Caleb Serong (Drafted by Fremantle)

[Pennant St Dee 13,190]

4 hours ago, Moonshadow said:

On a phone or ipad, go to the 3 horizontal bars top right of screen, then go to account, then down bottom ignored users, then type on moonsha....... oops, I mean Olisik.

It gives you the option to ignore posts and messages, but not where his post is quoted, unfortunately 

Cheers and done,

[SwissDee 43]

Going off highlights packages and what's been written ....

I picked Serong ahead of Young (in my mind), based on the fact he is touted as a forward. I think we need forwards, while I think out defense, if we don't have the entire back 6 out injured, looks pretty sound. Obviously that's just an opinion.

Just because Young played down back at junior level of course doesn't mean he can't play forward at AFL level.

Honestly though, reading and looking at highlights packages, Young, Serong, Ash, Stephens, Flanders, Green, Robertson ... they're all around the mark I would have thought, they're all around the same size, who knows how they will go next year.

[Its Time for Another 4,225]

23 hours ago, Watts the matter said:

I have no idea what kick you are talking about? When is this in the video?

No wonder. I went back to find it for you. It’s at 48sec. Only problem, on closer inspection it’s actually Weightman not Young. Still a very good kick though. 
My 2 cents worth is the kicking skills of the top 4 in the finals was a clear significant point of difference. And we don’t have it. Young brings it Serong doesn’t. 

[Watts the matter 1,235]

2 hours ago, It's Time said:

No wonder. I went back to find it for you. It’s at 48sec. Only problem, on closer inspection it’s actually Weightman not Young. Still a very good kick though. 
My 2 cents worth is the kicking skills of the top 4 in the finals was a clear significant point of difference. And we don’t have it. Young brings it Serong doesn’t. 

Yeah thought it might have been that one (although personally I think the mark by Serong was much better than the kick in that instance, if 35 didn't fall over it wouldn't have got there).

[dazzledavey36 54,951]

Interesting on SEN this morning Caleb Serong was interviewed. When asked who out of all the coaches had impressed him the most at draft camp he said Simon Goodwin.

Don't think we read too much into it, but i thought that was interesting.

[spirit of norm smith 16,468]

Serong is a good player. Definitely an option at 8 if Kemp and Stephens are gone (Strange JT did not mention him). Better option imo than Weightman as he can play forward and is a proven mid.
 

Serong Would develop as a small forward and then go into midfield after about 2 preseasons in gym and afl fitness. 

[dazzledavey36 54,951]

42 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Serong is a good player. Definitely an option at 8 if Kemp and Stephens are gone (Strange JT did not mention him). Better option imo than Weightman as he can play forward and is a proven mid.
 

Serong Would develop as a small forward and then go into midfield after about 2 preseasons in gym and afl fitness. 

One thing Serong doesn't need is gym work. He's already solidly built. If anything, he has been told that by several clubs that they will trim him down over the pre season so they can start to really expose his midfield talent as well as forward where he will start his career.

[ben russell 764]

Serong racks up disposals, tackles hard, marks the footy well, is excellent by hand but unfortunately he regularly butchers the ball by foot.

I think he will slide a bit due to his poor kicking skills. I hope we don’t pick him at 8.

[Slartibartfast 17,309]

13 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Interesting on SEN this morning Caleb Serong was interviewed. When asked who out of all the coaches had impressed him the most at draft camp he said Simon Goodwin.

Don't think we read too much into it, but i thought that was interesting.

Well I think you're right in terms of who we will select but it says volumes about Goodwin.

I didn't bother opening the thread on Goodwin during the season as I suspected it was full of wrist slashing and irrational criticisms of him.  But I saw enough references in other threads to confirm my suspicions.  But one thing is pretty clear.  Goodwin is an outstanding communicator and representative of our Club.  Whilst I think his pressers are bland and usually say nothing (a frustration to supporters seeking information but probably a skill in itself) he has been front and centre at attracting players and staff to our club.  When interviewed players leaving or joining our Club invariably mention how impressed they are with Goodwin and footy department personnel such as Burgess and Richardson have said similar. He is largely responsible for attracting targetted people to our FD.

I know there will be those who question Goodwin after last year but it's pretty clear from what Burgess said (16 of the 22 who played in the PF had post season surgery) that 2019's performance is mainly the result of fitness and injury to players.  I think Goodwin is a fantastic coach and we are lucky to have him. Next season will tell us a lot but I'm supremely confident.

[dazzledavey36 54,951]

15 minutes ago, Baghdad Bob said:

Well I think you're right in terms of who we will select but it says volumes about Goodwin.

I didn't bother opening the thread on Goodwin during the season as I suspected it was full of wrist slashing and irrational criticisms of him.  But I saw enough references in other threads to confirm my suspicions.  But one thing is pretty clear.  Goodwin is an outstanding communicator and representative of our Club.  Whilst I think his pressers are bland and usually say nothing (a frustration to supporters seeking information but probably a skill in itself) he has been front and centre at attracting players and staff to our club.  When interviewed players leaving or joining our Club invariably mention how impressed they are with Goodwin and footy department personnel such as Burgess and Richardson have said similar. He is largely responsible for attracting targetted people to our FD.

I know there will be those who question Goodwin after last year but it's pretty clear from what Burgess said (16 of the 22 who played in the PF had post season surgery) that 2019's performance is mainly the result of fitness and injury to players.  I think Goodwin is a fantastic coach and we are lucky to have him. Next season will tell us a lot but I'm supremely confident.

I am a Goodwin fan.

The fact that he has been able to play a huge role in bringing in blokes likes of Jordan Lewis, Jake Lever, Steven May, Ed Langdon, Adam Tomlinson and Harley Bennell speaks volume on the guy. Watch the interview with Alan Richardson and he even mention that he was blown away how impressive Goody is with his enthusiasm, dedication and that he was an incredible hard worker.

I have spoken to people in the past who have had dealings with him in the past and all said the same thing in terms of that you couldn't find a more impressive and dedicated individual who has a sense of real care and compassion for his players.

[Pennant St Dee 13,190]

Well said BB & DD, I agree and I'm a Goodwin fan.

Still learning and IMO he would have learnt more about himself and the list this season than in his previous 2

[Mt. Dee-Maaan 608]

strange player.. not too much said about him really. considering he's been thought to go top ten all year, not many talk him up.

 

[DeeSpencer 25,717]

On 11/8/2019 at 10:56 AM, dazzledavey36 said:

I am a Goodwin fan.

The fact that he has been able to play a huge role in bringing in blokes likes of Jordan Lewis, Jake Lever, Steven May, Ed Langdon, Adam Tomlinson and Harley Bennell speaks volume on the guy. Watch the interview with Alan Richardson and he even mention that he was blown away how impressive Goody is with his enthusiasm, dedication and that he was an incredible hard worker.

I have spoken to people in the past who have had dealings with him in the past and all said the same thing in terms of that you couldn't find a more impressive and dedicated individual who has a sense of real care and compassion for his players.

I reckon we'll know by about a month in to the season - even if we are 2-2 or maybe 1-3 - if Goodwin has a future and it will be because he'll finally relax in his media conferences and show a bit more of himself. Do that and I think a lot of views will change. Whether it's humour or anger it's time for passionate, dedicated and a more human Simon Goodwin.

Needs to sit down with the Reverend and have a chat about how he did it. Then if the rest of the club comes with him in a positive and professional way (unlike mid 2000's when it was Daniher covering over the cracks of a decaying club) we'll be on the up.

I know a player drafted by Melbourne who copped some stick from a couple of premiership coaches. The premiership coaches turned out to be right. The interviews and as the American's say 'game recognise game' can be a vital part of the draft process. I wouldn't want every player loving Goody, but I'd love to know who came away with mutual respect.

[Demon Disciple 12,152]

2 hours ago, Rocky said:

strange player.. not too much said about him really. considering he's been thought to go top ten all year, not many talk him up.

 

Would be hilarious if he turns out to be the best pick of the draft in a few years time. Would pretty much signify that everything anyone ever knew about drafting could be thrown out the window, lol

[Engorged Onion 10,215]

3 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

I reckon we'll know by about a month in to the season - even if we are 2-2 or maybe 1-3 - if Goodwin has a future and it will be because he'll finally relax in his media conferences and show a bit more of himself. Do that and I think a lot of views will change. Whether it's humour or anger it's time for passionate, dedicated and a more human Simon Goodwin.

Needs to sit down with the Reverend and have a chat about how he did it. Then if the rest of the club comes with him in a positive and professional way (unlike mid 2000's when it was Daniher covering over the cracks of a decaying club) we'll be on the up.

I know a player drafted by Melbourne who copped some stick from a couple of premiership coaches. The premiership coaches turned out to be right. The interviews and as the American's say 'game recognise game' can be a vital part of the draft process. I wouldn't want every player loving Goody, but I'd love to know who came away with mutual respect.

For the life of me, I cannot see how anyone can  link how Goodwin operates in press conferences - which we ALL know - have very little resemblance to how any coach operates day to day - and how players/staff react to him - and then FURTHER to how he has a future in the game...

They

are

mutually

exclusive 

things.

Edited November 9, 2019 by Engorged Onion

[Fyfelike 0]

Dockers fan here - came across this forum...

Thoughts on Serong now?

[spirit of norm smith 16,468]

On 11/7/2019 at 8:34 PM, spirit of norm smith said:

Serong is a good player. Definitely an option at 8 if Kemp and Stephens are gone (Strange JT did not mention him). Better option imo than Weightman as he can play forward and is a proven mid.
 

Serong Would develop as a small forward and then go into midfield after about 2 preseasons in gym and afl fitness. 

We were on board. Will be a very good player.  He probably may be not able to crack Dees midfield right now so better outcome for him was Freo grabbing him. 

[Pickett2Jackson 3,904]

2 hours ago, Fyfelike said:

Dockers fan here - came across this forum...

Thoughts on Serong now?

Give Jesse Hogan back.

[Bang Bang Bang 5,826]

2 hours ago, Fyfelike said:

Dockers fan here - came across this forum...

Thoughts on Serong now?

Serong looks really good but you won't find any Melbourne fans unhappy with the Luke Jackson selection. 

[Wiseblood 24,637]

2 hours ago, Fyfelike said:

Dockers fan here - came across this forum...

Thoughts on Serong now?

Sure you did, elegt.

[whatwhat say what 22,775]

2 hours ago, Fyfelike said:

Dockers fan here - came across this forum...

Thoughts on Serong now?

looks like becoming a super player

thoughts on jackson, pickett, and rivers?

[4_Kent_Watts 889]

Personally it was my opinion that I would of liked Young and Serong but I guess I was being greedy as that wasn't  possible with the way the draft went. Jackson and Pickett I'm happy with and Rivers looks like he'll be a very handy player. 

[DubDee 25,891]

We could kill for another inside midfielder right now 

[Little Goffy 14,578]

3 hours ago, Fyfelike said:

Dockers fan here - came across this forum...

Thoughts on Serong now?

Of Freo's draftees I would have taken either Young or Henry before Serong.  I think they did very well out of that draft but I also don't think Serong offers much of anything we are short of.

I also happen to have a gut feeling that the Demons have ended up with the best career-span player available at all three of their selections, so I'm not hurting and wish Freo all the best.

[dworship 3,342]

3 hours ago, Fyfelike said:

Dockers fan here - came across this forum...

Thoughts on Serong now?

Ah, a Fremantle supporter with 20/20 hindsight. The foresight aspect at your club is somewhat up for debate.