DEMONS DUMP MACCA- ITS OFFICIAL

[Guest unstable punt]

Don't know if he was right for the job as he was not there long. However, i like the way JS is going about his business, getting the people around him that he wants, not just puts up with who is there.

bring on Cameron Schwab

[Guest unstable punt]

I think it’s really disappointing.

We should have at least found another one to take over straight away

And waited until the end of the year.

agree with that, end of year

[rpfc 27,673]

agree with that, end of year

Not going to happpen with the whispers growing louder.

Mike Sheahan revealed it and it would be constantly discussed, best to make the decision public when it was made privately.

Fox is untried, so I guess assurances have been made by Schwab that he will takeover.

We are an embarrassment.

Please, let this be the end of it.

[praha 10,552]

I'm not at all critical of this. We've got a new guy come in and take control of the organization. If he believes part of it isn't up to his standard or doesn't fit in with what he wants to do, he can change it. No matter how long they've been a part of the company. Macca fit in with Gardner's vision, not Stynes'.

[Jaded No More 59,781]

God help this football club.

[Mousey 47]

Why is everyone so sad and devastated about this?

Paul Mac.. i didnt hear a peep out of other than an idea of having a kid day>? wow i could do that!

Paul Gardiner is the reason for all these poor decisions. Only good thing he did was appoint Bailey as the coach in my mind.

Good on stynes to clean up the mess as quickly as possible and to start the search for a qualified person who has been in the industry and understands what it takes to run a football club.

Jimmy you have my backing and i applaud the tough decisions being made now not in 12 months.

[mattie 0]

Lighten up everyone.

Surely the new Board would have only taken such a dramatic, controversial and costly step if it had good reasons. Or do some of the posters here think they are all crazy?

Surely by now we should have no faith that the old Board got the appointment right.

So give Jim a break. He's clearing the decks so we can start afresh. Hopefully he has got it right.

Judge ONLY by the outcome over the next year or so.

[w00dy 146]

took some balls from stynes to make this call... it was a call that obviously needed to be made... backing the board on this 100%...

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Paul Mac.. i didnt hear a peep out of other than an idea of having a kid day>? wow i could do that!

But you didn't.

[Roost It 1,434]

God help this football club.

God is helping and that's why Stynes is in and McNamee is out

[Mousey 47]

But you didn't.

No i didnt....

but you cant honestly think that is an earth moving idea from someone who is getting paid so much money to do this?

[jacey 333]

God is helping and that's why Stynes is in and McNamee is out

god's hungover after a massive week partying.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

No i didnt....

but you cant honestly think that is an earth moving idea from someone who is getting paid so much money to do this?

It was one quick idea, early in the season as a means of getting more people through the gates. It's not as if his whole strategy was based around this idea, but rather a quick and simple idea that seemed to be pretty popular and successful given the number of people on the ground after the game.

[Deeoldfart 7,839]

Maybe I'm alone, but I don't want a running commentary of discussion on the tenure of staff played out in members emails or constant press releases.

You are definitely not alone Rogue.

[Rogue 585]

but you cant honestly think that is an earth moving idea from someone who is getting paid so much money to do this?

It was better than what we had in the years before.

Just because you haven't heard of anything else doesn't mean it's not happened.

Stynes highlighted McNamee's work on the Casey Fields project, and strengthening ties with the MCC.

[Mousey 47]

It was one quick idea, early in the season as a means of getting more people through the gates. It's not as if his whole strategy was based around this idea, but rather a quick and simple idea that seemed to be pretty popular and successful given the number of people on the ground after the game.

True but thats not a lot is it for the position our club is in right now?

We need someone who has been there done that and get things done quickly, who knows football.

I still think the Wimbledon trip is the thing that tipped jimmy and board over the edge, when everyone else was working hard to try turn things around our CEO goes away and plays tennis,all during the most important yet dark times for our club.

[re draft molan 1]

Wow......And I thought we bottomed out several weeks ago. Apparrently we have a way to go yet!

[tez 6]

what gets me is the way it has been leaked to the media goes to show leopards dont change their spots, i realy do hope this stops and now otherwise the ship won't just leak it will start to list.

POOR FORM

[Cards13 9,117]

God help this football club.

I don't think Ablett fits into Yoda's youth policy JD...

[Cards13 9,117]

Lighten up everyone.

Surely the new Board would have only taken such a dramatic, controversial and costly step if it had good reasons. Or do some of the posters here think they are all crazy?

Surely by now we should have no faith that the old Board got the appointment right.

So give Jim a break. He's clearing the decks so we can start afresh. Hopefully he has got it right.

Judge ONLY by the outcome over the next year or so.

The issue is we do not have that much time, we are on our last gasps if we do not stop loosing money hand over fist. As one poster pointed out how much of our debt over the last two years has been to do with covering costs of employees we've moved on? Close to $1.5/$2mill?

And if you want to judge Jim over a year or so why would Paul Mac not get the same time frames from the board?

I don't know if it is a right or wrong choice but my goodness from the outside looking in we still look a mess.

The reasoning behind the descision might be sound but at the same time I hope we can get someone into the role very very quickly, if a board member is running the day to day CEO function, it would surprise me if he had the time to do an exceptional job if he has a day job....

The other worry is Casey, how does this affect that going forward? Is this going to be the 3rd person (Spargo) from the club who has been in charge of it now? Casey must be a little concerned with that.

[45HG 1,539]

This footy club is going down the toilet.

I've never been so distressed about the MFC. The first 450,000 raised by debt demolition can go towards paying out our CEO's.

How could he be on such ludicrous salary? 8 teachers wages that is.

Same old boys club that has always reeked from our club.

Curse of the Norm indeed

[melbournefc 18]

I'm trusting Jimmy Stynes' approach on this. I was never a fan of Paul Gardiner, and think Paul McNamee being hired by Gardiner had the same 'vision'. You can tell Jimmy Stynes is well and truly focused at taking this club places.

Jimmy, if you're reading this...give Cameron Schwab another go. He was the very same guy who brought us Diamond Joe Gutnick....

[Geddy Lee 582]

If the SEN rumour - mentioned earlier in the thread - is correct, MacNamee wasn't the #1 choice after this search, but PG took him on board.

This is the crux of the matter.

Jim Stynes was furious when MacNamee was selected, PG not listening to his team.

He is rectifying the situation.

I personally have no problem with it because I disagreed with his appointment.

[45HG 1,539]

Why didn't Jim challenge for the board at this time then?

[two sheds jackson 3]

I agree with Tez- regardless of the rightness or wrongness of the decision (and we really dont know enough to say one way or the other), the way its all come about is a big worry. If the new board were keen to get rid of McNamee from day one, then they obviously meant to keep a lid on it so that they could put the feelers out and get as good of an idea as possible about potential replacements before publicly announcing a decision. It looks like someone in the know (possibly even a board member) might have blown that plan out of the water by leaking it to Sheahan, forcing the club to announce the decision sooner than they would have liked.

The fact that there has been no mention of a possible change of CEO in the media until yesterday, that McNamee himself only found out about it through the media, and that Stynes' press conference was announced only after PM's sacking was common knowledge -in short, the whole way this situation has been handled- screams of panic.