Injury List 2020

[whatwhat say what 22,713]

Is this actually longer than this time last year?!??

[Earl Hood 6,082]

3 minutes ago, whatwhatsaywhat said:

Is this actually longer than this time last year?!??

The injuries may not be as bad as last year but [censored] we are back to our seasonal norm of 15 or 16. Can we just get a break from this stuff ever? It does make a difference over a season. Richmond has a couple of flags achieved in seasons when they had no more than 2 injuries at any time for a whole season! Imagine that. The Hawks were similar thru much of their three flags and Geelong before that. You need some luck with injuries but it alludes us year on year. 

[binman 42,740]

The critical thing is most of the injured players got a sold block of training in before XMAS and have s old fitness base down.

Also most of that list is still running so keeping their fitness levels up. 

[CHF 2,720]

18 minutes ago, binman said:

The critical thing is most of the injured players got a sold block of training in before XMAS and have s old fitness base down.

Also most of that list is still running so keeping their fitness levels up. 

Binman, I agree with you. The pre-Christmas hard, consistent training was something that we lacked during the last pre-season. We are in a much better position than this time last year.

Of the players nominally on the injured list, from media reports and our own training reporters, I am of the opinion that the following will be fit and available for Round 1.

               Max Gawn

               Michael Hibberd

               Stephen May

Jake Melksham

The following I believe are possible for Round 1 but not as definite as to above.

Angus Brayshaw – Elbow… a difficult one to know the timeline for recovery as it is an unusual injury.

Mitch Hannan – from the sounds of things, he is likely to be back with the main group very soon. Round 1 availability will depend on match fitness.

Kade Chandler – Wrist.. Round 1 availability will depend on Match fitness/ preseason gametime.

Joel Smith - ? not up to date on this injury. From reports he has trained well so far this preseason.

Aaron vandeBerg – foot? I believe that this is not a serious injury and that he will be back to training in the near future.

Harrison Petty - ? No idea

 

The rest will not have a hope of making Round 1.

 

I am a glass half full kind a guy.

[Pates 9,660]

1 hour ago, Earl Hood said:

The injuries may not be as bad as last year but [censored] we are back to our seasonal norm of 15 or 16. Can we just get a break from this stuff ever? It does make a difference over a season. Richmond has a couple of flags achieved in seasons when they had no more than 2 injuries at any time for a whole season! Imagine that. The Hawks were similar thru much of their three flags and Geelong before that. You need some luck with injuries but it alludes us year on year. 

I have always said that luck is the intangible ingredient that almost every premiership team has had over the journey, and it's something that we have never had happen to us when we've been in with a shot.

I really hope that when theses guys get back out on the park their fitness base they have created over the summer will stand them in good stead. 

[spirit of norm smith 16,338]

There’s 8 blokes already very doubtful imo for round 1.  Wow. And not even up to preseason matches. 
 

Gawn is crucial!!

[Demonland 71,653]

Updated injury list based on training reports including suspected minor ankle roll to TMac.

 

	PLAYER	INJURY	LENGTH
	Angus Brayshaw	Elbow	TBA
	Kade Chandler	Wrist	TBA
	Kyle Dunkley	Ankle	TBA
	Max Gawn	Knee	TBA
	Mitch Hannan	????	TBA
	Steven May	Knee	TBA
	Tom McDonald	Ankle	TBA
	Harrison Petty	Groin	TBA
	Joel Smith	Foot	TBA
	Aaron vandenBerg	Foot	TBA
	Corey Wagner	Knee	TBA
	Braydon Preuss	Knee	8-10 Weeks
	Harley Bennell	Calf	Indefinite
	Kade Kolodjashnij	Head	Indefinite
	Aaron Nietschke	Knee	Season

 

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

5 minutes ago, Demonland said:

Updated injury list based on training reports including suspected minor ankle roll to TMac.

 

	PLAYER	INJURY	LENGTH
	Angus Brayshaw	Elbow	TBA
	Kade Chandler	Wrist	TBA
	Kyle Dunkley	Ankle	TBA
	Max Gawn	Knee	TBA
	Mitch Hannan	????	TBA
	Steven May	Knee	TBA
	Tom McDonald	Ankle	TBA
	Harrison Petty	Groin	TBA
	Joel Smith	Foot	TBA
	Aaron vandenBerg	Foot	TBA
	Corey Wagner	Knee	TBA
	Braydon Preuss	Knee	8-10 Weeks
	Harley Bennell	Calf	Indefinite
	Kade Kolodjashnij	Head	Indefinite
	Aaron Nietschke	Knee	Season

 

Important injured players from this list:

• Brayshaw
• Gawn
• May
• McDonald
• Smith
• vandenBerg
• Preuss

Not a great start.

[binman 42,740]

2 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

Important injured players from this list:

• Brayshaw
• Gawn
• May
• McDonald
• Smith
• vandenBerg
• Preuss

Not a great start.

Of that list though only preuss is confirmed being out for any length of time and all of them have got a very strong fitness base down.

So not that a big an issue really.

[Caligula's cohort 1,014]

15 minutes ago, Demonland said:

Updated injury list based on training reports including suspected minor ankle roll to TMac.

 

	PLAYER	INJURY	LENGTH
	Angus Brayshaw	Elbow	TBA
	Kade Chandler	Wrist	TBA
	Kyle Dunkley	Ankle	TBA
	Max Gawn	Knee	TBA
	Mitch Hannan	????	TBA
	Steven May	Knee	TBA
	Tom McDonald	Ankle	TBA
	Harrison Petty	Groin	TBA
	Joel Smith	Foot	TBA
	Aaron vandenBerg	Foot	TBA
	Corey Wagner	Knee	TBA
	Braydon Preuss	Knee	8-10 Weeks
	Harley Bennell	Calf	Indefinite
	Kade Kolodjashnij	Head	Indefinite
	Aaron Nietschke	Knee	Season

 

Replace T.mac for Spargo

[binman 42,740]

Just now, Caligula's cohort said:

Replace T.mac for Spargo

Spargo was in full training today apparently

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,790]

15 hours ago, CHF said:

Angus Brayshaw – Elbow… a difficult one to know the timeline for recovery as it is an unusual injury.

 

There was a report somewhere that his arm guard has been removed and he might ramp things up next week.

Hopefully he'll be ready for Marsh 2 V's Hawthorn along with Gawn and May.

[Demonland 71,653]

29 minutes ago, Caligula's cohort said:

Replace T.mac for Spargo

I took Hibberd, Melksham and Spargo off the list after the training report and added Corey Wagner (Iced Knee) and Tom McDonald (rolled ankle - hopefully minor).

[Lord Nev 13,512]

Another addition:

G.Pert (Shoulder)

Currently on light duties after a fishing injury.

Classic Melbourne to take it too far.

[chookrat 4,247]

6 hours ago, Demonland said:

Updated injury list based on training reports including suspected minor ankle roll to TMac.

 

	PLAYER	INJURY	LENGTH
	Angus Brayshaw	Elbow	TBA
	Kade Chandler	Wrist	TBA
	Kyle Dunkley	Ankle	TBA
	Max Gawn	Knee	TBA
	Mitch Hannan	????	TBA
	Steven May	Knee	TBA
	Tom McDonald	Ankle	TBA
	Harrison Petty	Groin	TBA
	Joel Smith	Foot	TBA
	Aaron vandenBerg	Foot	TBA
	Corey Wagner	Knee	TBA
	Braydon Preuss	Knee	8-10 Weeks
	Harley Bennell	Calf	Indefinite
	Kade Kolodjashnij	Head	Indefinite
	Aaron Nietschke	Knee	Season

 

You can add Gary Pert to the list with a shoulder. The CEO needs to be smarter and not engage in such reckless activity that could derail our season. He is old enough to know better and is the captain of the ship FFS.

[Demonstone 22,361]

2 hours ago, Lord Nev said:

Classic Melbourne to take it too far.

 Nothing wrong with trying to land a big fish, even it's not trading time yet.

[PaulRB 6,352]

I think that we are in a pretty good spot re-injuries.

We appear to be pushing the boys very hard on the track, but being ultra-conservative (and slow to re-introduce them) if they have injuries or niggles. Of the current injury list, only Preuss is clearly out for part of the season (aside from tyhose injured prior to the pre-season in KK, Bennell and Neitschke. 

My guess all (the TBA) will be back in full training over the next couple of weeks to a month, and if we were in the season proper some of the "injured" players would be working through it to play next week... 

[spirit of norm smith 16,338]

I think we need to get through the preseason with minimal injuries.  Need to get a fit and firing squad for the season start. Gawn, Brayshaw, Tmcd and May are crucial.  All in my top 10 MFC players.  

[Demonland 71,653]

Big Demons forward joins All Australian ruckman in rehab group

Marc McGowan provides the latest update on Melbourne's pre-season injuries ...

IMPORTANT forward Tom McDonald is the latest big-name Demon to join the club's rehab group.

McDonald sported strapping around his left knee and trained away from the main group, alongside All-Australian ruckman Max Gawn, Mitch Hannan, Kade Chandler and Corey Wagner.

It's the same knee he suffered a season-ending meniscus tear on last year, although he shed the strapping as the session continued and he didn't appear overly limited.

	PLAYER	INJURY	LENGTH
	Angus Brayshaw	Elbow	TBA
	Kade Chandler	Wrist	TBA
	Kyle Dunkley	Ankle	TBA
	Max Gawn	Knee	TBA
	Mitch Hannan	Groin	TBA
	Steven May	Knee	TBA
	Tom McDonald	Knee	TBA
	Harrison Petty	Groin	TBA
	Joel Smith	Foot	TBA
	Aaron vandenBerg	Foot	TBA
	Corey Wagner	Knee	TBA
	Braydon Preuss	Knee	7-9 Weeks
	Harley Bennell	Calf	Indefinite
	Kade Kolodjashnij	Head	Indefinite
	Aaron Nietschke	Knee	Season

[Bitter but optimistic 22,223]

Does anyone have any realistic estimates on those listed above as TBA ?

[old dee 23,782]

35 minutes ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

Does anyone have any realistic estimates on those listed above as TBA ?

I doubt the person who made up the list does Bbo so NO.

[Hogan2014 390]

I’m convinced the club is cursed .. could be to hell again ... 

[buck_nekkid 5,848]

It may be also that the pre-season is harder than they have ever done, and a few niggles have emerged.  This time leading into the giggles games is a perfect time to ease people back /modify programs to aid recovery, get players over niggles and set them up for the season proper.  We have being going hard at it, so if we have a few contact and soft tissue injuries and can ease players through, they will have done the hard kms and training, and can now do modified and maintenance work so they can be as near to cherry ripe as possible.  There are some concerns with that list, but not as many as the ‘total number’ suggests.  IF we can get through the piracy games without adding any to the lower end of this list, think I think we will be in a good spot for the season proper.

[Demonstone 22,361]

Should be a slogan, buck:  "Skip the giggles to fix the niggles".

[DeeSpencer 25,530]

During the season we'll often have up to 5 guys who have played the previous week and will play the next week on modified or very light duties. Some who won't even make the injury report. 

4 serious injuries and 11 guys not at their best is too many, but that 11 could quickly resolve down over the next few weeks.

Anyway, we seem to be mastering the train harder aspect, probably plenty of room to look at training smarter. Personally I think if we increase the skills at high intensity without contact earlier in summer we might get less injuries when more contact comes in. Without a great skill level our contact match sim drills are going to end up in plenty of bodies crashing in.