Our best player in 3 years time?

[Kento80 83]

For me I have to say Trenners, but I reckon it will be a close fought battle between him and Wattsy. For smokey I'm gonna roll with Petterd. Probably won't be a popular selection, but if he can learn to play at his best consistently, the we have a real weapon there.

[Biffen 12,946]

Watts and Trengove will gain plenty of Brownlow votes in the future 3 seasons barring injury . Frawley to just get better .

[Pennant St Dee 13,304]

A week is a long time in football let alone 3 years look at the Cats from around 2001-2003/4 promising kids who now have become elite Scarlett, Ablett, Chapman, Johnson & Bartel not to mention other quality players from that group and 5 years ago around 06 who were Pendlebury & Swan

[ChannellingHopgoodAgro 4]

I agree that our best will be Watts. My smokey is Morton - really hoping he gets it together this year!

[PaulRB 6,411]

I think Jurrah will walk a bit smaller with Clark in the team...

Easy to argue the opposite, as Liam will be up against the third best defender with Clark and Watts likely to get the bigger defenders. That said, it would be unlikely the team would go through him as often as last year... Depends also where he fit's into the Game plan, perhaps he'll be used like Krakouer at the Pies, or running back into space, or leading out of the goal square, or on the flank...to state the obvious time will tell and his class will prevail...

Given he can be so damaging, especially in bursts he's a proven weapon.

Go Dees

Edited February 7, 2012 by PaulRB

[rpfc 28,769]

Easy to argue the opposite, as Liam will be up against the third best defender with Clark and Watts likely to get the bigger defenders. That said, it would be unlikely the team would go through him as often as last year... Depends also where he fit's into the Game plan, perhaps he'll be used like Krakouer at the Pies, or running back into space, or leading out of the goal square, or on the flank...to state the obvious time will tell and his class will prevail...

Given he can be so damaging, especially in bursts he's a proven weapon.

Go Dees

It was a joke, an irony.

You see, when people say a person will make another walk taller - they mean they will progress and do better.

I was mirroring that sentiment but infusing it with a ironic twist as Clark being in the team will mean Jurrah will do a number of things that 'smaller' forwards do, such as crumbing.

Hence, 'Jurrah will be walking smaller' is to say he will do well, but do it in a literally 'smaller' role.

I've heard the saying that if you have to explain jokes extensively then they are not funny.

I do not prescribe to this idea.

(Cough)

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Trenners and Watts equal best.

Interesting thoughts on Jurrah- he definitely has the skill set to be able to play the small forward role- and seeing as we don't need him to play tall he could spend a lot of time at the feet of others. What other options do we have at the moment? This is a move I would make if I was coach.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Yeah we got it- it just wasn't that funny..

[rpfc 28,769]

Yeah we got it- it just wasn't that funny..

Good!

I don't understand the last five words of that post.

[Lutz 76]

I like him do you have a roughy Lutz?

Gysberts from Watts and Trengove, with Howe and Blease as a smokies.

Edited February 7, 2012 by Lutz

[Viney12 196]

excellent topic

our best will be Watts

smokey for me is Bail

Agree re Bail

Think he's very underrated in the football world and a very important player on our team

[deeko 952]

Its hard to go past Watts and Trenners but I have a huuuuge man crush on Frank Grimes.

I remember snippets of him playing in the centre during NAB cup games and he reminds me so much of Jobe Watson. Hoping he can better him and become a full time mid. So he is my number 1 in 3 years.

Also have heard him speak and agree with everyone that he is great to listen to and even at such a young age has an aura.

In 3 years: Jamar/Gawn taps the pill down the throat of Jack T, Jack G & Jack V to hit Jack W lace out.... deelicious!

Smokey, Max Gawn. Did some great things in his couple games last season. A year of a Pizza & Steak diet with a lot of big weights and watch out league!!

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Smoky for mine would be Clark. Just dawned on me we're going to have Clark, Watts, Howe and Jurrah- all capable of a grab in our forward line next year. Exciting times!!

[Lutz 76]

Petterd..?

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Its hard to go past Watts and Trenners but I have a huuuuge man crush on Frank Grimes.

I remember snippets of him playing in the centre during NAB cup games and he reminds me so much of Jobe Watson. Hoping he can better him and become a full time mid. So he is my number 1 in 3 years.

Also have heard him speak and agree with everyone that he is great to listen to and even at such a young age has an aura.

In 3 years: Jamar/Gawn taps the pill down the throat of Jack T, Jack G & Jack V to hit Jack W lace out.... deelicious!

Smokey, Max Gawn. Did some great things in his couple games last season. A year of a Pizza & Steak diet with a lot of big weights and watch out league!!

Who are you? Casey Donovan's nutritionist?

[rjay 25,087]

Agree with Frawley but the term ELITE means top few players in the league.

I couldnt name our last elite player......

Robbie Flower

[Dr. Mubutu 866]

Robbie Flower

Woewodin WAS voted the best and fairest in the league.......

Taking Jordie_tackles' specifications, surely that tags him as elite?

[binman 43,757]

Yeah we got it- it just wasn't that funny..

I have to say i thought it was funny - and actually i reckon quite accurate. With Clark, Watts, Howe, Petterd and Green we have a surfeit of marking options. LJ will have license to go for the odd speccky but also be there to swoop on the crumbs - just like Wiz. When you think about he would make a pretty frightening "small" forward and dam hard to match up on too

Edited February 7, 2012 by binman

[Green Machine 63]

Trengove, and my smokey is Bail

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

Mitch Clark, Jack Trengove and Jack Grimes. We'll need at least 3 to be up near the top.

[The Chazz 4,077]

Scully

Newton

[Hannibal 5,814]

Elite players in the comp are Judd, Abblett, Goodes, Swan etc

I dont like when people break down elite into sub catogories

That's not my definition, although I agree that there's no official AFL definition; and even then it's subjective. Judd/Ablett/Goodes are super stars. I equate elite with genuine A graders. Right now we don't have one genuine A grader. Frawley and Jamar had A grade years in 2010, but one A grade year doesn't make someone an A grader. Although I have no doubt that the former will soon be rightfully called one and I'm hoping that a few others reach that status.

[Hannibal 5,814]

Woewodin WAS voted the best and fairest in the league.......

Exactly. Woewodin had an elite year, but he wasn't a superstar. Elite doesn't equal "superstar". Elite equals A grade.

[Slartibartfast 17,625]

Watts/Howe

[Range Rover 1,935]

Watts

Trengove

Frawley