4 minutes ago, picket fence said:

Garbage List management!

I"m surprised by it. Is only a report which means nothing " in the Hun so means even less" . Both will struggle to play regular games next year. 

1 minute ago, Mr Steve said:

I"m surprised by it. Is only a report which means nothing " in the Hun so means even less" . Both will struggle to play regular games next year. 

agree, so seems little point in re-contracting them, especially Melksham

Fair dinkum, how people could knock the Dees list management the year after winning a flag after a 57 year drought is beyond me. 

 

Hibbo and Melksham can offer a lot for our younger brigade and could play a lot of footy at Casey. I am thinking that JVR, Howes, Chandler, Bedford, Bowey, Woewodin and whoever we bring in via trade and draft will have a big say in wether they get the chance to play many games. We really need to blood all of the above.!!

2 hours ago, Mr Steve said:

Being reported today that both Melksham and Hibberd will get another year. 

If so, it reflects the ongoing ultraconservatism in our selection regimen.

Dynasties are built on continuing renewal

2 hours ago, Mr Steve said:

Being reported today that both Melksham and Hibberd will get another year. 

Very Suprising 

Always feels like we never have players nominating Melbourne as their preferred club for trades.

Last one I think was BBB in 2019.

2 minutes ago, OhMyDees said:

Always feels like we never have players nominating Melbourne as their preferred club for trades.

Last one I think was BBB in 2019.

Langers?

5 minutes ago, OhMyDees said:

Always feels like we never have players nominating Melbourne as their preferred club for trades.

Last one I think was BBB in 2019.

Dunstan

18 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

What is he hearing..?? #ETtheTradeWhisperer.

Sirens? After taking a dump on Dogga's brand new front doorstep?

13 minutes ago, OhMyDees said:

Always feels like we never have players nominating Melbourne as their preferred club for trades.

Last one I think was BBB in 2019.

Lever, May, Langdon, Ben Brown, Dunstan. 4 were vital elements of our premiership team.

45 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

Dunstan

Reminds me of the Life Of Brian skit about the Romans:

Recently, no players ever nominate Melbourne as their preferred destination, because why would they!

What about Langers?

Ok, i'll give you Langers - except for that metrosexual, no player nominated Melbourne as their preferred destination  !

Dunstan?

What? Who? Ok, except for Dunstan and the metrosexual, no player nominated Melbourne!

Lever?

Ok, ok. Except for Dunstan, the metrosexual , and Lever - NO player nominated Melbourne!

May?

Jesus!. Except for Dunstan, the metrosexual , Lever and May - NO player  nominated Melbourne!

Brown?

What? Who? Which one? Ok, except for Dunstan, the metrosexual , Lever, May and Brown x 2 - NO player  nominated Melbourne!

Tomo?

Alright, alright;  except for Dunstan, the metrosexual , Lever, May, Brown x 2 and Tomo - NO player has recently nominated Melbourne as their preferred destination!

56 minutes ago, gs77 said:

Lever, May, Langdon, Ben Brown, Dunstan. 4 were vital elements of our premiership team.

Might be adding Grundy before too long 

While last years trade period was very boring this one is shaping up to be very different. I think we will have to wait until the last day or two before Jackson deal gets done, as I think there will be a massive amount of pick swaps this year that will need to get done before the Jackson deal gets done. 
Think both pick 1&2 will be traded and although we are a chance to pick up one of them it’s far more likely that we will pick up one or more of the picks they are traded for. If that is the case we could be waiting on the likes of the Rankine deal to be completed before pick swaps take place ahead of the Jackson deal. 
I’m hoping that if the Jackson deal is stalling it might help us get get Grundy for less than a first round pick as the pies will need picks to get their deals done. Perhaps picks 32&41 get it done. Or if we trade Bedford whatever pick we get for him might come into the mix. 

35 minutes ago, binman said:

Reminds me of the Life Of Brian skit about the Romans:

Recently, no players ever nominate Melbourne as their preferred destination, because why would they!

What about Langers?

Ok, i'll give you Langers - except for that metrosexual, no player nominated Melbourne as their preferred destination  !

Dunstan?

What? Who? Ok, except for Dunstan and the metrosexual, no player nominated Melbourne!

Lever?

Ok, ok. Except for Dunstan, the metrosexual , and Lever - NO player nominated Melbourne!

May?

Jesus!. Except for Dunstan, the metrosexual , Lever and May - NO player  nominated Melbourne!

Brown?

What? Who? Which one? Ok, except for Dunstan, the metrosexual , Lever, May and Brown x 2 - NO player  nominated Melbourne!

Tomo?

Alright, alright;  except for Dunstan, the metrosexual , Lever, May, Brown x 2 and Tomo - NO player has recently nominated Melbourne as their preferred destination!

Sorry I should clarify my comment to say that it feels like no one wants to nominate for us this trade season. Still well a truely early into trade season so all being well we’ll get a few.

1 minute ago, OhMyDees said:

Sorry I should clarify my comment to say that it feels like no one wants to nominate for us this trade season. Still well a truely early into trade season so all being well we’ll get a few.

I was only joking, but I agree it would be great for a really good player to come our and say I want to go to the dees.

I wonder when really good players nominate a club it is code for, the club offering them a boat load of money (even though technically they can't do so whilst still contracted to another club). 

For average players, it is code for, I'm not good enough to get a regular senior game at my club becauseim not tbat good.

 

6 minutes ago, OhMyDees said:

Sorry I should clarify my comment to say that it feels like no one wants to nominate for us this trade season. Still well a truely early into trade season so all being well we’ll get a few.

Probably because we don't have a lot of money to throw around and because it is very difficult to get a game let alone be part of the regular 22.

23 minutes ago, OhMyDees said:

Sorry I should clarify my comment to say that it feels like no one wants to nominate for us this trade season. Still well a truely early into trade season so all being well we’ll get a few.

 

reading between the lines it looks like this guy might 

What has he heard? Ney, not the thud of a terd.. more of a whisper, certainly crisper.. #WatchThisSpace #HowDoesHeDoIt? #ETtheTradeWhisperer

Edited September 14, 20223 yr by Ethan Tremblay
[censored] is censored?

1 hour ago, Sydee said:

 

reading between the lines it looks like this guy might 

Let’s hope so Sydee 👍🏻

Or not. 

5 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

What has he heard? Ney, not the thud of a terd.. more of a whisper, certainly crisper.. #WatchThisSpace #HowDoesHeDoIt? #ETtheTradeWhisperer

Heard and terd rhyme with James Hird... and he just nominated to coach Essenden again! great call ET! #howdoeshedoit? 

Edited September 14, 20223 yr by Caligula's cohort

Hibberd deserves an additional year

Melksham one has stumped me though 

Edited September 14, 20223 yr by adonski

Let's go Hirdy 

Need to see Chandler in the seniors.

Very good balance between attack and defence 

In his game. I would have him in rather than melksham