BACK to Petracca, I’d be furious if we let him got for a lousy 2nd round pick in a weak draft. He has talent. We need to harness it. If he goes , I want a ready made player in return. Certainly nothing tied in with Langdon. Track will finish top5 in our bnf and is contracted 

Edited August 25, 20196 yr by Leoncelli_36

2 minutes ago, Leoncelli_36 said:

BACK to Petracca, I’d be furious if we let him got for a lousy 2nd round pick in a weak draft.

Not going to happen

Just now, drysdale demon said:

Not going to happen

We have a track record of being bent over though 

1 hour ago, Lord Nev said:

It's not about what we (the club) want, it's about what Petracca wants. People need to start opening their eyes to what's potentially happening at the club right now.

Just for the record, Geelong refused to trade Kelly last year because he was contracted and couldn't get the trade value they wanted. 

Just now, Leoncelli_36 said:

We have a track record of being bent over though 

Believe what you want to

8 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

 

Click on his moniker to go to his profile page and then click on 'see their activity' on the right side of the page and the story will unfold.

Ok I did that, and I guess the premise Leoncelli 36 presents is plausible. I have no insight to his rating within the club for his captaincy, but do with his public persona. He is uninspiring and of limited intellectual capacity; embarrassing. I can only imagine what the likes of Tom McDonald think

5 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

Just for the record, Geelong refused to trade Kelly last year because he was contracted and couldn't get the trade value they wanted. 

Yeah for sure, but what's happening this year now?...

4 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

Just for the record, Geelong refused to trade Kelly last year because he was contracted and couldn't get the trade value they wanted. 

And thats with go home factor. Josh Mahoney would laugh in CP5's managers face if he said that Patty has offered to take CP5 fishing in Moggs Creek and while he's nether been there it sounds pretty cool. 

26 minutes ago, DemonOX said:

I have no contacts connected to the club but I appreciate the comments from posters who do. 

It is up to each of us if we believe them or not and time will tell if they are right. 

Imo where there’s smoke there is fire. 

Is there smoke though..? 

Christian Petracca supposedly met, in person, with the Geelong staff and players, in August... and nothing leaked in the media at all..?  Not even a twitter post from a shady journo. 

When Boak met with them (the comparison made in the OP), it was proclaimed left right and center all over the media.  

 

9 minutes ago, Lord Nev said:

Yeah for sure, but what's happening this year now?...

Agree it is rare for a club to not give in to a player.  Geelong/Kelly was an example of the exception. 

Sure their refusal was only good for a year so the end result is the same.

Edited August 25, 20196 yr by Lucifer's Hero

1 minute ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

Was just referring to the comment that it is what the player wants that counts.  Agree it is rare for a club to not give in to a player.  Geelong/Kelly was an example of the exception.

Yeah, there's still the odd occasion a contracted player stays. The Kelly one didn't really feel like they held him against his well and it was ugly or anything though. Not like the McCarthy one. Just seems like players (and their agents) have all the power now.

9 minutes ago, TeamPlayedFine39 said:

Is there smoke though..? 

Christian Petracca supposedly met, in person, with the Geelong staff and players, in August... and nothing leaked in the media at all..?  Not even a twitter post from a shady journo. 

When Boak met with them (the comparison made in the OP), it was proclaimed left right and center all over the media.  

It's BS.  

No doubt Trac met with the club, and I see no problem with that, but the bloke aint going anywhere.

Seeing as club will be parting ways with Brayshaw and Hunt, I would imagine they would be working extremely hard to keep other young stars happy.

2 hours ago, TeamPlayedFine39 said:

People perhaps getting a little carried away here... the OP is hardly full of detail or citing sources.

Can't believe it took 38 responses for this 

7 minutes ago, praha said:

Seeing as club will be parting ways with Brayshaw and Hunt, I would imagine they would be working extremely hard to keep other young stars happy.

????

1 hour ago, Lord Nev said:

To be honest, I don't ask if they're breaking confidence by telling me things. I don't post everything I hear though and sometimes I'm asked to not pass particular things on and I don't.

I understand you not believing me. I have no problem with that as I would be exactly the same. We'll just go round in circles though with this. Just decide you don't believe me and I'll be ok with that.

Are you Saty 2.0?

11 minutes ago, praha said:

Seeing as club will be parting ways with Brayshaw and Hunt, I would imagine they would be working extremely hard to keep other young stars happy.

Bold predictions or one too many raspberry cordials, praha?

27 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Bold predictions or one too many raspberry cordials, praha?

why not both?

So my sister just texted me to say the Facebook pages are saying Petracca and Salem have asked to be traded. Am I a bit slow on the uptake here?

4 minutes ago, A F said:

So my sister just texted me to say the Facebook pages are saying Petracca and Salem have asked to be traded. ?Am I a bit slow on the uptake here?

???????

OMG I hope the club sorts this crap out!!!

Both are contracted so I'd be saying no trade.

I'd be very surprised if they were both asking to be traded.

 

We've got a year to sort ourselves out.

10 minutes ago, A F said:

So my sister just texted me to say the Facebook pages are saying Petracca and Salem have asked to be traded. Am I a bit slow on the uptake here?

That Kelly trade by Roos is looking better by the day!!!

1 hour ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

 

Click on his moniker to go to his profile page and then click on 'see their activity' on the right side of the page and the story will unfold.

So if JV remains in a Captaincy role next year, we are going to have a fully fractured playing group next year.

Will the Club be strong enough to make the big moves....?