Jimmy Toumpas

[ThreeOneSix 954]

This kid should not be playing afl footy.

He should be at Casey working on his game. Same with Kent.

Its a shame our list is so bad that we have no one to play ahead of these kids.

Bit harsh to lump Kent in with Toumpas, at least Kent has a dip.

[What 18,810]

was disappointing

But will not affect his development at all

[Jaded No More 68,292]

He was clearly gutted when subbed off. We forget he is a baby playing in the worst midfield in AFL-VFL history.

You can see how badly he wants it. Cut him some slack!

[Yeats8 21]

Did he have an illness before the game?

[whatwhat say what 22,289]

anybody seen the photo of him in the ice bath up in darwin?

no wonder he's slow.

[jumbo returns 6,703]

Oh well.

Hopefully there'll be a midfielder that sticks out like the proverbial dog's anatomy as 'ready to play' in this year's draft.

[Gorgoroth 12,734]

Oh no!!!!

A kid in his first year has a bad game!!!

Quick, lets all pot him.

Flogs

Edited July 20, 2013 by Gorgoroth

[AllenIsLord13 1]

but he's wearing Jimmy Hird's number? Why isn't he as good as him right now???

[Nasher 33,607]

It was a shocker. I won't make any excuses, that was a disaster by any measure, young or not. That said, I agree that this was clearly an outlier. Even if he does turn out disappointing, he'll never be as poor as he was tonight. I won't judge ANY player on his absolute worst game, especially a 19 year old finding his way. That's just not a fair way to judge.

He'll play for Casey next week, and he won't ever be that poor again. He's an emotional guy and was clearly gutted. We move on.

[Chook 15,001]

Fitzpatrick was terrible last week, but great this week.
Toumpas was great last week but terrible this week.

Demonland's Official Conclusion: Fitzpatrick is great but Toumpas sucks.

[DeeSpencer 24,828]

Brereton didn't need to pick apart every move he made. Some of which were reasonable.

How about we pick apart a GWS youngster for an entire game one week Derm you [censored].

In fact not a youngster lets pick Phil Davis who is a millionaire who spuds up everything and is meant to be a leader.

[Undeeterred 3,059]

Fitzpatrick was terrible last week, but great this week.

Toumpas was great last week but terrible this week.

Demonland's Official Conclusion: Fitzpatrick is great but Toumpas sucks.

Well, it is a small picture, short term memory kind of place.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Brereton didn't need to pick apart every move he made. Some of which were reasonable.

How about we pick apart a GWS youngster for an entire game one week Derm you [censored].

In fact not a youngster lets pick Phil Davis who is a millionaire who spuds up everything and is meant to be a leader.

exactly

and the [censored] population around here tends to borrow most of their comments from what they hear on the telly. The amount of times I have read somebody parrot a response as if it was their own is ridiculous.

it's the main reason for Naitanui-overrated-itis for example

[Robbie57 2,003]

Last interview said he was struggling to get his body right each week. He is young and needs a rest. Week off then back to Casey for a couple.

[P-man 13,366]

There doesn't seem to be much discussion about the possibility of him having an illness, or simply not adapting to the conditions. There was more to it than just a bad game. He wasn't right tonight. He'll be fine. He proved his wares against the best in the league last week.

[DeeSpencer 24,828]

Last interview said he was struggling to get his body right each week. He is young and needs a rest. Week off then back to Casey for a couple.

id be keen for him to play again in 2 weeks against GWS.

Also the supposed superstar Wines only had 8 touches today.

These young guys are always up and down

[Chook 15,001]

Also the supposed superstar Wines only had 8 touches today.

That is surprisingly comforting to know.

[dazzledavey36 53,073]

He has been battling knee problems the last couple of weeks. Fact.

[P-man 13,366]

Also the supposed superstar Wines only had 8 touches today.

It's Round 17 and he's in his first year of AFL. Not exactly surprising that he's dipping. It's still one of the best first seasons I've seen. Unfortunate for him that he's paying in the same year as the J bomb whose basically what you'd get if you genetically engineered the perfect AFL player.

[whatwhat say what 22,289]

It's still one of the best first seasons I've seen. .

Gotta disagree with that.

[P-man 13,366]

Gotta disagree with that.

Did you want to elaborate?

His impact on games, certainly in the first half of the season, has been phenomenal for a first year player. Happy for you to throw up some names for comparison.

[MadAsHell 4,209]

Kade Simpson's stats in his first three games for Carlton 0 kicks 0 handballs 0 marks.

Toump had a shocker and he knows it. He was also very, very good the week before. I think some people on here need to stop jumping at their own shadows.

[ucanchoose 1,816]

Brereton didn't need to pick apart every move he made. Some of which were reasonable.

How about we pick apart a GWS youngster for an entire game one week Derm you [censored].

In fact not a youngster lets pick Phil Davis who is a millionaire who spuds up everything and is meant to be a leader.

I actually liked listening to it to be honest. Not only did he pick apart the mistakes he gave advise how to rectify it. That's colour commentary and A HELL OF A LOT BETTER that most of them on tv.

Just because it was a Melbourne player people get their backs up. I don't get it.

Even my 8 year old son could understand when we watched the replay this morning

[BAMF 4,167]

Bit harsh to lump Kent in with Toumpas, at least Kent has a dip.

I'm not bagging out either player. I just don't think they are ready for Afl yet.

[Biffen 12,873]

Dermie took it upon himself to personally coach Watts through the game which became very tiring.The more Derm tries to seem intelligent, the stupider he looks.

Also-Grimes wasn't good last night-he was average, and Rich beat him.

Hanley carved us up as did Rockliffe.

We are falling down in the Ruck but must keep big Max up there while he learns.

Toumpas had a bad day and can be forgiven .

Byrnes is slowing up our list development and is not half as good as Rodan.

Jetta might get Toumpas' spot next week, and a last chance to prove he can play.