Ross Lyon

[old dee 23,781]

They fracked around on Cousins for quite a while and looked indecisive at the end of it.

Yes they did RR and thanks for the new avatar.

JM if I am not wrong!

[pitchfork 181]

SEN just reported Lyon meeting with StK players...likely to leave Saints.

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

Rumours on SEN that Lyon's meeting with the Saints playing group privately right now ....letting them know first

Could be the smoke.....

[Craig Drinker 179]

SEN just reported Lyon meeting with StK players...likely to leave Saints.

Do you think that means we've already stitched him up or not necessarily?

[Demon17 5,186]

Do you think that means we've already stitched him up or not necessarily?

Can someone start a SEN post on this. Perhaps after last nights deplorable effort by Michael nettlefold(this best he could do under the circumstances) Lyon belives in doing the right thing and dealing with this isssue right away.

Grant Thomas asked G. Lyon was he under the same management as R. Lyon during the interview.

Also on the hour before both Walls and Darcy advised Lyon to join the Dees as his the evryone else's best outcome

[H_T 3,043]

I found last nights interview with Nettlefold on FC unbelievable. St.Kilda have a very good coach who is under contract next year and plan to extend his contract. What is the hold up ? Perhaps it's R.Lyon holding back for a better deal $. Since he changed management mid-year (going to Craig Kelly's team at Elite Properties - same management team who manages G.Lyon). Given what took place in the busy off-season last year concerning the school girl, as well as their indifferent poor form in the first half of the year. Perhaps R.Lyon has had enough of the increase in grey hairs or loss of hair ?

And just maybe an enticing offer to coach elsewhere is the tonic he needs ? Or not.

If it is to happen, it should happen quickly. Whether St Kilda sign him or move on to other pastures.

[Jarka 767]

They fracked around on Cousins for quite a while and looked indecisive at the end of it.

My understanding of that situation was that the Footy Dept definitely wanted him and had made a handshake agreement. But the Board got cold feet with some of the comments from their fans and sponsors and then stepped in and put a stop to it.

[Mono 455]

$5 million for 5 years.

First $cullys $6 mill., then this. Idiocy.

Reminiscent of CEO's ludicrous salaries.

Rediculous.

[demoniac 1,330]

They didn't pay much except for Lovett and that was a big risk that could have paid off big - Lovett in the first GF last year = Saints win.

Lovett - trade pick 16

Schneider and Dempster - trade pick 26

Michael Gardiner and Birss - trade pick 43

Peake - trade pick 48

Gamble - pick 90

King and Charlie Gardiner - trade pick 90

Polo - pick 103

Dawson - Rookie pick 13

The Luke Ball deal was a fiasco though.

They did pay quite alot..in terms of precious spots on a limited list.

[Real Demon 232]

http://www.sportsnewsfirst.com.au/articles/2011/09/13/ross-lyon-looks-headed-for-melbourne/

Well if it isn't our good friend Kim HACKdorn

If it was anyone else reporting it, I'd be pumped!

[Real Demon 232]

$5 million for 5 years.

First $cullys $6 mill., then this. Idiocy.

Reminiscent of CEO's ludicrous salaries.

Rediculous.

Don't agree...........if you sack a first time coach, and determine you want the best available experienced coach, then it's inevitable you are going to have to dangle a mighty fine carrot to get a coach to leave their club, particularly when they are still contracted.

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

I found last nights interview with Nettlefold on FC unbelievable. St.Kilda have a very good coach who is under contract next year and plan to extend his contract. What is the hold up ? Perhaps it's R.Lyon holding back for a better deal $. Since he changed management mid-year (going to Craig Kelly's team at Elite Properties - same management team who manages G.Lyon). Given what took place in the busy off-season last year concerning the school girl, as well as their indifferent poor form in the first half of the year. Perhaps R.Lyon has had enough of the increase in grey hairs or loss of hair ?

And just maybe an enticing offer to coach elsewhere is the tonic he needs ? Or not.

If it is to happen, it should happen quickly. Whether St Kilda sign him or move on to other pastures.

Nettlefold didn't look confident at any stage last night. I suspect they're fighting a rear guard action to try and win him back.

Not easy when a big offer with more years of service is on the table.

Lyon's management would be negligent if they weren't looking to maximise his pay cheque here given all the bites he must be getting and that he would be in the top 3 to 4 of the options available.

Edited September 13, 2011 by Rusty Nails

[Deetective Sgt. Taggert 389]

Do you think that means we've already stitched him up or not necessarily?

Or perhaps its just a regular end-of season review...

[nutbean 8,838]

Nettlefold didn't look confident at any stage last night. I suspect they're fighting a rear guard action to try and win him back.

Not easy when a big offer with more years of service is on the table.

Lyon's management would be negligent if they weren't looking to maximise his pay cheque here given all the bites he must be getting and that he would be in the top 3 to 4 of the options available.

The "spirit" and "intent" of the Lyon contract is for another 12 months - compare that to Eddie MacGuire - "If Mick decides to go elsewhere we will go legal"

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

My understanding of that situation was that the Footy Dept definitely wanted him and had made a handshake agreement. But the Board got cold feet with some of the comments from their fans and sponsors and then stepped in and put a stop to it.

I think the there were some references that were sought by the Board at a late staqe which added to the supporters and sponsors. They did seem to vacillate over the issue.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Great call........coach yes, recruiting input no!

Lovett, Dempster, Dawson, Peake, Gardiner, Polo, Gamble are examples as to why.

You gotta remember he was in charge of a top 3 team at the time. He didn't have the timetable available to choose all kids. He needed depth and fill needs quickly. He nearly got there,,, except for they're losing culture. when they got in front in the dying seconds of the Gran' fianale', the saints put their hands in they're pockets.

[Mac7 309]

$5 million for 5 years.

First $cullys $6 mill., then this. Idiocy.

Reminiscent of CEO's ludicrous salaries.

Rediculous.

Why?

How much do you think Essendon is paying for their coaching Team?

How much to you think Clarkson is getting?

How much do you think we would have to pay for Malthouse?

Good people cost a lot of money. If we are serious about wanting to compete then we have to spend money getting the best people to our club.

We are basically head hunting one of the best coaches in the league away from another club, it’s not going to be cheap. If it pays off then the $5 million will be made in Premiership memorabilia alone!!

[drdrake 3,162]

To me the only way Lyon will leave St Kilda is if he and the ST Kilda Board want a different direction. What happens if Lyon goes to the board and states this list is at its end we need to trade agressively and start a rebuild. When asked who do we trade Lyon throws up names like Goddard, Dal Santo, Roo, the board isn't happy with this and believe they have the cattle to win a premiership. All of the sudden the coach and the board want to take the team in different directions.

The board may also be looking at Geelong and thinking maybe a new coach might just give this group one last crack.

[davey_magik 1]

I think Lyon would do a wonderful job with our list TBH.

I think our list talent-wise is better than St.Kildas (I think our core young group will be better than theirs in a few years and with more depth) and Lyon would be silly not to play more attacking football with the ability at his disposal. He also wouldn't take laziness from the players or inconsistent efforts.

[old55 23,402]

To me the only way Lyon will leave St Kilda is if he and the ST Kilda Board want a different direction. What happens if Lyon goes to the board and states this list is at its end we need to trade agressively and start a rebuild. When asked who do we trade Lyon throws up names like Goddard, Dal Santo, Roo, the board isn't happy with this and believe they have the cattle to win a premiership. All of the sudden the coach and the board want to take the team in different directions.

I disagree, all that has to happen is for Lyon to go to the board and tell them he wants to coach MFC - they're not going to force him to see out the last year of his contract - they don't want a coach who doesn't want to be there.

[Longsufferingnomore 1,631]

Don't agree...........if you sack a first time coach, and determine you want the best available experienced coach, then it's inevitable you are going to have to dangle a mighty fine carrot to get a coach to leave their club, particularly when they are still contracted.

carrot is dangling

[old55 23,402]

He nearly got there,,, except for they're losing culture. when they got in front in the dying seconds of the Gran' fianale', the saints put their hands in they're pockets.

That's complete and utter bullsh1t - they fought it out to the bitter end in both matches. Against Geelong it was Scarlett's brilliant toe poke and against Collingwood it was a cruel bounce in front of Milne that prevented them from winning. In the dying minutes of Collingwood draw Riewoldt took an inspirational pack mark 4 deep on the HBF that he had no right to make and kicked into the corridor to set up a scoring opportunity. Lenny Hayes kicked a longer goal than he ever has on tired legs. They fought it out fantastically.

[Real Demon 232]

That's complete and utter bullsh1t - they fought it out to the bitter end in both matches. Against Geelong it was Scarlett's brilliant toe poke and against Collingwood it was a cruel bounce in front of Milne that prevented them from winning. In the dying minutes of Collingwood draw Riewoldt took an inspirational pack mark 4 deep on the HBF that he had no right to make and kicked into the corridor to set up a scoring opportunity. Lenny Hayes kicked a longer goal than he ever has on tired legs. They fought it out fantastically.

Spot on!

And if either of those had have eventuated, we would be no hope of getting him!

[drdrake 3,162]

I disagree, all that has to happen is for Lyon to go to the board and tell them he wants to coach MFC - they're not going to force him to see out the last year of his contract - they don't want a coach who doesn't want to be there.

It is that simple agree but he has to want to coach the MFC and to me to only reason he would leave St Kilda is if him and the board disagree on something, it could be 2 years instead of 3 but IMO it will more likely be the direction of the team. Ross Lyon is on Record stating it is the end of an era, if the board doesn't agree with his statements we have a new coach.

If he signs with MFC no matter what the real reason is at the press conference both St Kilda and ours the reason will be stated that St Kilda and Lyon had different opinions on the direction of the club.

Edited September 13, 2011 by drdrake

[old55 23,402]

It is that simple agree but he has to want to coach the MFC and to me to only reason he would leave St Kilda is if him and the board disagree on something, it could be 2 years instead of 3 but IMO it will more likely be the direction of the team. Ross Lyon is on Record stating it is the end of an era, if the board doesn't agree with his statements we have a new coach.

He might simply think it's the end of an era and time to move on, no need for direction disagreement - his direction is outta there.