Post Match Discussion - Round 12

[beelzebub 23,313]

Well.. missed the whole thing... could only grabs scores from time to time.

Fell in a hole.

Much work still ahead. 

A few of the cocky might want to adjust their glasses.

Judging by the scores..and albeitly that all i have...they towelled us 

A wake up reality check.... we're far from 'there' yet.

Hopefully better after a rest.

 

 

[loges 6,767]

2 minutes ago, olisik said:

He deliberately falls over when his tired so he can have a breather.

Cut off so many of their attacks, hate to see what we'd have lost by if he wasn't playing.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,197]

1 hour ago, Wiseblood said:

I reckon the loss of Lever hurt more than we realise, and goes back to what Goodwin was saying earlier in the year.

It took a month or so for Lever to settle, find his groove and play great footy.  Now that our most important defender has gone down for the year you would expect it to take a month or so for us to find the best way of covering for him going forward.  I thought Joel Smith had a real dip and earned another crack in a fortnight, but our structures were back to what we saw in the first 4-5 weeks.  

Tightening this up and finding a way around Lever will take a little time, hopefully as little as possible.

I thought that was the least of our concerns. We were flat footed and behind all day, got smashed in the middle and got hunted around the packs. Our delivery forward was shocking, back to the long kicks down the line albeit not as bad as the Richmond game.

[DeeZee 7,363]

Viney and Petracca both look like they need another preseason.

Also thought Goodwin was out coached again today

[At Least I Saw a Flag 5,222]

Thank God Oxley wasn't playing for the filth today.

I still have nightmares about that match ...

[Skin Deeamond 339]

Dog vomit performance

[Clintosaurus 7,838]

It was almost like no one at the club thought Collingwood might try and stop us playing like we did the did the last 6 weeks.

[Gorgoroth 12,924]

Big game lost again, over handballing again. Leaders were poor in a loss.. again.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

2 minutes ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

I thought that was the least of our concerns. We were flat footed and behind all day, got smashed in the middle and got hunted around the packs. Our delivery forward was shocking, back to the long kicks down the line albeit not as bad as the Richmond game.

I can't argue with any of that, Doc.  Their pressure and our unwillingness to work super hard at getting ourselves back in the contest was hard to watch at times today.  I reckon they would have had at least 20 intercept marks during the game, many of them from quick kicks out of a contest.  It wasn't good enough.

[jumbo returns 6,740]

The ball should never have landed in Cox's hands so easily

Midfield was hammered

[Skin Deeamond 339]

The worst ever.

we have a good team.

they are also rans

we packed up and went home.

drop dead demons

[Soidee 1,496]

Our game style is rubbish at the G!  No speed to cover fast teams.  Not a happy place to go to watch our team at our home ground.  

[binman 42,691]

1 hour ago, rjay said:

@binman

Still think Collingwood are no good?

Couldn't watch the game today as my son was playing in a basketball tournament in Ballarat. On the way to winning their grand final they beat Collingwood in the semis. Took it as a good omen

Was planning on watching the game 'as live' tomorrow before work. Had made it very clear to my son that if learnt the result whilst tooling around on his phone not to make any comment. At all.

Whilst stuck in a massive traffic jam outside of Ballan i heard him say 'oh no'. When asked 'oh no' what he gave some lame answer. I correctly assumed we had lost.

Just watched the highlights. Doubt i will watch the replay. 

I hope i was wrong about Collingwood being no good.  

Edited June 11, 2018 by binman

[—coach— 3,496]

28 minutes ago, Skuit said:

I forgot the rule where you can only ever learn from a lesson once. We got outplayed in the middle. We played in a finals-like atmosphere. We struggled with spread again at the MCG. I believe we will learn from the loss. 

We also said that after the Hawthorn then Richmond games. So I guess we can look forward to learning the same lesson over and over again for many years to come. The future is bright!

[Elegt 872]

1 hour ago, leave it to deever said:

Bet Dunn is laughing.

he slaughtered Hogan. whoever got rid of him should be shot. would fill the lever role well and he burnt off Hannan

[Forest Demon 4,681]

Seem to be a mixed reaction at Joel Smith's game, but I personally liked what I saw.

When you think he has only played a couple of games, I think we need to leave him in for at least a month.

He has a lot of the right tools, and I could see him being an important player come the end of theaeason if we are still in the mix.

 

[John Crow Batty 8,862]

Though it was almost a repeat of R23, this game was more like round 15 when we were smashed by the Swans after winning four in a row. We were quite listless after that. Hopefully the bye will help us this time to regroup. 

[Skin Deeamond 339]

1 minute ago, Forest Demon said:

Seem to be a mixed reaction at Joel Smith's game, but I personally liked what I saw.

When you think he has only played a couple of games, I think we need to leave him in for at least a month.

He has a lot of the right tools, and I could see him being an important player come the end of theaeason if we are still in the mix.

 

He was useless

[Adam The God 30,135]

2 hours ago, DeeZee said:

Backline fell apart without Lever today.

Backline fell apart because our midfield and half forward line fell apart. I thought the defenders battled relatively well. Joel Smith struggled in the first half, but grew into the game. Great spoil in the last. His spoil and then follow up tackle early on was good too.

2 hours ago, Hogan2014 said:

I think you may want to direct the attention to our mids centre clearances 10-18!

The around the ground clearances were worse. 16-27! You don't win games of footy with our attacking press system, when you lose the clearances that badly.

2 hours ago, Dockett 32 said:

Very quiet on the train. We were two short with Peterson and Spargo ( kid playing against men. Strange selection in clutch game)

Oliver ok. Viney and Jones totally pantsed by DeGoey, Trelor and Sidebottom.

When are we going to recruit an outside runner like one of the Collingwood blokes?

Our midfield does ok against the bottom 8. Against the top liners - Leadership normally disappears after that. I think they know their limitations.

In Tyson, Stretch, Hunt, Garlett, JKH comes into it too, maybe also the ginger nut and one of Keilty or Petty.

Jones and Viney cannot be in the centre at the same time awful. Slow, slow,slow.

Out Pedo, Harms, Bernie, Spargo, Harmes ,

Melksham.

Hogans attititude and performance????

Do we keep him or do some serious trading for Lynch?

Tommy Mac a shining light, Max tried hard Fritch tried.

Wow. There's some stuff I agree with and then there's this... the bloke was second for the Coleman coming into this game, playing midfield and forward. He's a star. He had a down day, but he'll bounce back.

You're suggesting Viney and Jones are too slow for the middle, but your replacement is Tyson?

I think we might go Jeffy and Hunt next, as we need some outside run, but I wouldn't say Viney is slow. And given Port's slowish midfield, we might reset with the same midfield and not go Jeffy or Hunt at all.

Rest is needed to reassess and then we go again in Port.

Edited June 11, 2018 by A F

[Forest Demon 4,681]

5 minutes ago, Elegt said:

he slaughtered Hogan. whoever got rid of him should be shot. would fill the lever role well and he burnt off Hannan

He was great today. We put all our eggs in the OMac basket and it has actually been going ok up until today.

[Gorgoroth 12,924]

We have 10 more games to win 5+ and make finals.

Goodwin and co have two weeks to come up with another clearance plan as the bullies and pies have slaughtered us and worked out what we were doing.

Also a rocket needs to be fired up the leaders. When games are not going our way or their own personal way they revert back to little give and gets. It’s poor. And ffs cane some one get Viney better boots, he fell over that many times today I thought he was Lewis.

[Forest Demon 4,681]

2 minutes ago, Stormy Dee said:

He was useless

Disagree. Defence was under siege and he showed really good cloaing speed and took a couple of good grabs.

[olisik 4,060]

7 minutes ago, Elegt said:

he slaughtered Hogan. whoever got rid of him should be shot. would fill the lever role well and he burnt off Hannan

Can say the same about Howe. We give him up for chips then trade 2 first rounders for a similair player with a bung knee.

[Gorgoroth 12,924]

Can’t blame the backs, if you watch every kick in they did, it was like Moses parting the Red Sea. 

Our forwards pressure did not exist.

[Lucifers Hero 39,612]

I think the view is different at the ground than on tv.  What I saw at the ground:

• We were absolutely smashed in the first quarter - the ball was in our forward 50 for about 5 minutes. 
• They kicked a lot of points and we could not get it out past the centre.  That was all lack of work rate.
• There were numerous times when some of our players were free for the switch that never came so when the kicks went down the line we were always outnumbered. 
• The down the line kick out of defence was too predictable - nearly always on the members side - just like the Richmond game.
• They won the 50/50 ball nearly all day.
• Lewis did a fine job of marshalling the backline so in that respect we didn't miss Lever so much.
• Some players were downright lazy. 
• More than half our team failed to have any impact at all for the whole game.  Some may have good stats but they were of little value.
• There was very little movement to give the ball carrier options.
• Our defence pushed up the ground too high again - just like the games we lost early in the season.  Their forward half was a paddock that they found easy to find space in.

The coaching may not have been up to scratch but that isn't the reason we lost by 7 goals.  That is a big margin and I think the players are the ones primarily responsible for it being so high.

Edited June 11, 2018 by Lucifer's Hero