Clayton Oliver leads the Demonland Player of the Year 12  votes clear of Christian Petracca with Brodie Grundy coming in 3rd leading into the Gather Round in Adelaide. Your votes please 6,5,4,3,2,1 for the Round 5 loss to Essendon.

Viney 1

Everyone else 0

2 minutes ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

Viney 1

Everyone else 0

Petty 0.5 for his efforts in the second half

0.5 for Grundy, he tried

-6 Tomlinson

-5 Melksham

AWOL Kozzy, TMac, Sparrow 

Viney 6

Rivers 5

Petracca 4

Oliver 3

JVR 2

Jordon 1

Oliver’s 2nd half, 6

Viney 5

No one else deserves anything. in fact we should deduct previously earned points.

6 . Viney

5. Rivers

4. Gus

3. Petracca

2. Oliver

1. McVee 

6. Langdon

5. Petracca 

4. Oliver. (Second half only)

3. Viney

2. ANB?

1. ?

 

They couldn’t be bothered so why should I.

6, 5 and 4 - no candidates

3 Oliver - strong second half.

2 Viney - non-stop effort all day.

1 McVee - far cooler under pressure than his more experienced colleagues in defence.

6: viney
5: petracca
4: rivers
3: petty
2: oliver
1: mcvee

I choose to award no points this round.

6. C.Oliver

5. C.Petracca

4. J.Viney

3. B.Grundy

2. H.Petty

1. L.Hunter

6. Viney

5. Oliver

4. Trac

3. McVee

2. Hunter

1. Grundy 

Viney

McVee

Oliver

Petracca

Rivers

Langdon

 

Unsubscribe this week  

Probably only Viney deserves any votes.  Oliver after 1/4 time and Petty 3rd quarter.  Many many were very disappointing.  Half hearted effort.  Outcoached and outmuscled.  

6 Viney - turnovers and all

5 Langdon

.

.

4 Rivers

3 Oliver (2nd half)

2 Petracca for trying

Umm

1 Jordon or McVee

 

Viney was dreadful... Back to Viney of old!

Oliver

Viney

Petty

McVee

Two more to come, when I can find them

 

6. C.Oliver

5. C.Petracca

4. J.Viney

3. B.Grundy

2. H.Petty

1. L.Hunter

6 Oliver

5 Viney

4 Petracca

3 McVee

2 Hunter

1 Petty

In a game where no Dees did nearly enough over 4 quarters:

6.  Oliver

5.  Viney

4.  Langdon

3.  McVee

2.  Petracca

1.  Grundy

Hunter and Rivers worked hard, and did a few nice things.

Move on!

Edited April 15, 20232 yr by Deeoldfart
Added last sentence

20 minutes ago, picket fence said:

Viney was dreadful... Back to Viney of old!

Was not.

6. Oliver 

5. Petracca 

4. Viney

3. Hunter

2. McVee 

1. Grundy

 

1 minute ago, chook fowler said:

Was not.

Just a RUGBY Player tonight Chook IMO!

Just now, picket fence said:

Just a RUGBY Player tonight Chook IMO!

At least he looked like he could give a flying [censored] unlike many others.