41 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

You can mount a case that every club will have a list of young talent that they could reel off as well.

Still felt we are a bit short on talent to be honest and there is a need to continue to stock pile yet again.

There are still question marks on some names that are either haven't been exposed at AFL level or have, but haven't shown anything close to being AFL standard.

I said earlier in the year that ideally we'd have another off season or two like the last two, and bring in 2-3 first rounders, but we're just not going to have the draft capital.

So either we get them through trading or JT pulls some rookies out of the hat ala Turner and McVee.

5 minutes ago, Adam The God said:

I said earlier in the year that ideally we'd have another off season or two like the last two, and bring in 2-3 first rounders, but we're just not going to have the draft capital.

So either we get them through trading or JT pulls some rookies out of the hat ala Turner and McVee.

My hope is to get back into the first round, but at what cost, I dont know..

6 minutes ago, Adam The God said:

I said earlier in the year that ideally we'd have another off season or two like the last two, and bring in 2-3 first rounders, but we're just not going to have the draft capital.

So either we get them through trading or JT pulls some rookies out of the hat ala Turner and McVee.

Just now, dazzledavey36 said:

My hope is to get back into the first round, but at what cost, I dont know..

I can think of 2 players who I’d consider moving along if we got high picks for them. Do we ask for a high pick and cop the high shared salary. It’s probably the only way we can get into the first round.

2 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

My hope is to get back into the first round, but at what cost, I dont know..

Is it worth getting back into the first round this year? Or better trading for players this year then try to load up in the first round next year assuming it’s a stronger draft?

11 hours ago, Fritta and Turner said:

Herbert?

Assume the poster meant Lindsay !!

9 hours ago, ANG13 said:

Is it worth getting back into the first round this year? Or better trading for players this year then try to load up in the first round next year assuming it’s a stronger draft?

I think anytime that you can get into the first round is always a bonus.

I'm a big believer that you're always going to get quality high end talent in the early round regardless if its a weak draft or not.

8 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

I think anytime that you can get into the first round is always a bonus.

I'm a big believer that you're always going to get quality high end talent in the early round regardless if its a weak draft or not.

All depends on the cost I guess. If we could trade Trac to the likes of the bombers I’m happy to get a first round pick in this years or next years draft even if that means paying a large junk of his wages for a couple of years.

I’m not in favour of trading our future first and a selection of second rounders to get into a highly compromised draft lacking quality.

I’d rather try and fill a lot of holes over two off-seasons than a quick fix now.

14 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

23 and under:

A grade (future stars): Langford

B+ (quality players):Bowie, Turner, Windsor, McVee, Lindsay

B (could be difference makers): Kolt, Kentfield

C+ (could contribute): JVR, Mentha

C (role players or possible contributors) Howes, Jeffo, AMW, Adams, Culley

Ungraded: the rest

It’s a reasonable list of young players, we’ll know a lot more in 12 months time about where the key forwards are at.

Good summation, only notable difference I would have is Jeffo as 'could contribute' (if the stars align; I thought there were some fleeting moments against North and Carlton that showed there just might be something there), and Kolt under role player / possible contributor (at best).

21 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

I think anytime that you can get into the first round is always a bonus.

I'm a big believer that you're always going to get quality high end talent in the early round regardless if its a weak draft or not.

If we can get back in by moving out a player (or two), I wouldn't necessarily be against it. But, I think we also need to bring in some much needed depth in that second - fourth round range, so if coming back in came at the cost of us packaging multiple picks I don't think we're in the right space to be doing those sort of movements. Granted as you rightfully pointed out, this year is both a weakened and compromised draft so potentially you could mount the argument that there is less impact in doing so, but I definitely wouldn't be moving future picks to do so given we could be looking at bottom four finishes in the next few years, coupled with the (potential) compromised Tasmanian drafts.

I guess the TLDR; yes, if we're able to get capital via outgoing player movements; no - if we're packaging current/future picks to do so.

Edited Tuesday at 21:463 days by BLWNBA

17 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

23 and under:

A grade (future stars): Langford

B+ (quality players):Bowie, Turner, Windsor, McVee, Lindsay

B (could be difference makers): Kolt, Kentfield

C+ (could contribute): JVR, Mentha

C (role players or possible contributors) Howes, Jeffo, AMW, Adams, Culley

Ungraded: the rest

It’s a reasonable list of young players, we’ll know a lot more in 12 months time about where the key forwards are at.

This is the most accurate assessment in my view.

We have some reasonable but speculative young talent. Probably about the average or slightly above for most AFL lists.

12 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

My hope is to get back into the first round, but at what cost, I dont know..

we have nothing to trade

Lever to North makes sense but I doubt that due to chronic injuries

Nothing significant For Viney Trac or oliver

Fritter maybe an upper second

Hard to see where we go

3 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Assume the poster meant Lindsay !!

Probs; Xavier Lindsay = Xavier Herbert = Poor Fella (MFC) My Country (AFL)

3 hours ago, BLWNBA said:

Good summation, only notable difference I would have is Jeffo as 'could contribute' (if the stars align; I thought there were some fleeting moments against North and Carlton that showed there just might be something there), and Kolt under role player / possible contributor (at best).

Jeffo is still very high ceiling but also low floor. There’s still a chance he’s a 50 goal forward at afl level, but also possible he never makes it. His combination of mobility, leap and skills are rare, just a matter of getting it out of him.

Sestan, any hope there?

I for one love our mix of old and new in the club currently, I don't want to get rid of any of the older guys they will mentor and train up the new guys and that is very important.

Just youth is going to set us back longer if we don't have the right older crew around them as they come up.

16 hours ago, Fritta and Turner said:

Herbert?

A well read literate poster's reference to Xavier Herbert of 'Capricornia' fame. Young Lindsay may turn out to be a true renaissance man painting the odd Chloe.

Edited Wednesday at 01:553 days by Tarax Club

Nice to sign these three youngsters

Edited Thursday at 07:092 days by Heart Beats True

are we sure the media dept got it correct and tim lamb didn't actually sign em all til 2036?

On 20/08/2025 at 10:44, DeeSpencer said:

Jeffo is still very high ceiling but also low floor. There’s still a chance he’s a 50 goal forward at afl level, but also possible he never makes it. His combination of mobility, leap and skills are rare, just a matter of getting it out of him.

Maybe an opportunity under a new coach ??

7 minutes ago, monoccular said:

Maybe an opportunity under a new coach ??

I would hope…if Jeffo and JVR can gel and get bigger and stronger we will be in business

1 hour ago, Demonland said:

All rookies, too!

On 19/08/2025 at 16:10, DeeSpencer said:

I wouldn’t bet my life on Jeffo making it but I’ll gladly buy shares in him at a cheap price. His development from nothing at VFL to now being an excellent player at that level suggests he can step up again. Especially with how raw he was physically. Hopefully this toe injury doesn’t interrupt his summer.

Excellent! That may well be the over statement of this month.

Edited Thursday at 10:261 day by old dee

On 19/08/2025 at 19:36, Fritta and Turner said:

Herbert?

Yeh, Lindsay too. (Herbert is a smokey from Patchewallock U16's)

3 hours ago, Demonland said:

Triple treat trio shot in the arm for supporters. All deservedly so, extended on the rookies list for next year. Great story Jai Culley getting a second chance lifeline after the list cutoff earlier this season. Thanks AFL.

The two territory boys; Ricky Mentha has shown some promise with a dash of x-factor and smarts as a small forward with Casey. An opportunity awaits with Kysaiah going to the centre for a Jeffrey Garlett successor.

Andy Moniz-Wakefield has kept his head up after a shocker knee injury. Reports suggest he has been most diligent with his recovery and is progressing well for a return to on field action 2026. Pleased the club sees his potential and gives him an opportunity to fulfill it.

Finally I'm nominating all three lads for the pencil moustache award this Movember.

Edited Thursday at 11:271 day by Tarax Club