54 minutes ago, GCDee said:

Langdon, Tomlinson and Elliot would be a huge trade period. 

If Frosty goes we will likely still hold picks in the first and second round to. 

Add Pick 3 whether that's Hayden Young, Sam Flanders or Lachie Ash and it's a huge trade period for us!

Glad we are chasing after Elliot.

Look at the pies list and their imported players treloar, beams, Adams then pendels, Grundy, Steele, Moore, de geoy etc etc

there is no way they have cap space to offer Elliot a decent deal even. He will think of his future and move. Not sure it will be to the demons though

1 minute ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Add Pick 3 whether that's Hayden Young, Sam Flanders or Lachie Ash and it's a huge trade period for us!

Glad we are chasing after Elliot.

I don't know why people think Gold Coast will get pick 2 they have not been on the bottom for long enough they will get a 2nd round priority. It's all they deserve it flies in  the face of the Dees not getting a priority pick when they were terrible a few years ago.

No way Pies can afford him. He'd be looking at a hefty paycut to knock any offers back this year.

This is why you don't pay overs for guys like Frost and Jones.

In arguably career best form and is exactly the type of player we need.

Get it done.

4 minutes ago, WERRIDEE said:

I don't know why people think Gold Coast will get pick 2 they have not been on the bottom for long enough they will get a 2nd round priority. It's all they deserve it flies in  the face of the Dees not getting a priority pick when they were terrible a few years ago.

Us being terrible years ago is irrelevant to the current GC situation. Gill will make sure his love child token club will get fairly compensated unfortunately. 

This gets better.

Ageing and massive hammy history.  Our soft tissue management has been 3rd world.

Billy is a great player, from good stock (Mum) but we have NFI.

Panic merchants.

 

 

 

Would want the opinion of the Richmond doctor before signing him and four years at $600k is a BIG risk.

Garlett would have been on around $400k (guess) so it's a big step up.

2 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Us being terrible years ago is irrelevant to the current GC situation. Gill will make sure his love child token club will get fairly compensated unfortunately. 

I doubt it if he was looking after the Suns properly he never would have Lynch leave and leave a massive hole in their team.

 

I’d like to think we’re still looking at drafting in some small forwards. Always need to have an eye to the future as well as the present.

6 minutes ago, TGR said:

 

Panic merchants.

 

 

 

Are you talking about the club or yourself?

16 minutes ago, praha said:

Are you talking about the club or yourself?

Probably Jordan Lewis in the Preliminary Final in Perth.  Saw it first hand unfortunately.

 

Next.

24 minutes ago, TGR said:

, from good stock (Mum) but we have NFI.

 

 

 

 

Who's his Mum? (Mrs Elliot, I know!, but is she an accomplished sportswoman?

If our offer is 2 years like the pies, doubt he'd move unless the coin is significantly more. If we are offering 4 years compared to two, he might budge.

Still think he'll stay a pie

Had a feeling this was a possibility when the Frost issue arose. 

As stated, Pies have a lot of stars and depth to cover in their salary cap. They barely signed on Langdon (a really good Backman) last year which showed the cap strain they are under.

Be good if there was some incentive based payments to hedge against injury.

Think he is a top class player with footy nous. 

1 minute ago, Jumping Jack Clennett said:

Who's his Mum? (Mrs Elliot, I know!, but is she an accomplished sportswoman?

No.  Good stock doesn't always mean sporting prowess.

3 minutes ago, Jumping Jack Clennett said:

Who's his Mum?

Makybe Diva.

He might not even want to leave Collingwood but I imagine if he did they’d struggle to match any offer we made. Big yes from me.

MFC  has made an offer to Jamie Elliot. Great get if it happens.

Edited September 12, 20195 yr by skills32
correcting text

And we have sooo much luck with ex Collingwood players....

1 minute ago, skills32 said:

MFC is chasing  Jamie Elliot. Great get if it happens.

Missed the already active Jamie Elliot thread?

yes apologies

39 minutes ago, Diamond_Jim said:

Would want the opinion of the Richmond doctor before signing him and four years at $600k is a BIG risk.

Garlett would have been on around $400k (guess) so it's a big step up.

If you want the opinion of a Richmond person, just read the post directly above yours.

 

Yes.

Yes please.

 

 

Now that Garlett is gone we have a need for an injury prone small forward