WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - CHRIS DAWES

[45HG 1,539]

Dawes has a contract right?

Yeah - I was thinking about that before. This must be as a possible trade scenario (or it's completely fabricated).

[dee-luded 2,959]

Neeld has seen Collingwood's twin-tall forward structure in full motion and I'm sure he wants to replicate it here.

Lynch is out and Tippett will break the bank. Pedersen, Casboult and any others mentioned are depth at best.

It's Dawes or Hogan, I reckon. Wishing for both.

Surely we have to stall Tippett from the Pies. Don't we want the Suns to spend their Pick 2 on the Tippett deal?

[Gippsland Dee 367]

If collingwood have added Q lynch to their stocks then i wouldn't be surprised if Dawes was to be pushed out.

He showed a year or so ago that he can play, he was right along side cloke as their big forwards! He is just down on confidence and when that comes back i would expect him to return to his previous form and be a consistently accurate goal kicker would be nice to get him if this does happen

[Dr. Gonzo 24,191]

He never got the best backman this year and barely got a kick.

As mentioned earlier Butcher and even Gumby would be far better options, especially Butcher.

No one has indicated how they think we might be able to get Butcher. Is he actually on the table? As far as I can tell he signed a 2 year contract extension last year so is contracted until the end of next season. Has he actually said he wants out of Port or is this just another trademark Demonland fantasy trade?

[thaipantsman 180]

hahaaha

yeah Martin is totally better than a 24 year old key forward who kicked a combined 57 goals and took a combined 200 marks in Collingwoods two grand final years

what a joke

Martin is nothing, he has done nothing at AFL level and never will.

Dawes will be the perfect support for Mitch inside forward 50. I hope we land him.

time will tell hogan

[thaipantsman 180]

one on one i will back martin every time for speed agility ..sad he didn't get to play for collingwood in the two grand final years. "martin is nothing"? tippett would be a good pick up though. a f in g good pick up.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,191]

Martin will be lucky to be on an AFL list after next season. Take the blinkers off.

[thaipantsman 180]

can dawes actually move and jump?

[thaipantsman 180]

if he still can we'll take him

[BarnDee 287]

PLEASE SHUT THE DOORS , BLOODY SLOW AS A WET WEEK , FFS , GET A GRIP , GIVE KT A MILL , !

[BarnDee 287]

• oi when i go shoppin for spuds , i squezze em , soft no good , a hard spud is the one ya want , dawes is a soft one , reject , forget , and , you know the rest !
  

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

I believe he has been tanking all year ( a perfect fit of Melbourne) and was missing Leroy Brown and Neeldy.

Collingwood must pay out his final year of contract just like we did when we got rid of Woey.

He'll be cherry ripe after a pre-season under Misson.

Just Dreamin!

[BarnDee 287]

I believe he has been tanking all year ( a perfect fit of Melbourne) and was missing Leroy Brown and Neeldy.

Collingwood must pay out his final year of contract just like we did when we got rid of Woey.

He'll be cherry ripe after a pre-season under Misson.

Just Dreamin!

just dreaming eh ? more like a bloody nightmare , , please nooooooooooooo

[Triple Jack 13]

This is an interesting one.

He was a very good player in 2010 and alright in 2011.

This year everyone saw that he was pretty much hopeless with no confidence!

I would just like to make a few points for you guys to think about.

All this information comes from one of his family members so for me I regard this as 99% of the truth.

■ He has played less then 5 games over the last 2 seasons without injections. He has struggled a lot with injuries with his hand causing alot of problems which has seen him lose a lot of confidence in his marking! Also struggled with knees and shoulders.

■ I also know for a fact he and Mick didn't get on very well. It was in fact Buckley his forward coach of 2010 and 2011 who he has a great relationship with!!!

■ As we all know a number of clubs, including Melbourne were prepared to spend big $650,000+, but he stayed because he loved the club. He is on only $350,000ish.

I have no idea whether he is coming to us or staying at the Pies. I just thought I would add what I know to this discussion.

[Toorak 108]

We lose Rivers and gain Dawes. I see we replace hard with soft. FFS don't do it!

[Go the Biff 3,414]

I think Old55 has this sorted. Pies looking to return to the forward structure that won them a flag. If however, Dawes is forced out due to salary cap constraints, he could certainly play a role with us. At the very least he could spread the opposition defence & reduce the double-teaming that Clark cops.

If he does end up looking for a new home, you'd think the Bulldogs would be barking and would be prepared to offer up more than most. Their forward line makes our midfield look well stocked.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I think Old55 has this sorted. Pies looking to return to the forward structure that won them a flag. If however, Dawes is forced out due to salary cap constraints, he could certainly play a role with us.

He is under contract so there is zero chance of this happening.

[Go the Biff 3,414]

Forced out / offered up / placed "on the table" etc

[Dee Fan 3,247]

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/open-dawes-magpie-power-forward-to-meet-with-bucks-after-collingwood-signs-lynch-20121002-26wp0.html

Open Dawes: Magpie power forward to meet with Bucks after Collingwood signs Lynch

Edited October 2, 2012 by RobbieF

[45HG 1,539]

Forced out / offered up / placed "on the table" etc

The only way I see him leaving is if the Magpies sit him down and say "you will not get a game in the seniors next year and possibly into the future also" forcing Dawes to agree to a trade.

Otherwise he will not be forced out, offered up or placed on the table.

[Go the Biff 3,414]

FWIW I reckon he's going nowhere

Hasn't stopped us from generating a five page thread on it though !!!

[Gippsland Dee 367]

I think Old55 has this sorted. Pies looking to return to the forward structure that won them a flag. If however, Dawes is forced out due to salary cap constraints, he could certainly play a role with us. At the very least he could spread the opposition defence & reduce the double-teaming that Clark cops.

If he does end up looking for a new home, you'd think the Bulldogs would be barking and would be prepared to offer up more than most. Their forward line makes our midfield look well stocked.

McCartney has already said that the bulldogs are not interested in participating in the FA/trade period, focusing on the draft this year

[P-man 13,366]

12 months ago I'd have been alot more excited about this, but to say he's been cod ordinary this year would be paying the guy a compliment. The last type of player we need to be recruiting is a passenger.

Christ I hope Neeld knows what he's doing.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,024]

McCartney has already said that the bulldogs are not interested in participating in the FA/trade period, focusing on the draft this year

Tanking!!!

[dee-luded 2,959]

No one has indicated how they think we might be able to get Butcher. Is he actually on the table? As far as I can tell he signed a 2 year contract extension last year so is contracted until the end of next season. Has he actually said he wants out of Port or is this just another trademark Demonland fantasy trade?

Maybe port would use Cale to advantage? Both under performing & in need of a change.