From the bottom of a sauce bottle – 3 way trade

[furious d 447]

Barrett says Dawes will make a decision tonight. His "breaking news" was that Brisbane are interested, they don't call him the purple headed warrior for nothing.

[pantaloons 2,019]

Pederson for a 2nd round pick.

We don't have an available 2nd round pick unless the above deal goes through. (our 2nd rounder is committed to JV)

Does this mean that Nudge is right and the deal I heard about at 9am this morning is close to complete?

Go Dees!

The 3 way deal is done

Announcement within 2-3 hours just a few details to iron out such as Dawes signing contract alteration etc

Well done Dees, a nice deal indeed imho

If this doesn't come true, I'm taking my likes back.

[olisik 4,060]

Geez Oli - Get over it. These guys know exactly what they're doing. Leave them to it. Go Dees!

When we do better then 16th then I will.

I think our performance over the past 5 years warrants some skepticism and not just all blind faith....

I apologize if you don't agree

[Ouch! 2,041]

When we do better then 16th then I will.

I think our performance over the past 5 years warrants some skepticism and not just all blind faith....

I apologize if you don't agree

And yet for the first time in 5 years it looks like they are actually trying to do something about it.

Can't have it both ways!

[MadAsHell 4,088]

When we do better then 16th then I will.

I think our performance over the past 5 years warrants some skepticism and not just all blind faith....

I apologize if you don't agree

Jack Viney = Midfielder

Pick 4 (Wines, O'Rourke or Toumpas) = Midfielder

Dom Barry = Midfielder/forward

Farren Ray = Midfielder/HBF

Midfield isn't being forgotten. It's just easier to find midfielders then it is KPP.

Edit: =

Edited October 12, 2012 by Tall Defence

[old dee 22,942]

When we do better then 16th then I will.

I think our performance over the past 5 years warrants some skepticism and not just all blind faith....

I apologize if you don't agree

There is some excitement this trade / draft period olisik.

But I do tend to agree with you.

Proof of the pudding is in the eating, when we start winning games against Vic. teams I will get excited.

Right now I have a smile

[dazzledavey36 48,943]

hmm i actually dont think its been a done deal guys. i respect nudge's great work alot but from what i have been told Dawes is still undecided and the ray talks are a way off as st kilda still think ray is a required player for 2013..

but happy to be proven wrong!

[olisik 4,060]

And yet for the first time in 5 years it looks like they are actually trying to do something about it.

Can't have it both ways!

I disagree actually.

The same feel was on DL this time last year when we landed Clark and drafted Taggart and Magner, got a new coach ect. Added Misson Craig and so on.

I need to see the action on-field before I will be satisfied.

If people want to start getting happy and excited about making a few trades then go for it but personally I wont be until we get some wins on the board.

Edited October 12, 2012 by olisik

[Number 2 11]

hmm i actually dont think its been a done deal guys. i respect nudge's great work alot but from what i have been told Dawes is still undecided and the ray talks are a way off as st kilda still think ray is a required player for 2013..

but happy to be proven wrong!

I don't reckon it'll get done today Dazzle.

Dawes needs to make public a desire to be traded to MelbourneFC before this can go down.

There is a bit of buzz on twitter atm suggesting that an announcement could come from Dawes soon.

I don't want to go against Nudge, coz he seems to be more on the money than I am. But I think it'll happen over the weekend, if it is going to happen.

[The Reverend 1,718]

When we do better then 16th then I will.

I think our performance over the past 5 years warrants some skepticism and not just all blind faith....

I apologize if you don't agree

You're entitled to be sceptical. Our performance has been poor by any measure. My optimism comes from the fact there seems to be a plan to get specific types of players to fill gaps in our list. I'm sure there will be a big improvement in the midfield, and all over the ground, next year and it will come not just from new players but from a team with better fitness, a better understanding and adherence to a winning game plan along with a much strengthened culture. We are one year into Neeld's reign. He has been putting the pieces in place with the footy department and is now starting to get the right pieces on the game board. It was never going to turn around in one year. Whilst I understand your doubts, I'm just buoyed by the sense of an actual strategy at play in our drafting so far. We've moved away from the kids only policy of the past and seem to be building a team with some bodies that can make us a hard team to play against, instead of being pushed aside like we have in recent years.

Let's hope this is the start of something different at the MFC. Go Dees!

[pantaloons 2,019]

I don't reckon it'll get done today Dazzle.

Dawes needs to make public a desire to be traded to MelbourneFC before this can go down.

There is a bit of buzz on twitter atm suggesting that an announcement could come from Dawes soon.

I don't want to go against Nudge, coz he seems to be more on the money than I am. But I think it'll happen over the weekend, if it is going to happen.

It's gone 10pm Pacific Time over in the US. I expect an answer from him in the next couple of hours or not at all today.

[H_T 2,941]

If this doesn't come true, I'm taking my likes back.

Speculating here, but if they are waiting to iron out some paperwork alterations to his existing contract and getting Dawes to sign off on it. Might take a bit of time with Dawes in the States....just saying.

[nutbean 8,837]

I need to see the action on-field before I will be satisfied.

If people want to start getting happy and excited about making a few trades then go for it but personally I wont be until we get some wins on the board.

This I agree with - I have been burned one too many times - quietly optimistic but definitely withholding judgement until I see some proof positive.

[H_T 2,941]

This I agree with - I have been burned one too many times - quietly optimistic but definitely withholding judgement until I see some proof positive.

I'm sure we are all in that boat of quietly optimistically speaking terms.

[old55 21,392]

I need to see the action on-field before I will be satisfied.

How about not posting all the whinging until the footy starts again then?

[nutbean 8,837]

Chris Dawes is no 31 at Collingwood - hmmmm

(a now cursed number if you ask me !)

[H_T 2,941]

If people want to start getting happy and excited about making a few trades then go for it but personally I wont be until we get some wins on the board.

We gather that. Questioning every rumoured pick, player thrown up with pessimism is most evident.

[ignition. 1,413]

What if Whitfield, Toumpas and Wines are the first 3 picks. Do we take Grundy.

Good question Theo, it is a possibility but I think there is no way GWS will knock back Grundy. They already have an exciting young midfield, yet lack an exciting young ruckman. Other than Giles they don't really have a standout, so I think it's more than likely Grundy* will go at 2 or 3.

EDIT: * I accidentally wrote Giles.

Edited October 12, 2012 by ignition.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

I have a few on ignore but its amusing that the ones whinging about potential tades are the same ones whinging that players wouldn't come or meet with our club

Edited October 12, 2012 by dandeeman

[old55 21,392]

Yes get this deal done. So I'm guessing after this happens 39 will go to North for Pedersen maybe.

So if all this is true the nett for us is:

Out: 20, 45, Martin

In: Dawes, Ray, Pedersen

That would leave us with Viney, Hogan, 4, [any FA compo], 65, 83 thru the draft.

[pm24 451]

Dawes' agent is coming onto TWR now, and has just announced that he will play at Melbourne!!!!

[Geddy Lee 582]

Dawes is ours.

[MadAsHell 4,088]

That would leave us with Viney, Hogan, 4, [any FA compo], 65, 83 thru the draft.

And Barry!

[olisik 4,060]

So if all this is true the nett for us is:

Out: 20, 45, Martin

In: Dawes, Ray, Pedersen

That would leave us with Viney, Hogan, 4, [any FA compo], 65, 83 thru the draft.

Its only 1 week into a 3 week trade period. Will we go quiet?

[pm24 451]

So we have now got Dawes, Burns, Hogan, Viney, Barry, pick 4, possibly Farren Ray, possibly Pedersen, and then two more draft picks from this Trade/FA period.

This is looking to be a very good off-season so far.