve landed at are part of the puzzle as well. 2 years in, I was very happy with how Jack was progressing, and I include myself in a group of many who can’t work out exactly what has halted his development.

There are no magical recruiting formula’s in any sport, never mind AFL. Senior experience can inform part of a player’s capacity to succeed in the AFL, but there are no guarantees.

[Bossdog 2,002]

Can we get Aish on the peptides now?

I seriously don't have any patience left. I just cant listen to 100 "Aish" threads describing him as the next Chris Judd... in 7 years time.

I am a patient person but seriously it makes me sick thinking about development. If anyone has a time machine speak out now! (I will accept a time freezing device also)

I have......Send a cheque for two thousand dollars to me and when it clears I will deliver...........

[ThreeOneSix 954]

Can we get Aish on the peptides now?

I seriously don't have any patience left. I just cant listen to 100 "Aish" threads describing him as the next Chris Judd... in 7 years time.

I am a patient person but seriously it makes me sick thinking about development. If anyone has a time machine speak out now! (I will accept a time freezing device also)

Judd didn't have a massive frame coming into the system, he went alright straight away.