Trade and Free Agency rumours

[DeeSpencer 25,444]

11 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Cats get Ollie Henry.

For pick 25 I'd be asking Ollie if he wants to sign back up for Collingwood or try his luck at North.

[layzie 33,748]

3 hours ago, Roost it far said:

I was in the pocket next to the point post with my brother and watched Wrensted run into an open goal only to miss, Sheesh I enjoyed 87 and 88 a lot. Heartbreak and all!

 

So many heart in mouth moments in such a short time period! 

[The Swimming Dee 1,904]

I can't remember but does anyone know if trading (or lack thereof) is allowed to continue over the weekend?

[daisycutter 29,604]

5 minutes ago, The Swimming Dee said:

I can't remember but does anyone know if trading (or lack thereof) is allowed to continue over the weekend?

sure they can. but only the afl can ratify it on monday

[adonski 11,783]

Lachie Hunter driving Josh Bruce to Gosch's!

[SFebes 4,884]

I think you all should go have a beer 🤣

[layzie 33,748]

1 minute ago, SFebes said:

I think you all should go have a beer 🤣

Finally some sense!

[Tarax Club 3,884]

4 hours ago, Wells 11 said:

think he meant 88 

Cheers!

Wells 11 88 it was.

TC
 

 

[old55 23,369]

Not sure what our overall strategy is.

Tim Lamb said we're only taking two ND picks which currently makes sense with 4 out (Jackson, Bedford, Rosman, Hunt) and 2 in (Grundy and Chandler upgrade).

But we only have one useful ND pick at 27 - 54 is not a useful draft pick because we traded out earlier ones on the basis we won't use them.  27 is surely earmarked for the Grundy trade somehow.

So we're short 2 2022 ND picks.  The Jackson trade is currently only going to produce 13 and (hopefully) some future picks.  Not sure where the other 2022 ND pick is coming from?

We'd either need to get two from Freo - 13 and one via a Lobb trade with the Dogs, or trade a F1st for a 2022 pick.  The other moving part is the Bedford pick, maybe we can trade a F1st to GWS for Bedford and a 2022 1st?

A lot to play out ...

[Tarax Club 3,884]

19 minutes ago, adonski said:

Lachie Hunter driving Josh Bruce to Gosch's!

Josh may be better off on the #70 tram!
 

 

Edited October 7, 2022 by Tarax Club

[deelusions from afar 1,776]

3 minutes ago, old55 said:

Not sure what our overall strategy is.

Tim Lamb said we're only taking two ND picks which currently makes sense with 4 out (Jackson, Bedford, Rosman, Hunt) and 2 in (Grundy and Chandler upgrade).

But we only have one useful ND pick at 27 - 54 is not a useful draft pick because we traded out earlier ones on the basis we won't use them.  27 is surely earmarked for the Grundy trade somehow.

So we're short 2 2022 ND picks.  The Jackson trade is currently only going to produce 13 and (hopefully) some future picks.  Not sure where the other 2022 ND pick is coming from?

We'd either need to get two from Freo - 13 and one via a Lobb trade with the Dogs, or trade a F1st for a 2022 pick.  The other moving part is the Bedford pick, maybe we can trade a F1st to GWS for Bedford and a 2022 1st?

A lot to play out ...

I'm pretty sure we will use our first round pick from next year (or a future first from Freo or both) to get another high pick.  Regardless of the quality of the draft I think we back our system to find the best players and then get a year of development into them.
 

[DeeSpencer 25,444]

30 minutes ago, old55 said:

The other moving part is the Bedford pick, maybe we can trade a F1st to GWS for Bedford and a 2022 1st?

That’s a good idea. GWS have too many early picks this year and would surely be better off backing some out until next year.

Could even get Geelong’s 2nd thrown in with 18 for Bedford and a future first.

 

[spirit of norm smith 16,267]

 

Dees supporters waiting for some trade news 

[Gawndy the Great 9,011]

I am starting to think the Lobb trade is holding it up.

13,30, F1, F2 (NMFC) gets it done for sure.

it’s a minimum 3500 points and could be up to 4000ish point wise.

We could then take 13, NMFC f2 , 30 to WCE for Pick 2 and end up with either Cadman or Warlord. We then have 2 picks inside 1st round next year and could again get into the top 10. 

 

[Nascent 9,104]

32 minutes ago, CYB said:

I am starting to think the Lobb trade is holding it up.

13,30, F1, F2 (NMFC) gets it done for sure.

it’s a minimum 3500 points and could be up to 4000ish point wise.

We could then take 13, NMFC f2 , 30 to WCE for Pick 2 and end up with either Cadman or Warlord. We then have 2 picks inside 1st round next year and could again get into the top 10. 

 

We're not getting all that unfortunately.

Absolute best we can hope for is 2 x first rounders and a 2nd (north or freo) with us giving back a future 2nd and 3rd.

[Lucifers Hero 39,556]

4 hours ago, Demonland said:

 

Can't see how they get JHF without WCE pick 2 involved.

For them to expect to get him and Junior Rioli for pick 8 and a F1 is a joke I would have thought they are ok for pick 2 but not with Rioli  included.

They need to put up something/someone else

4 hours ago, Demonland said:

 

I don't blame them.  They owe Rioli nothing.

If they are giving him away for free in the Port trade of pick 8 and a F1 for Rioli and Pick 2 then let him go to the psd.  They will have lost nothing.

It is one time where the losing club doesn't miss out on anything.

[DubDee 25,590]

Is there still any chance of Whitfield being traded?  I wonder if we would use one of the LJ picks to get him?  not sure of his value in picks

[SA Red n Blue 48]

6 hours ago, Left Foot Snap said:

This Bowes trade really annoys me. This one isn't just a case of a local boy wanting to go home and taking unders to go to a media darling 'well run club'. This is a player that comes with a salary dump and is going to the one club that should not be able to afford it given its recent big signings and other players being brought in this year. Something stinks and eventually someone will talk. There is no way in my mind they are not cheating the salary cap and I've thought this for a number of years, but if they of all clubs can absorb the salary dump then something is rotten in Denmark!! How there is not more media questioning and scrutiny is beyond me.

To be fair they’re a smart club. Easy to do & if you get caught it proves how dumb you are & how poorly run the club is. No way anyone can prove cash in the hand, gifts etc from wealthy members, sponsors or supporters. It’s rife in the NRL to the point of sponsors donating units/houses or taking a loss on a sale of a property to players & nothing illegal about that. The house may cost say $800k to build & they will sell it for a mill to general public but do a sale for $600k to a player. They haven’t paid the player any more, but the player has cashed in on another property & got an increase on assets. Same as clubs giving players vehicles & saying they are got their use whenever they want. Player gets a car with no expenses so not getting paid any more, but receiving a benefit by reducing costs. It happens in all sports. 

[Wilson7 2,648]

1 hour ago, DubDee said:

Is there still any chance of Whitfield being traded?  I wonder if we would use one of the LJ picks to get him?  not sure of his value in picks

No chance we could fit Whitfields wage in the salary cap

[Sir Why You Little 36,963]

10 hours ago, Tarax Club said:

Alan Johnson’s performance in the ‘87 Elimination Final against the Eagles. In their very first final and our first final since ‘64 was described by coach John Northey as “Magnificent”. Justifiably so.
 

For those DL’s of a certain vintage most certainly an unforgettable almost legendary time with some great individual and team performances. Despite being derided as ‘ordinary’ and participating in that season’s final series by ‘default’.

1988

[BenJamin on Deesy St 805]

4 hours ago, CYB said:

We could then take 13, NMFC f2 , 30 to WCE for Pick 2 and end up with either Cadman or Warlord. We then have 2 picks inside 1st round next year and could again get into the top 10.

We would be unstoppable with Demon Warlord.

[John Demonic 5,747]

5 hours ago, CYB said:

I am starting to think the Lobb trade is holding it up.

13,30, F1, F2 (NMFC) gets it done for sure.

it’s a minimum 3500 points and could be up to 4000ish point wise.

We could then take 13, NMFC f2 , 30 to WCE for Pick 2 and end up with either Cadman or Warlord. We then have 2 picks inside 1st round next year and could again get into the top 10. 

 

If I'm WCE I'm asking for 13, Freo or Melb f1 and NM F2. With a potential future 3rd coming back to us. And even then that deal is too weighted to the future, i'd ask the Dees to trade a F1 to get a pick 8-12 this year 

There's just no incentive otherwise.

 

Edited October 7, 2022 by John Demonic

[Gawndy the Great 9,011]

2 hours ago, Ben E said:

We would be unstoppable with Demon Warlord.

I have dibs on the handle if we recruit him 😂

[YesitwasaWin4theAges 6,684]

12 hours ago, Left Foot Snap said:

This Bowes trade really annoys me. This one isn't just a case of a local boy wanting to go home and taking unders to go to a media darling 'well run club'. This is a player that comes with a salary dump and is going to the one club that should not be able to afford it given its recent big signings and other players being brought in this year. Something stinks and eventually someone will talk. There is no way in my mind they are not cheating the salary cap and I've thought this for a number of years, but if they of all clubs can absorb the salary dump then something is rotten in Denmark!! How there is not more media questioning and scrutiny is beyond me.

Wouldn't it be beautiful if someone started stitching on the whole operation down the Highway?

[spirit of norm smith 16,267]

ESPN FOOTY VIEW

Melbourne

List needs:

• Classy midfielder/forward who can pass precisely to inside 50m targets

• Ruck depth

• Outside run and speed

Who should they target?

The major missing link for Melbourne is a classy midfielder/forward who can hit inside 50 targets reliably. 2021 Sandover Medallist, Bailey Rogerswould fill the role perfectly with his versatility to play midfield and forward and his classy skills, strong marking and ball winning capabilities a bonus. With Carlton midfielder Will Setterfield in and out of Carlton's best-22, he may be someone Melbourne could make enquiries into as a further classy midfielder who could add improved balance to the Demons midfield.

While Brodie Grundy has been heavily rumoured to be joining Melbourne, the Demons should be demanding Rory Lobb as part of any deal for Luke Jackson. While Lobb has requested a trade to Western Bulldogs, Melbourne arguably need Lobb more, not just as a ruck, but as a contested marking force close to goal and someone who does not relegate Gawn to spending most of his time forward. What makes the Lobb fit so ideal is that he is ideally suited to a relieving ruck role behind Gawn and gives the Demons the option if Gawn misses games at some point to take over as Melbourne's lead ruck.

While Bradley Hill has been linked to North Melbourne, the wide-open expanses of the MCG would suit Hill much better as it did during his tenure with Hawthorn. With Melbourne a team featuring prolific ball winners, Hill for the Demons would need to do nothing more than just be himself which makes Melbourne his ideal landing spot.