Why not at the right price, we are in need of a fwd/mid that is quick and applies elite pressure, something we need more of.

I would be feeding right off of the dead carcass that is Essendrug.

Edited October 9, 20205 yr by Win4theAges

Can't see Dodo letting 4 best 22 players out the gate, or maybe their problems really are that bad. Regardless, could be a decent get as a more outside positioned mid that we've been after. Still reckon a decent forward would be the priority before someone like Smith

Mercenaries jumping ship. 
 

Would have been a more than handy forward but doesn't appear to have come back the same player after major injury.

Lost a yard?

Would need a thorough medical...

Good player, but doesn't really address any of our main needs (key forward, wingman, small defender/HBF), so it's a pass from me.

A mere shadow of what he was. 

His numbers looked ok in 2020.  Has some appeal but not a heap. 28 next year and contracted.  They wont do a deal easily and he would be on a decent salary. Wasting our time to get involved I think.

Yuk

Very good at his best, but his type not at the top of our priority list.

much as there's been minimal interest in t mac since he signed a decent deal and copped a few serious injuries, much the same would probably be true of smith

he's definitely not the player he was several years ago

1 hour ago, Pulp Fritschon said:

His numbers looked ok in 2020.  Has some appeal but not a heap. 28 next year and contracted.  They wont do a deal easily and he would be on a decent salary. Wasting our time to get involved I think.

Yeah, I'd love him in our forward half but tend to agree with your summary of the situation.

I'd take Tippa but not Smith.

3 hours ago, MadAsHell said:

Good player, but doesn't really address any of our main needs (key forward, wingman, small defender/HBF), so it's a pass from me.

A skilled pressure mid/forward is probably as big a need as any of those other positions. We lose a lot of games because we don't have midfield rotations to keep the work rate high, we don't have guys to take the handball receives from Oliver and co and we don't have anyone who can kick inside 50. We need the yin to Petracca's yang.

It doesn't stand out as a need because we've never used someone in that role, but to me it's a clear need and why we got Bennell.

 

no because I think he would cost to much in terms of $$$$$ and compensation in picks/players. He’s ok but not the fast wingman type we should use our $ to be chasing. 

Edited October 10, 20205 yr by spirit of norm smith
Y

Good pressure fwd, doesn’t kick many but knows how to lay a tackle (something we are  sorely lacking) and had off an assist, 

Get TIPPA now DEES

On 10/10/2020 at 9:09 PM, spirit of norm smith said:

 

no because I think he would cost to much in terms of $$$$$ and compensation in picks/players. He’s ok but not the fast wingman type we should use our $ to be chasing. 

Do u have a player in mind? Jack?

Edited October 11, 20205 yr by Paulo
updated

7 hours ago, Paulo said:

Do u have a player in mind? Jack?

I’m looking at Tom Phillips as the most likely gettable option.

Age 24. Experienced.  90 games.  44 goals.
Left foot wing. Fits straight in. 
Reasonable price in $ and trade. Offer 3 years which Pies wouldn’t.  
Offer our future 2021 2nd round pick. 

5 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

I’m looking at Tom Phillips as the most likely gettable option.

Age 24. Experienced.  90 games.  44 goals.
Left foot wing. Fits straight in. 
Reasonable price in $ and trade. Offer 3 years which Pies wouldn’t.  
Offer our future 2021 2nd round pick. 

Okay, but curious as to why, considering the compromised nature of this year's draft, you'd offer next year's pick instead of this year's?

3 minutes ago, TRIGON said:

Okay, but curious as to why, considering the compromised nature of this year's draft, you'd offer next year's pick instead of this year's?

Optimism.
 

Get Phillips for 12 months before having to pay 2021 compo.

And because our future 2nd 2021 pick will be in the 30s as we rise up the ladder ?

On the optimistic side, you'd hope that next year's pick was somewhere between 30 and 36 ?.

Going with the 'Sunshine & Lollypops' scenario, the next questions to ask are:

1. What does next year's draft crop look like compared to this year's?
2. Where will our current 2nd round pick slide to in this year's compromised draft?

Edited October 11, 20205 yr by TRIGON