GAMEDAY: Rd 14 vs St. Kilda

[Freddy Fuschia 729]

Melbourne doesn’t do 8 point games very well but it will have to if it wants to remain a contender.

Simple as that.

[Deesprate 1,323]

The Saints had a pretty tough game last week whereas we played bruise free football against Dogs. With a week rest there is simply no excuse to drop this one. However the fact are a quarter of our team has been turned over plus other than a depleted Pies outfit we have beaten no one above us. Lose this and another season wasted win it and redemption is possible. I think where a 40/60 proposition. A loss confirm we are a 10/14 team a win put us in the 5-8 bracket. Big game for club and Goody. This site will meltdown if we lose. 

[ding 5,126]

The Dogs showed how we struggle against genuine legspeed, and our team today is even slower than last week.

Our ins are genuinely eyebrow-raising. 

Im confounded as to the thinking behind selection and I think we'll get pumped tbh. 

[—coach— 3,496]

Like many I’m perplexed by the selections this week, but like a car crash I can’t look away.

Hoping for a win, fully expecting to loose, if we do loose then I hope that some good comes out of it and we make the hard decisions that’s need making. 

[Grouse 191]

8 minutes ago, ding said:

The Dogs showed how we struggle against genuine legspeed, and our team today is even slower than last week.

Our ins are genuinely eyebrow-raising. 

Im confounded as to the thinking behind selection and I think we'll get pumped tbh. 

The thing that concerns me with this selection is that we have very few injuries and yet it seems like we don't have any quality  depth. We don't have speed, and apart from our ruck stocks, it seems like we have a list clogged with players that can't quite make it in out best 22. Really hoping the boys have come to play but the doubts remain. 

[Cards13 9,117]

I had a great time last week, had my first zoom game watch with the lads and had a really good laugh and great catch up. The game was virtually irrelevant and that’s how I feel this week unfortunately.

[praha 11,124]

Can't see us getting close. Gobsmacked by the ins. They will absolutely run us off the park. Hoping for a wet game, no idea what the weather is like but that's our only hope to slow them down. Otherwise I can see another 5-6 goal loss. Saints will need a bit of pace and spread for 10-15 minutes to build a lead and that's game over.

[Deesprate 1,323]

4 minutes ago, praha said:

Can't see us getting close. Gobsmacked by the ins. They will absolutely run us off the park. Hoping for a wet game, no idea what the weather is like but that's our only hope to slow them down. Otherwise I can see another 5-6 goal loss. Saints will need a bit of pace and spread for 10-15 minutes to build a lead and that's game over.

Geez if where relying on rain in Alice where in trouble. Last time the Todd river ran in August was 1848

[doc roet 1,279]

A prime time free to air game for Goodwin to show off and display all of his extraordinary visionary flexible coaching talents for all to see.- not.

 

[Ethan Tremblay 30,030]

I actually have a good feeling about this game. Saints by 64. 

[leave it to deever 17,461]

Well the cats have created an opportunity for us to play finals this year.

 

Lets see if the lads take it.

Edited August 28, 2020 by leave it to deever

[doc roet 1,279]

8 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

I actually have a good feeling about this game. Saints by 64. 

A 100 pt drubbing should do the trick. 

[Bitter but optimistic 22,065]

As we all know ....... lose this and that's 2020 done and dusted................ yet another wasted year.

I am neither enthused nor encouraged by team selection but that's who is going to represent the Red and Blue today so like others, I will be barracking with my usual well lubricated gusto.

I will enjoy humble pie if we beat the Aints.

[MarkMacca 133]

1 hour ago, Deesprate said:

The Saints had a pretty tough game last week whereas we played bruise free football against Dogs. With a week rest there is simply no excuse to drop this one. However the fact are a quarter of our team has been turned over plus other than a depleted Pies outfit we have beaten no one above us. Lose this and another season wasted win it and redemption is possible. I think where a 40/60 proposition. A loss confirm we are a 10/14 team a win put us in the 5-8 bracket. Big game for club and Goody. This site will meltdown if we lose. 

And a draw puts us as 9? ...

[doc roet 1,279]

A couple of plagons and a good plogging of your maid and you'll feel better in the morning if we lose bbo, or does that normally happen if we win?

[Stevienic23 1,183]

Dare I say our plan might be to negate their speed by playing keepings off ala Geelong style? Hopefully we aren't going to take them on head to head in speed and outside run. Rivers, Wagner & Mcdonald are all relatively reliable kicks (within their limitations) - as well as having Salem & May back there so perhaps we'll try and use short sharp ball movement. 

Obviously the fear of this is going to be the inevitable turnovers which will kill us. 

[Bitter but optimistic 22,065]

5 minutes ago, doc roet said:

A couple of plagons and a good plogging of your maid and you'll feel better in the morning if we lose bbo, or does that normally happen if we win?

I am a creature of habit Doc.

[McQueen 17,864]

Our best can beat anyone in the competition. 
 

Yeah-nah. 
 

Season shot today folks. 

[praha 11,124]

1 hour ago, Deesprate said:

Geez if where relying on rain in Alice where in trouble. Last time the Todd river ran in August was 1848

completely forgot it was in Alice lol

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,285]

All comes down to workrate of our mids and small forwards.

I'm confident with our backline getting the job done but if there is no pressure up the ground with their I50s it will be more of last week.

If we lose the game in the same fashion where the doggies waltzed out of their D50 to goal without pressure,  Goody can start thinking about an early payout at years end. 

[Delusional demon 82 1,197]

I expect to be going ‘insane in the tim membrane ‘ tonight with OMac coughing up 4 majors after being caught 5 meters off his opponent on the lead , as usual Saints pressure and outside run will put our defence under enormous pressure tonight . 

and conversely our forwards will add little pressure on the other end , I hope some of them watched the cats v dogs last night , I don’t think we’ve ever been capable of that sort of pressure (except in those two finals at the G in 2018)
 

 

[Demon Dynasty 17,094]

1 hour ago, —coach— said:

Like many I’m perplexed by the selections this week, but like a car crash I can’t look away.

Hoping for a win, fully expecting to loose, if we do loose then I hope that some good comes out of it and we make the hard decisions that’s need making. 

Bit of a cryptic message there coach?

[The Chazz 4,077]

There's just no way that I can see us winning this game.

We have liabilities in Jones, Wagner. An underdone Gawn. We have hit and miss players in Spargo, AvB, Hannan and Melksham.

That's almost a third of the side with serious question marks on them before we even start.

Then I look at going in with no genuine small defender, against a team that has a small forward 4th on the league goal kicking ladder.

So many factors that point to a heavy loss.

Dees by 11 points.

Edited August 28, 2020 by The Chazz

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,640]

Will be interesting to see what big Maxy comming back into the side can bring.  I think he will need to put in one of his gut busting inspirational captain's efforts to help get us over the line, but I wouldn't put that past him.

I'm not as cut up about the selections as some are here.  If anything, I think the inclusions will add some much needed despiration and effort to the team.  Rivers should be better than Harmes, Wagner on a par with Sparrow, Max is a big upgrade on Pruess and Brown should give us as much as T Mac, but a bit more mobility.  Whilst I rate Fritsch, he was burning a lot of opportunities in our forward line and wouldn't surprise me to see Hannan have a day out in his absence as I think Fritsch was somewhat robbing Hannan of being a second lead up target which I think Hannan can also do fairly well.

Also feel like we need a big game from all our mids to win it at the source and go on with it from there.  Patracca has had a pretty quite month or so and I think it's about time he smashes a game open.

I certainly think we can get the job done, but I'm not particularly confident in it though.

[Deeoldfart 7,996]

In my 'glass half full' way, I'm clinging to the hope that our relatively good history at Traeger Park will get us over the line.  The glass is developing a small crack.