So there has not been one credible source for this.  Not one newspaper line or ‘rumour’.  Suggest this is tail chasing as self soothing butt hole licking.

 

1 hour ago, R.I.P. Troy said:

[censored] me, here we go again. Hate this time of year.

There would be 17 clubs into him.

He's not going anywhere.

 

I'd say 18 clubs would want his services Troy, don't discount our own

Think someone just made it up

The Offseason is so much better when we're getting Pick 2 and Langdon, as opposed to losing Pick 2, Petracca, and have a split playing group.

(If the playing list is split, the current captains cannot be reappointed. If it is specifically due to Viney, that's just another error by the coaching staff. Turns out this season can get worse..) 

11 hours ago, chookrat said:

I'm with ugottobekiddong on this one. Supporters whingeing that we are hard done by impacts how our club is viewed within the broader AFL community.  Stop being naffs and playing the victim and start looking at what we can do. 

I'm not worried about how we are seen amongst the broader community - supporters opinions do not influence the day to day running of the club, or strategic list management, or winning premierships, etc etc etc etc..

50 minutes ago, Engorged Onion said:

I'm not worried about how we are seen amongst the broader community - supporters opinions do not influence the day to day running of the club, or strategic list management, or winning premierships, etc etc etc etc..

But they do influence the financial strength of the club via memberships, game attendance, buying sponsor's products and buying merchandising.  And # of members is a major determinant of FTA time slots which is important to sponsors to get TV exposure.

Sure, our voice isn't loud but I do feel the club cares what supporters think as they have the 'power of the purse' so to speak and can walk away (and have shown they will) at any time.

Edited August 27, 20195 yr by Lucifer's Hero

Don't tell me we're going to lose Petracca. It'll probably end up being Langdon in and Petracca out. And no better off in the draft. Yeah great MFC.

Just so long as we sign up ANB and JKH and Oscar and Stretch. Yeah well done. Hoorah.

Can we sell some more home games as well so I don't have to turn up anymore.

 

On 8/26/2019 at 10:58 AM, Demon3 said:

Trac wont go, but like lots of things, we have 1 year to sure everything up, the mass exodus may not be this year, but it will be next year if we are still a  basketcase.

 

 

Agreed. If 2020 is a mess, the doors will fly open

I would be more worried about the Pies snatching him than the Cats but let's hope he is happy to at least see out his contract.

Obviously 2020 is looming as a massive year for the entire club.  An improvement is expected but a bigger one would help even more with out of contract negotiations in situations like this one.

In many ways we need to land a big fish (or two!) in the trade and end the year on a strong positive.

A big list cull of NQRs and a few new marquee players coming in might be just the tonic and see us going in to 2020 with a touch more positivity and excitement.

Time to go on a spending spree me thinks.

54 minutes ago, deespicable me said:

Don't tell me we're going to lose Petracca. It'll probably end up being Langdon in and Petracca out. And no better off in the draft. Yeah great MFC.

Just so long as we sign up ANB and JKH and Oscar and Stretch. Yeah well done. Hoorah.

Can we sell some more home games as well so I don't have to turn up anymore.

 

Yep, just like last year where we got rid of Hogan to be replaced by May, who proved to be unfit, and walked around patting ourselves on the back. All while letting half-decent depth players like Kent walk for peanuts in a bid to recruit Wagner's brother. Then thinking KK was a prized recruit we got on the cheap. We have overrated our list, and cleaned out players that were talented in the hope of half-baked spuds like ANB, Wagner and Stretch would cut the mustard at AFL level. 

19 minutes ago, Rusty Nails said:

I would be more worried about the Pies snatching him than the Cats but let's hope he is happy to at least see out his contract.

Obviously 2020 is looming as a massive year for the entire club.  An improvement is expected but a bigger one would help even more with out of contract negotiations in situations like this one.

In many ways we need to land a big fish (or two!) in the trade and end the year on a strong positive.

A big list cull of NQRs and a few new marquee players coming in might be just the tonic and see us going in to 2020 with a touch more positivity and excitement.

Time to go on a spending spree me thinks.

The Pies have no cap room

15 minutes ago, Leoncelli_36 said:

Yep, just like last year where we got rid of Hogan to be replaced by May, who proved to be unfit, and walked around patting ourselves on the back. All while letting half-decent depth players like Kent walk for peanuts in a bid to recruit Wagner's brother. Then thinking KK was a prized recruit we got on the cheap. We have overrated our list, and cleaned out players that were talented in the hope of half-baked spuds like ANB, Wagner and Stretch would cut the mustard at AFL level. 

Two things.

One, Steven May proved when he was fit that he'll be a massive asset in our backline.  True, he could have been more professional in his approach to pre-season training which then hampered his year, but I've seen enough to be convinced that getting him is the right move.

Two, it's not as if Hogan set the world alight at Freo.  His foot looks to be a long term injury concern for him so it's not as if he went and kicked 60 goals for the season.

And Dean Kent did what we all knew he would - play decent footy and then get a long term injury.  Regular as clockwork.

6 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

The Pies have no cap room

That is true D11.  They are in a conundrum with the Grundy deal as it is and the flow on from that likely to hit them elsewhere.

That gives me.more confidence on Tracc staying.  We should also consider the Elliot option and free up our two younger tall forwards if needed to get him and Cameron in for 2020.  Cameron is pie in the sky and not due till next year but it does have a nice ring to it on paper.

F:  Elliot  Cameron  Lockhart/Chandler/?

HF:  Fritschkreig  T-Mac  Melk

Just now, Rusty Nails said:

That is true D11.  They are in a conundrum with the Grundy deal as it is and the flow on from that likely to hit them elsewhere.

That gives me.more confidence on Tracc staying.  We should also consider the Elliot option and free up our two younger tall forwards if needed to get him and Cameron in for 2020.  Cameron is pie in the sky and not due till next year but it does have a nice ring to it on paper.

F:  Elliot  Cameron  Lockhart/Chandler/?

HF:  Fritschkreig  T-Mac  Melk

If we get Jeremy Cameron to the club then I'll change my avatar to a pic of Saty for an entire year. 

4 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

If we get Jeremy Cameron to the club then I'll change my avatar to a pic of Saty for an entire year. 

And continually deny our players had an interrupted pre-season due to injuries. 

1 minute ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

And continually deny our players had an interrupted pre-season due to injuries. 

I'll change my username to this as well:

NoPreasonInjuries

I think Tracc will stay but not because pies have no cap room - they lose Wells this year who was reportedly on $600k p.a.  They also lose lesser players like Dunne.  

So will have the cap space to target players and they repeatedly get players without paying a premium.

Tracc comes out of contract next year so if he is unhappy and puts off contract talks then it might be a different story.

11 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

If we get Jeremy Cameron to the club then I'll change my avatar to a pic of Saty for an entire year. 

I was a tad hesitant at first Wise ... but why not.  Anything for Cameron!

 

38 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Two things.

One, Steven May proved when he was fit that he'll be a massive asset in our backline.  True, he could have been more professional in his approach to pre-season training which then hampered his year, but I've seen enough to be convinced that getting him is the right move.

Two, it's not as if Hogan set the world alight at Freo.  His foot looks to be a long term injury concern for him so it's not as if he went and kicked 60 goals for the season.

And Dean Kent did what we all knew he would - play decent footy and then get a long term injury.  Regular as clockwork.

There is a lot to play out here, but it's looking like a disaster.

I agree he looked good when he played but......

Firstly, he gave us very little this season and would have been a free agent now, Collingwood got Jordan Roughead for nothing and have got more out of him this season. 

Secondly, if we don't bounce back and compete for a flag next season, it is a disaster. If he is a good player and we don't make finals it's a bad trade even if he wins our best and fairest. He is/will be 28. He should be in his prime and we need to be competing. 

We didn't just give up Hogan, we gave up Bailey Smith or Ben King to get him. Both look like outstanding prospects so that is what he will be compared to unless the team is competing for a premiership.

 

1 minute ago, Watts the matter said:

There is a lot to play out here, but it's looking like a disaster.

I agree he looked good when he played but......

Firstly, he gave us very little this season and would have been a free agent now, Collingwood got Jordan Roughead for nothing and have got more out of him this season. 

Secondly, if we don't bounce back and compete for a flag next season, it is a disaster. If he is a good player and we don't make finals it's a bad trade even if he wins our best and fairest. He is/will be 28. He should be in his prime and we need to be competing. 

We didn't just give up Hogan, we gave up Bailey Smith or Ben King to get him. Both look like outstanding prospects so that is what he will be compared to unless the team is competing for a premiership.

 

A lot of 'what ifs' for something you claim is 'looking like a disaster'.

Plenty to play out here and I'm just going by this year.  Anything can happen in the ensuing years.  We can argue that point after it's happened.

Just now, Wiseblood said:

A lot of 'what ifs' for something you claim is 'looking like a disaster'.

Plenty to play out here and I'm just going by this year.  Anything can happen in the ensuing years.  We can argue that point after it's happened.

I agree, at the time of the trade, I didn't know how I felt about it and am still unsure.

I like May as a player, but we gave up a lot to get him.

I don't see how after finishing 17th and the season he had you could call it anything but a disaster. 

If he was to win our next 3 best and fairest's and we don't make the finals in any of those seasons would you call that a successful trade?

Have you seen Bailey Smith play?

15 hours ago, buck_nekkid said:

So there has not been one credible source for this.  Not one newspaper line or ‘rumour’.  Suggest this is tail chasing as self soothing butt hole licking.

 

Yep- when’s this story going to break in the 24 hour AFL news cycle that’s starving for news..?

Christian Petracca meeting with Geelong and Collingwood worthy of a tweet, article, thread on BigFooty..?  

so nothing but BS rumours on Trac leaving then?

good.

If there areTrade Brayshaw and Trade Viney threads then there can be a Trade Petracca thread. 

Just depends on whether you believe he’s genuinely going to get any better or not. Purely statistically he is treading water season upon season:

https://finalsiren.com/PlayerStats.asp?PlayerID=2626

Those are average numbers. Disappointing really for a number 2 draft pick after his fifth season.

I’ve seen cases made where some of our supporters put him in the top ten forwards in the competition, which is plainly ridiculous. From my vantage point he’s a player who continues to operate off the unearned hype of media adulation, a player with serious flaws (especially with his kicking action) which may never correct themselves. 

I say sell now while he still has value. We’d get a pick from 8 - 15 for him which we could use on a classy outside runner ... or maybe even young Fischer McAsey to bolster our key forward stocks.

Something has always been a bit off key about Petracca IMO. Work ethic, attitude, drive to succeed ... can’t quite put my finger on it but something has never quite sit right looking on.

41 minutes ago, GetJonnoPatton said:

If there areTrade Brayshaw and Trade Viney threads then there can be a Trade Petracca thread. 

Just depends on whether you believe he’s genuinely going to get any better or not. Purely statistically he is treading water season upon season:

https://finalsiren.com/PlayerStats.asp?PlayerID=2626

Those are average numbers. Disappointing really for a number 2 draft pick after his fifth season.

I’ve seen cases made where some of our supporters put him in the top ten forwards in the competition, which is plainly ridiculous. From my vantage point he’s a player who continues to operate off the unearned hype of media adulation, a player with serious flaws (especially with his kicking action) which may never correct themselves. 

I say sell now while he still has value. We’d get a pick from 8 - 15 for him which we could use on a classy outside runner ... or maybe even young Fischer McAsey to bolster our key forward stocks.

Something has always been a bit off key about Petracca IMO. Work ethic, attitude, drive to succeed ... can’t quite put my finger on it but something has never quite sit right looking on.

i think it is quite simple - he doesn't have the tank to play 4 quarters. If he wants midfield time that will need to change.