Josh Fraser...2nd ruck?

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

The scary thing, is that if we'd lost that game to Carlton, we'd have had pick 1 instead of pick 4, and would have had the PP before the first round the following year, instead of after (pick 2, instead of pick 18)

If we'd lost that one game, our ruck division would be: Jamar, Kruiser and Nic Natanui. WOWOWOWOW!!!!

I dont believe MFC would have taken Kruezer at 1 if they had him. We had pick 4 in that draft and we were rapt to have got Morton. I understand that Cotchin was preferred to Kruezer. Although for a ruckman Kruezer if very promising. If we did get Kruezer we would not have been taking Nik Nat who in IMO has all the media heat but is still raw and unproven.

[big tuna 0]

Another negative about getting Fraser is that I wouldn't be able to hang as much sh!t on my filth supporting mates. I usually only play this card when they have a crack about Watts or Trapper. They used to defend him and make excuses but now they have absolutely no come back for any Fraser related jibes, and often agree

[DeeSpencer 23,714]

One of Warnock (23 years old) or Hampson (22 years old) from Carlton would be worth looking at. Both are behind Kreuzer and currently behind Jacobs as well.

I'm not sure they would be a long term answer as successful second rucks as they can't do much else but ruck, but they would add depth behind Jamar, probably along with Spencer and Gawn.

Would allow us to give PJ the flick with no concerns.

I still have some faith in Martin. He and Fitzpatrick seem the best suited to play as second rucks as they offer something up forward.

[Roost It 1,434]

NO

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

One of Warnock (23 years old) or Hampson (22 years old) from Carlton would be worth looking at. Both are behind Kreuzer and currently behind Jacobs as well.

I'm not sure they would be a long term answer as successful second rucks as they can't do much else but ruck, but they would add depth behind Jamar, probably along with Spencer and Gawn.

If they cant do anything but ruck then what is the use of them as a 2nd ruck? Why would you just recruit for depth if they would be competing with Spencer and GAWN. If they are not getting a game in front of Jacobs then clearly they are no further along the progress path

Would allow us to give PJ the flick with no concerns.

We should be doing that anyway. PJ gives us zip. His position will be taken by a rookie and Spencer will be elevated.

I still have some faith in Martin. He and Fitzpatrick seem the best suited to play as second rucks as they offer something up forward.

That's the issue. We need a player to pinch hit in the 2nd ruck role

[Rogue 585]

With the trend towards a pinch-hitter playing the second ruck role it's even more odd that people are advocating for a second ruck who can't do much else other than ruck (...and not ruck well enough to be your number one ruck!).

[WonnaJurah 5]

haha he is a deadset dud atm

big pass for me, better off having Sylvia in ruck instead of him

[DEEfactor 6]

Another negative about getting Fraser is that I wouldn't be able to hang as much sh!t on my filth supporting mates. I usually only play this card when they have a crack about Watts or Trapper. They used to defend him and make excuses but now they have absolutely no come back for any Fraser related jibes, and often agree

Agree totally. Richmond gets rubbished constantly for picking Tambling instead of Buddy or Roughhead... but the Filth chose Fraser over Pavlich (very glad btw that SuperPav isn't wearing black and white, it would've made the Buckley worship seem minor).

And yes, I will acknowledge the Tigers picked Fiora before Pavlich in the same draft. That hurts.

[Demon Rob 2]

always good to have a comedy thread

[Sir Why You Little 35,392]

Josh Fraser?? Cannot stand the bloke....cant remember what year but remember him giving the wave to Jeff White on one particular Queens B'day game after the wobblers got a good start.....we ended up running all over them which was as sweet as it gets!!

I remember that moment well. Jeff White remembered it too, and absolutely caned that over rated Hack.

Please let us not see Josh "Malcolm" Fraser in a MFC Jumper.

[Guest Rojik of the Arctic]

The replies sum up my feelings. The only recycled players I would be happy with at the Dees will come in the PSD and I don't see us using that for a while.

[Disco Demons 92]

we already have a josh fraser...but his name is meesen...both had the potential but amounted to nothing.

[Swampfox 190]

Looking from the outside in i would expect Collingwood to be dissapointed with the progress of Josh Fraser

To me he plays like a Follower and not at all like a Ruckman

When he was drafted he was the next big thing according to some

Looks like one of those who only has himself to blame through lack of work not lack of ability

Not interested in Fraser in a Melbourne Jumper even if he played for free

Edited May 28, 2010 by Swampfox

[jayceebee31 692]

For once I totally agree with Rino.

NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO WAY!

And Me TOO! Especially after Jamar belted him QB.

Edited June 15, 2010 by jayceebee31

[H_T 2,941]

Looking from the outside in i would expect Collingwood to be dissapointed with the progress of Josh Fraser

Confirmation they were disappointed, when they traded for Jolly.

Big "No" from me.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

please no...

[dee-luded 2,958]

Ok maybe not. I'm interested as to who people think WOULD be a good (experienced) 2nd ruck to pick up? We definitely need someone to support the big Russian sooner rather than later.

Just a thought starter - relax hey?

Your looking past whats already there. Spencer is not far off as a regular 2nd ruck, he just needs plenty of games. If,,, you don't want to be patient, then persist with PJ for just one more.

Personally, IMO, we are only into Rnd 9 or something this year, a developing players year. Lets give Spencer @ least another 9 - 10 games this year, there's 13 games to come.

By next summer, after another pre season of fitness & weight work, he'll be even bigger, & hopefully, angrier.

He's our next genuine 2nd ruck, ahead of perhaps gawn.

If we were to recruit a backup, that would mean we've let PJ go, so, in that scenario I'd prefer a mobile follower type bigman, as a short term situation.

[dee-luded 2,958]

Looking from the outside in i would expect Collingwood to be dissapointed with the progress of Josh Fraser

To me he plays like a Follower and not at all like a Ruckman

When he was drafted he was the next big thing according to some

Looks like one of those who only has himself to blame through lack of work not lack of ability

Not interested in Fraser in a Melbourne Jumper even if he played for free

I don't think he does either well.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Oh God please no...

[Deeman 1,435]

The best way to bring happiness and a smile to every Collingwood supporter's face would be for us to take Fraser off their hands.

[Deevout 456]

Oh God please no...

Ditto to this.

No room on our list now for big mistakes...

[monoccular 16,745]

No No No No No No.

A balloon would float more effectively in the forward line than Fraser.

Insipid attitude and no physical presence. A wet sponge of a big man.

Jolly is not doing much at the Pies. Wood is being played as a second ruck and he isnt much. What does this say about Fraser?

Pass

I would rather have Newton as a ruckman - even he has more of a physical presence than Fraser - that's how bad I feel Fraser is as a ruckman.

[Jarka 767]

I'd prefer going after Kosi, and that's saying alot.

[hillie 41]

our best second ruck this year has been dunn. i think we need a more athletic type ruckman to compliment jamar. a paddy type or, i hate to say it, a nic nat type. that type can act as another midfielder and also can push forward to add to the scoreboard.

[Guest The Boss]

Josh Fraser is too soft, never been a fan.

The only instance he should come across is through the PSD, and ONLY if he is the best available player at our pick. If Collingwood do get rid of him, I have a feeling he will be Gold Coast bound anyway. As far as I know, GC17 do not have any ruckmen that are ready to step straight into AFL so Fraser could fill the gap for 1-2 years.