5 minutes ago, Heart Beats True said:

For all the doom and gloom, we are still in this. Massive rocket needed at half time. 

Totally agree, as usual we're competing and defending well and can win this and then the same old thing.

Gotta ask about selection decisions again and our forward set up.

Fritsch seems to have the confidence of a 16 year old boy in a brothel.

Schache did not chase his opponent at one point

We also aren't physical enough. A number of times we didn't put body on opponents to protect their team mates who had possession.

Salem seems to be the only player right now who has consistently clean foot skills.

 

1 minute ago, TheWiz said:

Too many passengers. 2Q thoughts:

- Thank goodness for Windsor

- Oliver looks undercooked

- Gawn doing well

- ANB, Salem and Howes playing well

- Laurie and Schache having a mare

I have given up on Laurie, not sure he'll get too many opportunities this season.

1 minute ago, ElDiablo14 said:

Petraca has to play like Dustin Martin, he isn't at the moment. Too scared to have a crack at goal.

Laurie, not impressed.

JVR needs to do something in the 2nd half.

Disagree. Players are having cracks at goal and missing when they should be handing it off to players in better positions. That's nerves. They all want to be the man to fix our forward line issues, when the way to do it is to hit someone in a good spot with low pressure on them so they can kick it. It's not a hard concept to grasp but in the heat of the moment we all seem to go to pot and spray it.

7 minutes ago, Demon Dynasty said:

My kingdom for a genuine CHF...

2022  2023  &  ?

Is JVR playing as a CHF or a deep forward?   

1 minute ago, Rodney (Balls) Grinter said:

Probably repeating things here, but how the F was Nibblers goal reversed?

Compelling evidence?

A dodgy goal review going the swans way… 

There was no way that was conclusive 

That was excruciating 

Edited March 7, 20242 yr by Roost it far

Gotta be the worst half of footy I’ve ever seen Trac play.

Schace is too meek, can’t see him ever changing.

Looks slippery as hell out there

Disappointed that we debut Billlings as sub, particularly after our media team made a big deal over our three debutants this game. Surely he deserved his spot after the praccies over a couple of others out there.

1 minute ago, ElDiablo14 said:

I have given up on Laurie, not sure he'll get too many opportunities this season.

Yep. Bring Billings on ASAP 

Just now, GCDee said:

A dodgy goal review going the swans way… 

There was no way that was conclusive 

The finger did look to flicker as the ball passed through, not like we deserve much to be honest.

3 minutes ago, Rodney (Balls) Grinter said:

Probably repeating things here, but how the F was Nibblers goal reversed?

Compelling evidence?

It was clearly touched.

Can’t believe we are that bad yet only 7 behind. The SCG is such a horrible ground, so congested. Awful game

My kingdom for Kozzie. We are getting nothing from Laurie, Spargo and Chandler. Fritter is a real worry.

I dont think Fritta could hit the proverbial barn door even if he is locked in th e barn.

Trac needs to do something

Debutants ok

May fantastic

1 minute ago, GCDee said:

A dodgy goal review going the swans way… 

There was no way that was conclusive 

Channel 7 are weak as.  Showed it quickly twice and no apitite to challenge their BS.

Just now, GCDee said:

A dodgy goal review going the swans way… 

There was no way that was conclusive 

JFC I am sick of those finger nail goal reviews from 40 meters! They all go against us. I don’t think the Swans even claimed a touch. 

2 minutes ago, Red But Mostly Blue said:

And for the life of me I didn’t see a single finger on ANB’s goal. Not sure how they made that decision so quickly. 

I’m glad I’m not the only one, sickeningly BT was the only one that actually said “hold on I’m not seeing a finger move there”. All for the decision changing when it’s blatantly clear, but to me there wasn’t absolute evidence of a touch. 

1 minute ago, GCDee said:

A dodgy goal review going the swans way… 

There was no way that was conclusive 

It's so ridiculous. They seem to be being tricked by the lighting changes as the hand and fingers rotate as the ball passes, plus there's the shadow from the ball. A terrible blight on the game to overturn decisions on such inconclusive evidence.

1 minute ago, gs77 said:

Disappointed that we debut Billlings as sub, particularly after our media team made a big deal over our three debutants this game. Surely he deserved his spot after the praccies over a couple of others out there.

Goody should put him on early in the 3rd for Laurie. Why wouldn't you exchange an ammo's level player for a proven silky mid with great skills?

I can’t stand the media orchestrating the AFL’s agenda. Why no replay of the ANB touched goal? It’s a huge call, show it.

Same old problems throughout the first half.

Forward line almost non-existent. Too many long bombs, with Van Rooyen constantly outnumbered and outmarked. Chandler and Spargo totally ineffective.

Laurie managed four fumbles in two minutes.

Fritsch off target with his kicking and dropping marks.

Gawn unable to dominate.

Defence the only bright spot, with Howes looking solid.

If Goody doesn't come up with a plan B, we are cooked for tonight.

1 minute ago, Pates said:

I’m glad I’m not the only one, sickeningly BT was the only one that actually said “hold on I’m not seeing a finger move there”. All for the decision changing when it’s blatantly clear, but to me there wasn’t absolute evidence of a touch. 

Incredible decision, just guess work.

Fritta gets out muscled at every contest. No body strength at all. So frustrating 

The umpires call was a goal and it was over ruled. Wrong!

We've played bad and we're down by 7.