Your Top 10 All-Time Favourite Demons

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

17 games.

That's Deefence's opinion on who's his favourite. No need to criticize. Bail is very good to watch and I wouldn't be surprised if he's on some more top 10 lists in the coming years.

Edited December 18, 2011 by Good Times Grimes

[Supermercado 2,797]

1988-

1. Allen Jakovich (1991 season fuelled my passion)

2. Phil Read (Ultimate cult figure, beloved by me but hated by many)

3. David Neitz (Machine)

4. Garry Lyon (Occassionally functioning machine. 1998 season still my favourite)

5. Jim Stynes (Ever reliable)

6. Russell Robertson (Frustrating but loveable)

7. Matthew Whelan (Most underrated player of my time)

8. Brad Green (very fashionable to ignore at the moment)

9. James McDonald (untainted for now even by the GW$ connection)

10. Andrew Leoncelli (Mr. Football Park)

Apologies to Martin, Frawley, Trengove (will all eventually qualify), Ingerson, Seecamp, T. Viney and for reasons only known to me Kevin Dyson, Jeff Hilton and Jamie Shanahan.

No apologies to Isaac Weetra, Wayne Lamb or Scott Simister.

[The Chazz 4,077]

1. The Wiz. One player you'd pay money to just go and watch. When he was on, nothing was impossible.

2. Robbie Flower. If it were based on best players, he'd be number 1 that I've seen.

3. Sean Wight. What he could do, and who he could do it on was truly remarkable. The 80's/90's had some of the greatest Full Forwards (Ablett, Dunstall, Lockett), and White could walk off with his head held high. Great man.

4. Al Jako. Wowee, what excitement. Anyone remember that goal he kicked against North - soccer goal, over his shoulder, about 30m out, was when they were building the Souther Stand?

5. Jeff White. I get the sense he has copped a bit on here, but he was one of the best rucks I've seen, and enjoyed going to a game to spend 70% of it watching White (when Wiz wasn't playing!).

6. Schwarz. Would have to be one of the worst luck stories. What could he have been if he stayed sound? Neitz was a better CHB than FF, but because of Scharz's knee, we didn't get to see that combination often enough.

7. Jimmy. Amazing man onfield, how is it possible he is a better man offield?

8. Travis Johnstone. I know, I know, but has there been a more skillful player ever to play for the Dees? When he was on, he had that amazing skill, like Flower, to seem to have all the time in the world. He was silk.

9. Jack Watts. No doubt at this stage there have been better players in my lifetime (30-odd years), but in 2011 there were moments where Watts took me to a place that I liked! When he starts doing that for games, and then seasons, rather than quarters, he'll be a true great.

10. Liam Jurrah. I hope he is a 10+ year player for us. That's all I will say.

So many other players that I could've added. Where it was hard for me is that I generally didn't pick our best player as my favourite. Trying to remember all the jumpers I owened, the Number 2 (Robbie) was my first, then followed by 27 (Wight), then I went to 43 (Andrew Ford), and then that was replaced by the 33 and since the Wiz departed, I've retired my back! When I thought about bringing it out of retirement, number 31 up and left, so I'm holding off for another 12 months!

[H_T 3,043]

1 Robert Flower

2 David Neitz

3 Garry Lyon

4 Stephen Tingay

5 Brett Lovett

6 Allen Jakovich

7 David Schwarz

8 Sean Wight

9. Jeff Farmer

10. Alan Johnson

[old55 23,547]

Robbie

Stan Alves

Alan Johnson

Allen Jakovich

David Schwarz

David Neitz

Todd Viney

Brett Lovett

Garry Lyon

Glenn Lovett

[The Chazz 4,077]

...

4. Al Jako. Wowee, what excitement. Anyone remember that goal he kicked against North - soccer goal, over his shoulder, about 30m out, was when they were building the Souther Stand?

...

Ok, so it may not have been 30m out, but was still a great goal!

[nutbean 8,838]

without giving my ten, one that hasnt been mentioned - even though he came from a different club and only played maybe 3 seasons - Steven Icke - a 6 foot CHB ( whose arms were 7'4" long) - rarely beaten and a great decision maker - cool as a cucumber

[Grimes is Great 183]

N.o.1 - Todd Viney - toughest MFC Player in last 25 yrs

2. Jackovich

3. Farmer

4. Tingay

5. Flower

6. Jimmy

7. Davey

8. Neitz

9. James Mac

10. Green

[Robbie57 2,020]

My list of favourite players:

1. Robbie Flower; I lived in Port during the dark years but would walk to the "G" and come home with the knowledge wehad the best player going around bar none.

2. Ronald Dale Barrassi: I am old. First number on my back. Had a pair of his boots. Remember going to the football with my dad just to see him.

3. Hassa Mann: Like Ronald Dale he is etched as a legend in my memory.

4. Gary Lyon: A true leader and barging tough.

5. Jimmy Stynes: Bar one moment of his career I loved watching him lope around the ground.

6. Adam Yze: How I wished he could go on forever...what was it that made him seem so much better than he was.

7. Rod Grinter: Neeld would have 6 of him in the team today. Imagine having him walk up to you at the start of a game.

8. Sean Wight: Desperate and totally lacking in fear. Would throw himself at the ball. Crazy double handed punches and lunges.

9. Jeff Farmer: "Wiz!" yelled the crowd. Say no more.

10. Gary Hardeman: Like Flower all class and better than the flashy pretender from North Melbourne on any given day.

Special mentions; Neitz, a ray of light in the dark, Jacko and Jacko (vich) both crazy and unpredictable. Fun to watch. David Schwartz oh my when he was on. Stinga, Stan Alves, Brett Lovett, Jeff White,Green, …I keep getting some greart memories from this thread keep it up.

Edited December 19, 2011 by Robbie57

[StillWoewodin22 5]

1. Tingay

2. Chopper Lovell

3. Woey

4. Robbie Flower

5. David Schwartz

6. Todd Viney

7. Andrew Leoncelli

8. Jimmy Stynes

9. Yeats

10 Sean Wight

[Mac7 309]

Bit different, but these were the table names at my wedding a couple of years ago:

Table 1: Norm Smith

Table 2: Rodney Grinter

Table 3: Jim Stynes

Table 4: Allen Jackovich

Table 5: David Schwartz

Table 6: Aaron Davey

Table 7: Robbie Flower

Table 8: Garry Lyon

Table 9: Ron Barassi

Table 10: David Neitz

[deesrule 104]

1: Ron Barassi only saw a little but the determination was incredible

2: Robbie Flower Best player in the league in a poor team got better in a good team

3: Tassie Johnston got to love a drop kick that lands in the centre circle

4: Hassa Man success folowed him

5: Stan Alves good entertainment sitting on the wing watch him avoid the tackle

6 :David Schwarz could have been the best CHF

7: Jim Stynes no further comment

8: Adam Yze magic before he got lazy

9:Brian Dixon ( only one I could catch for an autograph on the ground after the game)

10: Jack Trengove just for that sling tackle and for the future

[Still Waiting 94]

1, Robbie Flower

2, Garry Hardeman

3, Stinga

4, Jimmy

5, Ox

6, Todd Viney

7, Jakovich

8, Geepa

9, Alan Johnson

10, Wiz.

[Demon Rob 2]

Flower,

Jackovitch

Jackson - Mark!

Jurrah

Wiz

Stinga

Lyon

Sean Wight

Jimmy

Ox

Alan Johnson

[Pennant St Dee 13,171]

Only in order from my memory as a kid when I started following and when they came into the side

Flower - Pure Class

Grinter - Pure Hardness

Wight - Brave and a Freak

Viney - Won it where it mattered at clearances and stoppages

Lyon - Born Leader, Great footballer with booming kick What could have been with a stronger back

Stynesy - Heart bigger than Phar Laps IMO stands along with the Red Fox and Barrass as legends of this club

Stinger - What could have been when he was fit showed class, sadly body let him down

Schwarter - Crippled by injuries but at his best he was almost unstoppable

Neitzy - AA at CHB & FF, gave everything for the club and made defenders know he was there

Woey - Did everything he could to get the best out of himself, to think we let him go and kept Yze and Jonno

Chris Connelly was my favourite for a time in the 80's but like others on this list was crippled by injuries. Trevgove is my current favourite and shows great leadership for a kid his age, I see another Woey in him with a bit more talent.

[Angelus BTVS 31]

Without question...

1. Dannie Seow

2. Luke Beveridge

3. John Howat

4. Brent Heaver

5. Fabian Francis

6. Chris Sullivan

7. Wayne Henwood

8. Wayne Lamb

9. Haydn Robins

10. Scott Simister

:huh: :wacko:

[frankie_d 1,471]

3 "lesser lights"

Peter Walsh - never saw him make a decision error under pressure - part of that Northey era.

Grinter - more skill that given credit, and could walk the walk

Froggy Crompton - won us our last flag, by one point, against the filth. immortal

and

Flower, Ox, Ronald Dale, Bluey Adams, Jimmy, Jakovitch, Neeta,

[neeldbeforezod 2]

1. Stynes

2. Flower

3. Lyon

4. Viney

5. Neitz

6. Whelan

7. Robbo

8. Yze

9. Jurrah

10. Broady (RIP)

[DeeZee 7,378]

1.Robbie Flower

2.David Schwarz

3. Gary Hardeman

4.Stan Alves

5.Gary Lyon

6.Allen Jakovich

7.Jeff Farmer

8.Liam Jurrah

9.Jim Stynes

10 Hassa Mann

Edited December 19, 2011 by DeeZee

[Sideshow Bob 2,369]

Wow. Some good names on these lists. Good to see everyone remembers the names from their own personal heyday - for some reason they always seem better... For me

T Viney

B Lovett

A Jakovich

B Wilson

S Tingay

R Jackson

G Lyon

D Schwartz

S 'Strawberry' O'Dwyer/ J Stynes (they were definitely a duo as such one person...)

Torn between Danny Hughes and Sean Wight to round out the top 10

Strangely couldn't fit in Robbie Flower - I was twelve in '87 Robbie's last year/ the return to finals, I remember being a kid in the rooms running between and around the legs of the greats of the late 70's and early eighties many many times but strangely have a greater memory of the grunt and brilliance of Brian Wilson and don't fully recall the grace of Robbie. I wish I could remember more of Robbie other than he was really really nice off field. I recall how Peter Daicos made time stand still and was just a magician, I put Robbie in that class but unfortunately the memories aren't as sharp as they should be. I would have seen him play live a good 1 to 200 times. Hmmm

[s-t-i-n-g-a 439]

Great to see a lot of love for Stinga!

I remember in 2000 hoping he would come back...would have given us some toughness we lacked on that last day in September. Had the biggest guns in the AFL. Alas a career cut too short.

[Rogue 585]

Is any body actually counting these votes, would be very interesting to see the outcome

Congratulations, you're hired!

[Nasher 33,613]

Peter Walsh - never saw him make a decision error under pressure - part of that Northey era.

You're about a decade out - Walsh was Daniher era. One of my favourites at the time too though.

[Wilson7 2,668]

1. David Neitz

2. Robbie Flower

3. Allen Jakovich

4. David Schwarz

5. Rod Grinter

6. Jeff Farmer

7. Steven Stretch

8. Brian Wilson

9. Darren Bennett

10. Alan Johnson

Edited December 19, 2011 by DavidNeitz9

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

You're about a decade out - Walsh was Daniher era. One of my favourites at the time too though.

IMHO one of the most underrated players in the time that I have been following the MFC.