19 hours ago, picket fence said:

No its not.. just pathetic list management! Should NEVER have been selected! DELIST!

Yes Mr President

Just now, redandbluemakepurple said:

Yes Mr President

WELL what are you waiting for... do it!

Tim Lamb.

Edited September 19, 2025Sep 19 by spirit of norm smith
K

Done less than nothing tonight.

If he’s injured, why play him?

25 minutes ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Done less than nothing tonight.

If he’s injured, why play him?

Coming back from injury I think. Maybe to soon and should have not played.

This will be his output at the Dees if he signs with us 100%

Do not sign BM, persevere with what we have, try the blokes we haven't. Anybody else but him.

Yeah he’d probably be the equivalent of Mitch Brown (ex Cat/Don) at this rate.

Save your pennies if he’s going to cost $700K a year.

Would rather Zane Duursma.

He’s playing a blinder tonight 🤣

His mind is already with us, cut him some slack!

Playing through a dislocated toe injury

Be grateful.... unscathed 😉

Feels odd we are after him with a three year deal but are getting rid of May.

Nowhere near it tonight. Pies list management have been streets ahead of us lately. They would have greeter intel than us about his body and how long it can hold up. Let the buyer beware

Do not touch

1 minute ago, Colm said:

Nowhere near it tonight. Pies list management have been streets ahead of us lately. They would have greeter intel than us about his body and how long it can hold up. Let the buyer beware

I mean they do still have a contract offer in front of him

He should not have played this week. Barely trained all week and was surprised they didnt being in McStay

Pass.

Best we close this one down?

14 minutes ago, adonski said:

I mean they do still have a contract offer in front of him

True but only 1 year and we are offering 2 with a third depending. unless things have changed.

1 minute ago, Colm said:

True but only 1 year and we are offering 2 with a third depending. unless things have changed.

I am typically very much for taking a risk when there's no draft picks needing to be spent

I'd take the punt on him for 2 years. The Age article suggested there would be a trigger for a 3rd year, so basically it's up to us at that point whether he goes on.

20 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

He should not have played this week. Barely trained all week and was surprised they didnt being in McStay

McRae blinked.

Ppl not seeing a bigger picture here.

Maybe its mcadam ptsd but after watching tonight i'm very wary of putting 3 years in front of an aging injury prone player who in my estimations is half as good as melksham.

@They played old injured players, Pendleton, Checkers, and Howe, That learning never gets old.