2008 Player Review - #3 Clint Bartram

[Demonland 72,213]

3. Clint Bartram [181cm 73kg 16.02.88 - 44 games (21 in 2008), 11 goals (5 in 2008)] - made a tentative comeback after suffering a season ending knee injury after round one of 2007 and managed 21 games but failed to fulfil the promise of his debut season. Question marks still exist over his disposal and decision making and next year will be important for him.

[Red and Blue Flame 187]

if he's still at Melbourne

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Question marks still exist over his disposal and decision making and next year will be important for him.

But hang on he is good trade bait according to some!

[beelzebub 23,378]

But hang on he is good trade bait according to some!

:D

[beelzebub 23,378]

Clint !!

Another of the "burst onto the scene in blazing glory only to fade to grey ( for whatever reason) "

As a club we have this down pat dont we

A victim of injury and restrict preparations this year he will certainly have to show something to warrant his maintenance on the list.

The plus for him...is he is far from alone

add another to the "its all in the preseason brigade " !!

[The HuLK 139]

seems as soon as he started playing the tagging role he has struggled.. Maybe mis-coached?

[wisedog 352]

Clint !!

Another of the "burst onto the scene in blazing glory only to fade to grey ( for whatever reason) "

As a club we have this down pat dont we huh.gif

From memory, in his debut season, it was his tagging roles that caught our attention. He got swag of tackles each game, but I don't recall him ever being a prolific ball winner. Unrealistic expectations on the kid I think.

Another pre-season under Bailey, and we'll see how he goes in 09.

[waynewussell 5,748]

Clint played the tagging role from game 1. He hasn't sustained the standards set in first year, but was persevered with in 2008. Bezzle and Rhino seem to have a mortgage on estimates of player (and poster) worth around here, so I wouldn't want to offer an opinion that strayed too far from the one those two illuminaries have already expressed, however, Bartram will need to regain early form to hold his place in 2009.

[Guest Chopper]

I think Clint had an average season.

He played a defensive role, mainly as a tagger. But the best taggers in today's game are the ones who are just as dominate as their direct opponent should be. Worth keeping but needs to have a big season next year.

[brey9186 102]

should be a great pacy back pocket/negator, but his disposal and decision making seem to let him down a bit

[Guest skipper3]

His first year was as a tagger - so, it isnt been mis-coached!

This year was pretty much his first full year since he made his debut - he will be much better for the 09 pre-season & will improve in 09

.

seems as soon as he started playing the tagging role he has struggled.. Maybe mis-coached?

[rpfc 28,447]

Disposal lets him down but gets a pass mark for the year because he was coming back from injury.

Commitment cannot be questioned.

Persist with.

[H_T 3,047]

3. Clint Bartram [181cm 73kg 16.02.88 - 44 games (21 in 2008), 11 goals (5 in 2008)] - made a tentative comeback after suffering a season ending knee injury after round one of 2007 and managed 21 games but failed to fulfil the promise of his debut season. Question marks still exist over his disposal and decision making and next year will be important for him.

"Failed to fulfil the promise of his debut season." - Will need to improve he's skills, gives 100%.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

..Rhino seem to have a mortgage on estimates of player (and poster) worth around here, so I wouldn't want to offer an opinion....

....that claimed massive upside in a player when he has a lack of pace and limited penetration by foot. B)

[Nasher 33,616]

Clint !!

Another of the "burst onto the scene in blazing glory only to fade to grey ( for whatever reason) "

I think a more realistic assessment would be that he arrived at the club already at his best game and hasn't gotten any better. I don't think he's gotten worse than when he arrived at the club. People are just assessing his game as a third year player now rather than as a first.

[Whispering_Jack 30,173]

It's very difficult to assess a player in the first year immediately after a long lay off with a knee injury such as that suffered by Clint Bartram. I think we need to see how he goes next year before we start writing him off. After all, he's still only a 20 year old!

[deanox 9,927]

I think a more realistic assessment would be that he arrived at the club already at his best game and hasn't gotten any better. I don't think he's gotten worse than when he arrived at the club. People are just assessing his game as a third year player now rather than as a first.

i think thats a fair assesment. and it should probably be noted that his preseasons have been limited by injury, so in effect this year was a continuation of his first (drawing a long bow? lol). hopefully he will have a chance to sit down with bails and outline a plan to work on over summer. and hopefully he stays injury free until this time next year, so we can see what improvement he makes...

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

It's very difficult to assess a player in the first year immediately after a long lay off with a knee injury such as that suffered by Clint Bartram. I think we need to see how he goes next year before we start writing him off. After all, he's still only a 20 year old!

Good point. He is really a 2nd year player for all the football he has missed.

[titan_uranus 25,020]

It's very difficult to assess a player in the first year immediately after a long lay off with a knee injury such as that suffered by Clint Bartram. I think we need to see how he goes next year before we start writing him off. After all, he's still only a 20 year old!

Add that to the fact that he was one of few players in the team who gave 100% at all times this year. Criticism at the moment is unwarranted IMO.

[jacey 333]

a player when he has a lack of pace and limited penetration by foot. B)

Definitely disposals and decision making/awareness but lack of leg speed?

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Definitely disposals and decision making/awareness but lack of leg speed?

My comment was in reference to massive upside on Nathan Jones in another thread.