We Won

[WERRIDEE 5,459]

The Salem Kelly trade that is. Salem is a much better player than Kelly. FACT.

[spirit of norm smith 16,340]

Great to see Salem, Kelly and Hunt having a chat after the game. Agree the deal is probably a break even though Kelly is the type of classy midfielder we need to compliment our midfield bulls. 

[BDA 22,735]

55 minutes ago, WERRIDEE said:

The Salem Kelly trade that is. Salem is a much better player than Kelly. FACT.

Salem is a very important player for us. A very reliable kick. I hope he re-signs again soon.

Kelly has been in the doldrums but when playing at his best is A-Grade.

I've no qualms about the trade and perfectly happy with Salem but i reckon Kelly is the better player.

[McQueen 17,864]

I thought we had the second coming of Chris Judd after Tyson played his first year. 
Upon reflection it was a pure indication of just how bog ordinary the list was. 
 

I wouldn’t be as quick to say we won that trade but maybe we’re starting to see the return on a long term investment. 

[praha 11,238]

2 minutes ago, McQueen said:

I thought we had the second coming of Chris Judd after Tyson played his first year. 
Upon reflection it was a pure indication of just how bog ordinary the list was. 
 

I wouldn’t be as quick to say we won that trade but maybe we’re starting to see the return on a long term investment. 

tyson looked destined for stardom after his first year at melbourne.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Tyson looked like the next Pendlebury with time and space in tight but it turned out he was just slow.

Havjng said that, he played a crucial role for us when needed.

Kelly and Salem are very different but would be very happy with either.

[dazzledavey36 54,452]

Kelly's drop in form has been in the past 3 years shows he's the cream on the top when you've got a good mix in the midfield. He's had to play more inside then outside and it hasn't suited his strengths.

In saying that, I would have him in a heart beat.

[DeeSpencer 25,531]

Both teams lost because they gave up the chance at Bont!

But really I liked the move of 2 down to 9, we needed a more mature player to help immediately and we had to stop putting all our faith in 1 early pick.

I always thought we gave up way too much adding pick 20 for only a late 40’s pick in return.

For 2 we should’ve got 9 and Tyson out right. 
 

As for Kelly - he’d kill it playing for us on ball and on the wing. Maybe we’ll grab him if he can give up on his 8 year 8 million extension!

[Pickett2Jackson 3,904]

 Kelly has kicked more behinds than goals in his career.  Hes a certainty to sign with us at the end of season.

 

[Bang Bang Bang 5,807]

I can understand the interest in this trade given the media love to hound us over it.

But a little known fact - we were never taking Kelly. After Boyd there was no consensus #2 pick that year. GWS were keen on Kelly but a lot of names were in the mix. Our man was most likely Jack Billings, who had trained with us in earlier in 2013 and ended up going at 3 to the Saints. 

I'm not sure if this can be easily found on the internet but I'm almost certain somebody at the club confirmed this around 2015-2016. 

With that in mind, Salem is a better player than Billings on his own. Tyson gave good service early on and then helped us get us Preuss who in turn helped us get Ben Brown. Jayden Hunt has had a serviceable career to date. GWS would be very happy with Kelly's output too. Both clubs benefitted from the trade. 

In hindsight, probably keep the pick and draft Bontempelli, but the trade certainly wasn't as binary as the clickbait Herald Sun journos would have you believe. 

[Little Goffy 14,494]

The trade was a wise on based on what was known and the risks and needs involved at the time.

Salem has steadily developed into what looks to now be a first rate player.  Dyson had a burst there where he looked like he was going to be outstanding, but for unknown reasons that faded away.

Right trade at the time, and the eventual results have turned out okay.

Might be time to put this one to bed.

[titan_uranus 24,983]

I don't care.

I like Salem. He's playing really well. That's all I care about.

[Flag 2021 143]

Kelly is great but we don't need him.

On the other hand I am an out and out Christian Salem fan. He'd be very hard to replace.

 

[david_neitz_is_my_dad 4,083]

Kelly and Green will be wanting out

[Redlagged 806]

Salem's a class player. Underrated. So why bother continuing this debate? Naturally we'd like Kelly as well. Kelly and Langdon on the wings!

[NowWeKnow 130]

https://www.triplem.com.au/story/paul-roos-revisits-the-josh-kelly-trade-37923

[Ham 741]

Would much rather Salem over Kelly.

[ChaserJ 5,074]

1 hour ago, david_neitz_is_my_dad said:

Kelly and Green will be wanting out

Possibly Lachie Ash as well.

[Pates 9,660]

1 hour ago, NowWeKnow said:

https://www.triplem.com.au/story/paul-roos-revisits-the-josh-kelly-trade-37923

That article nails every aspect of the trade. We needed a ready to go player to help Jones in the middle, GWS wanted to add another top draft pick to their line up. We also highly rated Salem anyway so we’re rapt to get him when we did. 

The footy media need sink the boots into clubs on something so they create this drama. I’m pretty sure the club moved on very quickly. 

[YesitwasaWin4theAges 6,691]

Clearly won that trade hands down, Salem is Mr.Dependable off half back with his distribution and decision making abilities.

While Hunty is a massive breath of fresh air in his more favoured role flying off half back. 

As for Dommy well he netted us Preussy and we on traded Pruessy for pick 31 which was part of the trade for Big Ben.

Massive win.

 

[YesitwasaWin4theAges 6,691]

1 hour ago, ChaserJ said:

Possibly Lachie Ash as well.

They are a finished product BWS.