Changes: Rd 05 v St. Kilda

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

1 hour ago, poita said:

Of the fringe players Hore was good and Stretch okay. Spargo's 7 touches were very good, but 7 touches and 1 tackle is not nearly enough of a contribution. C.Wagner was quiet and his brother is still ordinary.

Depending on who is available I'd be replacing Spargo first, followed by J.Wagner and C.Wagner in that order. 

Having said that I'm not sure I'd be playing either Jetta or Lewis against St Kilda. If the current side can't beat St Kilda they should give up. Save those guys for Richmond, rather than expecting them to back up 4 days later.

Wouldn't have seen him out there last night except for the Lockhart late withdrawal Poita.  Coming back from a broaken jaw also.  Looked sharp early before fading....match fitness?  Needs a few games under his belt i reckon.

Edited April 12, 2019 by Rusty Nails

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

1 hour ago, SPC said:

How did people see Weids performance? He seems to struggle for fitness, arrives late to contests. 

One of only a handful of players to improve their output on last year IMO.  Given the ugliness of the first 3 weeks and his lack of experience that's not too shabby.   Would just like to see him start standing up and impacting games when things aren't going our way during matches, like the first quarter last night (against the tide if you like), vs going ok and better when the team's picked their game up and more players are on and performing.

[Red and Blue realist 2,051]

Got to remember with the changes that after the Saints we play the Tigs 4 days later, so while we have the bigger break now I wouldn't be expecting anyone who's had an injuries (Lewis, Jetta and May) to play both. So it might just be forced changes then look at bringing them and guys like Lockart, Garlett etc. in fresh for the Tigs.

Edited April 12, 2019 by Red and Blue realist

[What 18,810]

2 minutes ago, Red and Blue realist said:

Got to remember with the changes that after the Saints we play the Tigs 4 days later

And thats why I want Lewis to come back for the Tigers game.

[deebug 1,754]

3 hours ago, Redleg said:

Did you notice Bruce gushing over the Swans and actually barracking for them?

Tripple M was also willing the swans on. 

It really p*##&^ me off

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,842]

2 hours ago, SPC said:

How did people see Weids performance? He seems to struggle for fitness, arrives late to contests. 

Excellent last quarter. 

His 52 metre goal was a massive steadier. His set shots for goal have become elite. 

[Red and Blue realist 2,051]

2 minutes ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Excellent last quarter. 

His 52 metre goal was a massive steadier. His set shots for goal have become elite. 

Plus the aggressive tackles, at one point I thought it Viney going for the ball but it was Weid bent over. The goals will come, but efforts like those will turn him into a really good player.

[Red and Blue realist 2,051]

25 minutes ago, Petraccattack said:

And thats why I want Lewis to come back for the Tigers game.

Yeah, I'd hold off on Lewis for the Tigs game, and also bring in one or both of Garlett and Lockhart to give us some real spark for that game. 

[SPC 3,549]

29 minutes ago, deebug said:

Tripple M was also willing the swans on. 

It really p*##&^ me off

Listened to them for 15 minutes before switching to SEN. 

[Guest]

The barracking stuff was two pronged @Redleg

Part of it was probably the old Kerry Packer maxim: 'Don't talk the game down.' The second part was that it would create a talking point if we lost about how 'easy we are to score against' and our 'mental fragility'. These two canards are well worn,  require little original thought but allow Lingy to come on air and tsk tsk us while sounding like he is knowledgeable.

For a win, there will be a few changes for mine as I can still see a few holes. There was improvement but a bit to work on.

In: Lockhart, Petty

Out: Spargo, OMac (concussed or not)

I could put Jeffy in but his Casey form is important for mine. That being said Preuss hadn't set the world on fire out there and he was bloody important last night to the win. However, Lockhart had earned his spot over the two weeks he was in so he stays in.

Spargo actually has a bloody good football brain and rarely makes a mistake with ball in hand but just can't get his hands on the thing. OMac needs to think about how badly he wants that spot in the backline because with May and Lever coming back, he won't be a walk in 22 member if he puts in pea hearted efforts like he did last night.

[Smokey 4,389]

9 minutes ago, Hillary Bray said:

OMac needs to think about how badly he wants that spot in the backline because with May and Lever coming back, he won't be a walk in 22 member if he puts in pea hearted efforts like he did last night.

I reckon the impending return of these players this year is already in his head, and perhaps he doesn't have the mental resiliency to keep putting in 100% knowing he doesn't get a game with May and Lever fully fit. I think Frost has gone past Omac comfortably this year, and that says plenty. And its not even a skill or ability thing, Frost is as prone as anyone to making blues but his athleticism sets him apart from Omac when they both have reasonably similar outputs otherwise. 

Having said that, we see the game a certain way and the coaches probably another. They are the ones with the intimate knowledge of the game plan, so maybe we are looking at the wrong metrics in assessing Omac. Long bow but still worth considering. 

[deebug 1,754]

5 hours ago, SPC said:

Listened to them for 15 minutes before switching to SEN. 

Good idea?

[Dame Gaga 2,453]

9 hours ago, whatwhatsaywhat said:

it's always hard to tell when the camerawork and the commentary are bad in unison

We needed Daisy on the boundary line to keep us informed on what was actually happening in the game and what the injuries were.

[WERRIDEE 5,479]

No change make Lewis and Jetta play in the 2's

[spirit of norm smith 16,462]

Ins. four quarter footy

outs. Oscar McDonald PLEASE !!!!!

[DeeSpencer 25,713]

A very difficult selection. Hard to balance the desire to reward the guys who did the job with the reality that last nights side is far from perfect.

Jetta straight back in if he's fit. Which defender makes way? J Wags?Oscar?  Hore? Does Hibberd come under big scrutiny? 

Does Lewis back mean Fritsch moves to a wing, maybe play C Wagner at half forward/mid and cover the likely absence of Preuss. 

Or do we bring in another taller target to keep the 3 tall structure? T Smith or Keilty?

[John Demonic 5,797]

6 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

No change make Lewis and Jetta play in the 2's

While I think Lewis deserves to be straight in due to his experience in aiding structure on the G, I too question whether Jetta should come straight back in given he was out of form in the first 3 games and I read somewhere he was losing 50% contests. There should be no favourites. Good call.

Edit: Having said that we might need him to play on Gresham as he's a gun and Jets might thrive on locking down a quality small fwd.

Edited April 12, 2019 by John Demonic

[FireInTheBennelly 4,072]

I thought Stretch was ok, and showed he was up to the level in a few contests where he would've been forgiven for coughing it up. Hoping he gets a good run at it for at least a month.

[dazzledavey36 54,947]

4 hours ago, FireInTheBelly said:

I thought Stretch was ok, and showed he was up to the level in a few contests where he would've been forgiven for coughing it up. Hoping he gets a good run at it for at least a month.

Me too, i would love Goodwin to give him a good block of 4 to 6 weeks of game time. I remember years ago against Hawthorn he did a real good shut down job on Brad Hill and completely took him out of the game. I wonder if that could be a role for him where he negates their quick outside players.

[What 18,810]

12 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

No change make Lewis and Jetta play in the 2's

Jetta will play if fit.  Hes a star and the rest will have helped him.  Like most of the team he looked underdone the first few weeks.

[Nasher 33,616]

12 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

No change make Lewis and Jetta play in the 2's

 

5 hours ago, John Demonic said:

While I think Lewis deserves to be straight in due to his experience in aiding structure on the G, I too question whether Jetta should come straight back in given he was out of form in the first 3 games and I read somewhere he was losing 50% contests. There should be no favourites. Good call.

Edit: Having said that we might need him to play on Gresham as he's a gun and Jets might thrive on locking down a quality small fwd.

Jetta was injured, hence the form.

Surely it’s beyond question that a non-injured Jetta plays seniors. I can’t see any sensible scenario where Jetta plays at Casey.

[dazzledavey36 54,947]

3 minutes ago, Nasher said:

 

Jetta was injured, hence the form.

Surely it’s beyond question that a non-injured Jetta plays seniors. I can’t see any sensible scenario where Jetta plays at Casey.

Nasher, you shouldnt have to explain yourself in regards to Jetta. But i also understand why you had to.. ?‍♂️

Jetta is simply locked and loaded in our best 22. He is also our Vice captain and when on song he's one of our best one on one defenders. St Kilda forwards have a mix of small forwards that run through there, Billings Lonie Gresham etc. Gresham is the one i want Jetta locking down on.

[58er 6,453]

9 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Nasher, you shouldnt have to explain yourself in regards to Jetta. But i also understand why you had to.. ?‍♂️

Jetta is simply locked and loaded in our best 22. He is also our Vice captain and when on song he's one of our best one on one defenders. St Kilda forwards have a mix of small forwards that run through there, Billings Lonie Gresham etc. Gresham is the one i want Jetta locking down on.

While the Jetta (if fit) argument for selection seems simple the fact that we play Saints on Sat and Tigers on Wed (Anzac Eve) with only a four day break I am not sure that  it will be wise for either Lewis or Nev to play both from a fitness angle. 

I would like them both to play but we must be conservative with our team selection to maintain our list in good health.

Let's welcome both back but I am confident that Marty Hore stood up well and that's encouraging.

Oscar with a nine  day break should overcome concussion if form warrants his selection.

Jonesy might also be managed for time during this period as will Braydon in the ruck if he recovers also from his shoulder injury.

Most others will need to play in both games providing they pull up without any minor aches pains or tears.

Our Medicos inc Dave Mission  have some  interesting and challenging selections along with the Match Committee for Rounds 5 and 6.

Good luck guys.

[dazzledavey36 54,947]

25 minutes ago, 58er said:

While the Jetta (if fit) argument for selection seems simple the fact that we play Saints on Sat and Tigers on Wed (Anzac Eve) with only a four day break I am not sure that  it will be wise for either Lewis or Nev to play both from a fitness angle. 

I would like them both to play but we must be conservative with our team selection to maintain our list in good health.

Let's welcome both back but I am confident that Marty Hore stood up well and that's encouraging.

Oscar with a nine  day break should overcome concussion if form warrants his selection.

Jonesy might also be managed for time during this period as will Braydon in the ruck if he recovers also from his shoulder injury.

Most others will need to play in both games providing they pull up without any minor aches pains or tears.

Our Medicos inc Dave Mission  have some  interesting and challenging selections along with the Match Committee for Rounds 5 and 6.

Good luck guys.

Agree in regards to the short turn around. If Jetta needs time to get his knee sorted then i would be happy enough for him to come back against Richmond. The recovery process from St Kila to richmond might be too risky also considering if he has lingering knee issues.

[DeezNuts 624]

I’d drop Hibberd, he needs a rest. OMAC can be removed.